• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

More IP's vs. Cable/Dsl router

nighto

Member
i am kind of pondering which to decide, if i should just buy extra ips for 10 buxs or go get Cable/Dsl router like the linksys Ethernet Cable/Dsl router. This situatuion is for AT&T/mediaone roadrunner service in Los Angeles and they only have 1 ip(currently). They have 2 computers and i was thinking it meant not be worth the money to buy extra ip's. I tried sygate and it works great, evertything seems to work. I got the Linksys Cable/Dsl router at frys to sample it out and it seems ok, with a little bug here and there with setups.

Sygate would be more than enough if they didnt need so much bandwidth.

I pesonally have san diego roadrunner and have had it for serveral years. In sd, they charge 5 bux for each additional ip. The way sd rr is setup is that ips are assigned to the cable modem, thus i believe based on experience that were alotted bandwidth based on cable modem. We dont have to regiser our nic mac address or anthing like that. We just ask for one additonal ip and boom its there for our use. And i think based on experience that that bandwidth usuage is limited to cable modem not ip's.
I understand that cable is dependent on how many people are using the service in my given area(node) etc... But what i am saying is that if i am download/uploading intensively and my roomate plays a online game, his pings really sucks hard. But my neighbors ping for playing the same online game on the same server is fine.

Well in LA(mediaone/At&t road runner) you have to regiser your mac address for each network card to use the cable service.
Meaning there setup is different and maybe there bandwidth is not dependent on the cable modem as the sandiego roadrunner. Basically if you want service you have to call mediaone RR and tell them your network card mac address to use there service. And your options are either u stick with 1 ip, or buy 3 for 9.99 additional. There is no option to have 2 ip.

Thus based on my experience with San diego roadrunner, having addtional ip is wothless with respect to bandwidth if the setup is similar to sd rr. But since LA is different setup maybe its differnt so i am in a deliema, on which option to choose.

Yes addtional IPs makes setup, playing games easier, but nowadays with Router/sygate all the stuff(games, icq,etc..) seem to work just fine.

Some help, and advice would be great on which to choose the Router method(sharing 1 ip) or getting additional IPS. Comments on how LA RR is setup would be cool too.

PS. Reason Sygate is not a option, eventhough sygate is kick ass program, sharing is dependent on host computer. So if host computer crashes, there goes the network. Router setup makes computers not dependent on host thus i dropped the sygate option ='(


 
I think you should go with the router. With multiple IPs you still don't have any firewall type protection, so I use the linksys one port router with a hub to then branch out to all the computers, which all have 192.168.1.# type IPs. I have not noticed any bugs in the router like you have said, but I haven't played with all the functions either. I have a linux web server set up behind the router in addition to some 98 machines and everything works great. I play Half Life online all the time with no worries. I have never used Sygate so I can't compare, but I have used the windows 98 ip sharing utility, and though it worked, I took a performance hit. Hope this helps.
 
So does anyone have LA mediaone/ATT cable service and have more than one ip, if so is there a big perforamce difference in bandwidth when having more than one ip.
 
In any cablemodem service, they will only give you X bandwidth per cablemodem. No way around that, so extra IP's buy you extra computers. Not extra bandwidth. 🙁
 
thks for info guys, Ok i ordered one last night,or this morning actually

but i thought i made correct decision in LInksys cable/router, ordered it from Amazon cause there the only ones with valid coupon left 🙁
50 off 200.

 
Yeah, go with the router. Especially with all of the free DNS services out there now, they make it really easy for you to run email, FTP, and telnet servers.

I like the Linksys router also.
 
Back
Top