Opty 165 rules.
I owned an X2 3800 and could barely squeeze 2.6Ghz out of it. That was pushing 1.5v and the X2 chip freaked out over 50C.
The Opty 165 goes much further on far less volts, and seems to handle higher temps without as much fuss. I can load it at 62C for hours and not throw errors. The X2 3800 would start throwing errors any time it broke 55C.
Of course, the stepping is going to make a huge difference, but there seem to be a lot more good stepping Optys than X2s.