The persistence of failed ideas is truly amazing, a tribute to the effectiveness of propaganda.
The whole pack is barking up the "manufacturing jobs" tree when there's not much there, rather than the "redistribution" tree, which is full of raccoons.
As I offered earlier, it's all about the way we view ownership & obligation, about how we accept hoarding & control as real scarcity.
The way people think about tariffs vs taxes at the top is a prime example. Tariffs forced capitalists to hire Americans to make money. That cut into their profits in no small way, but contributed to the well being of American workers. It was a form of forced redistribution of resources. Capitalists would have preferred to use cheaper foreign labor all along.
When tariffs were removed, Capital surged out of the country & cheaper foreign goods entered, but it never was enough to offset the effects on workers' earnings, so other compensations were made, chiefly in the form of more credit. Capital's share of national income soared from offshoring & soared again collecting fees & interest, too.
Obviously, illusory extension of more credit in lieu of wages will only carry us just so far, which is where we are today.
If tariffs served as a redistribution method pre-Free Trade, then we need to provide a different mechanism to achieve the same effect, and taxes are all there is, along with Capital controls.
Instead of cutting taxes at the top, which is what we've done, we should have been raising them. Instead of trying to compete with cheap foreign labor, basically impossible, we should have demanded greater compensation for allowing our Capitalists to use it. We need to realize that, in a Democracy, Ownership can be exerted at a higher level & obligations placed on it in different ways to achieve the same effect as previously.
That would require a paradigm shift in our collective thinking, thinking currently dominated by adherence to concepts that have failed the middle class, concepts that have benefited the financial elite enormously.
Heresy, I know.