Maybe I'll preorder The Last of Us but I usually don't preorder games as I always try to wait until reviews to buy one. Too many games look good only to turn out to be turds.
I've got a pretty good sense of what will be good or not based on my personal requirements of a game.
Ni no Kuni was pure bliss for me, despite it's numerous issues, and from what I've seen of The Last of Us, I'm sure I'm going to enjoy it as well regardless of mainstream opinion.
But then you know me... I'll probably say it's one of the best games this generation after disappearing for two weeks 100%ing it while every mainstream outlet review could say it sucks (because theres not enough shooting!) and Ill be giving 0 fux.
Other than serious/tragic JRPGs, I'm a sucker for any suspense/survival horror/post apocalyptic genre to play with the lights out, especially now that Resident Evil is dead. I put in over 200 hours in Fallout 3 100%ing it on the hardest mode with all DLC.