I received the Moto X Play today.
It's good, but coming from a Nexus 5 there's some aspects that are a clear downgrade. Others are a clear upgrade, however.
Firstly, the screen gets brighter than the Nexus 5 and looks just as good. I don't notice the downgrade in PPI at all. There is a vivid colour mode that's enabled by default, which leads to slightly more saturated colours than the Nexus 5.
The speaker is a clear improvement over the Nexus 5. Better in every single regard. Loudness, clarity, bass... everything. No contest.
The build feels nice and solid. Comfortable to hold in the hand. Dust can become trapped around the edges of the glass screen though and the buttons feel cheap as they rattle audibly if tapped - they are fairly loose fitting compared to the Nexus 5. However, haptic feedback feels better than the Nexus 5 and isn't as noisy.
The phone is slower than the Nexus 5. Animations aren't quite as smooth and there's usually a bit more stutter. It's not massive difference, but it's immediately noticeable with both side by side. GPU performance, while again worse than the Nexus 5, can still allow for flawless playback of games such as Smash Hit (high settings), Sleepy Jack and Jelly Defense. I have tested all of my live wallpapers and they run fine too.
Camera is definitely better than the Nexus 5 in daylight. It loses this massive advantage in low light though but still manages to outperform the Nexus 5, despite the lack of OIS which is impressive. I shall upload samples soon.
The lack of a gyroscope is a disappointing omission. The Nexus 5 has this and this means that the Moto X Play lacks the ability to take photo sphere and panoramic shots in the Google camera app.
Battery is a clear upgrade over the Nexus 5. Currently at 78% and my screen has been on for 2h 11m so far - a large section of that was benchmarking using 3DMark with screen brightness at 50% (adaptive enabled). So first impressions of the battery are very good indeed. Will need longer to fully establish just how much of an improvement it is.
That concludes my first impressions. I like the phone. It's great in many regards, but there are some noticeable compromises that makes it feel less of a bargain than the Nexus 5 was back in 2013. I am happy with it overall, but I suspect I shall jump ship to the new LG Nexus once that is released.
I'll post more once I've had a bit more time with the phone.