wow u guys are no help at all. lol
unfortunately neither am i... although I do have 2 sisters who have been dating awhile, their boyfriends give them sort of odd presents.
One of them gave my sister a michael jordan poster. He gave her a vince carter poster the year before (i think these were just anniversaries, not birthdays). For some odd reason she doesn't even like the raptors or wizards, let alone know what city those teams play in. I think last time she asked "how many home runs has michael jordan hit in his life?" well, i guess he did play in the minors, but that's not what she meant!
Here's actually a good idea. They have some sort of teddy bear shop where u can like choose a type of teddy bear and pick out clothes and all that stuff and get it named and have a special house with all these personalized things on it, I thought it was a pretty good idea for a girls gift. So maybe you can try that