I can maintain ~60% completion in the difficulty setting just below Heisman, but what bothers me more is how the DBs tip the ball and play volleyball with the damn football(and eventually pick it off). That, and the corners are way too adept at playing the ball thrown over their(and their assignment's) shoulders. They also jump too high while running towards one direction.
Another thing is that the deep ball is too easy. If there's a single coverage downfield, you just have to throw it up there to create a 1-on-1 jump ball situation and too often the WR comes out ahead. I really like the game, but I think the ESPN series has surpassed it in the actual playing dept. The recruiting phase of the game still rocks though.