That depends on the cut.
The nicer cuts can be done rare. The toughest stuff needs to be well done. Everything in between gets done accordingly.
Tenderloin steak = rare or medium rare (I can handle a nice medium too)
Beef brisket = slow cooked well
One other tip OP: Don't cut it on a plate like that. You'll dull the knife. Cut it on wood.
Learned something new.
But this is an eye roast, which I am fairly sure should be cooked to Medium-Rare. Atleast that is how I have always had it.
