Originally posted by: Oakenfold
I loved napster, but Metallica has a right to protect what is theirs. If it wasn't metallica it would have been someone else.
Blame the RIAA if you want to blame anyone, they just needed some names to back them up. That would draw media attention, before bands got involved you think anyone would listen to that whiny RIAA heffer?
No, I think I'll blame Metallica. mp3's are a wonderful medium for internet exchange of music, and it wasn't until Napster came along that the mp3 enthusiasm really skyrocketed. Before Napster, it was a real PITA to find any mp3, to the point where it wasn't worth it. I use mp3's to sample music from various artists, and I buy the CD's if I like what I hear. I also use mp3's for remixes that aren't available on CD and for special tracks you can't find elsewhere.
There are other bands out there that embraced the mp3 medium -- some even released a track or two for FREE on mp3 while others charged only a little for the download. The issue is clearly not piracy of music, it's about the greedy RIAA trying to strongarm another potential moneymaker: mp3's. Obviously, this medium could conceivably rake in a large revenue, and too bad the RIAA wasn't the brainchild of the operation. That title goes to Napster, which ultimately got raped in the process.
Look what the recording industry has done to the music industry. Before, at least the artists were somewhat talented, could actually sing, and had lyrics that were okay. Now, the greedy RIAA n Pals have turned American music into a jello-mold teeny-bopper heaven...it's not longer about talent, it's about marketing a product that will sell. This is how you get the likes of Britney Spears, *NSync, and Backdoor Boys -- entities that were contrived, solely to sell CD's to unwitting prepubescent girls and horny adolescent boys. RIAA controls who becomes a "star," and in doing so, they control the modern music that you listen to. This is why pop music, IMO, has completely degenerated over the last decade or so. ...and now, the recording industry wants to dominate another sector: the distribution and sale of mp3's.
So yes, blame the RIAA....but blame also the groups that support the monopolizing vision of the RIAA, that is, Metallica. Again, I refuse to support a band so greedy that they would threaten Napster as well as threaten to sue two U.S. universities (remember that?) for mp3 distribution. ...and for those of you who support Metallica or the RIAA, for that matter, then I suggest that you delete your mp3 collections out of consistency.
Valsalva