• We should now be fully online following an overnight outage. Apologies for any inconvenience, we do not expect there to be any further issues.

Netbook hard drives

damocles

Diamond Member
Oct 9, 1999
5,105
5
81
I am looking at getting a netbook. Probably a Dell Mini with a SSD drive. Reading the net, I see confusing reports on what is more reliable (standard drives or normal drives).

On my past laptops I have need had issues with standard drives but I like the idea that an SSD is a bit more shockproof.

How well will current (MLC) SSDs last?

Cheers
 

Krynj

Platinum Member
Jun 21, 2006
2,816
8
81
IMO, some SSD drives are clearly better performers, but right now, they do not justify the cost. They're more likely to withstand drops and other shocks, but, other parts in a laptop aren't as reliable as an SSD drive. A drop/jolt with enough force to botch an HDD is probably going to spell disaster with some of the other laptop components, the screen being a large factor. SSD owners right now are considered early adopters. "Early adopter" is often times a nice way to say "beta tester". There's lower power consumption, which will boost a laptop battery's life, and that's always a plus. But most competitively priced (read: under $150) drives will come with very low read/write times. So if that's an even trade off for you, it sounds like you've got to decide how much you want to spend.

I have an Asus EEE PC 1000HE that can last up to about 8 hours with a regular 160GB notebook HDD in it. I can easily pick it up, fold the screen, and put it under my arm to move to another room while it's still on. As soon as I have to fold it up and put it in my back pack, it's as simple as putting it into standby, and tossing it in my backpack.

I personally won't buy an SSD for a couple years. For casual users, it's simply not worth it. It's new fangled technology that always yields a lofty price tag. Give it time, the SSD market will become very competitive, at which time, us consumers can cash in.
 

damocles

Diamond Member
Oct 9, 1999
5,105
5
81
Good points, thanks. The main aim of my netbook will be for light travel, reading in cafes etc.

I am looking at Dell Mini 9 which only comes with the 16GB SSD (Dell is good for me as the warranty cover works where I travel, Asus is also good though).

If the drive lasted me two years, I guess i would be reasonably happy if I could swap in a newer one (not sure if that will be feasible).