Originally posted by: Crimson
Originally posted by: slurmsmackenzie
Originally posted by: DragonMasterAlex
Originally posted by: slurmsmackenzie
i have a better idea. why don't we, as one of the richest countries in the world, offer free medical care to EVERYONE! all doctors of the same degree receive the same pay. that way, we can stop all the lawsuits over malpractice (i forget the number, but deaths due to malpractice, illness contracted at hospitals is outstanding) and insure that every hospital throughout the nation has credible doctors. we need a communist medical regime. otherwise, all the good doctors are gonna be doing boob jobs and face lifts.... why? cuz that's where the money is. god forbid everyone gets good medical care.
How about we, as one of the few countries in the world that respects INDIVIDUAL rights, stop trying to justify why it's OK to STEAL from some people and give to others? I'm sick to death of this Robin Hood bvllshit and everyone who believes that it's alright to STEAL from someone on the grounds that "hey, they can afford it!".
Jason
you assume we're all starting from square one. someone actually getting into a highly specialized field from the more poverty stricken (medicaid reliant) neighborhoods is by far the exception rather than the rule.
fact: middle class jobs in the u.s. are dwindling.
fact: while jobs are being created, they are mostly minimum wage, or temp jobs.
fact: SOMEONE has to do these jobs!
we expect that someone will do these jobs, it's evident. you can't pay all of your bills off of minimum wage. they deserve equal health care (it isn't equal by any stretch of the imagination, but it's better than what you're proposing). you're just gonna have to mumble under your breath when you see uncle sam taking his chunk. be a good american and take your medicine
Ok, we'll just accept all that as FACT.. :roll: Currently, in my entire circle of friends, family, and aquantances.. I do not know ANYONE who has a temp job, and I do not know ANYONE who is making minimum wage. Now, I have friends that live in the ghetto.. and I have friends that are very wealthy... So I think I have a good representation of both rich and poor in my circle of friends. I even have friends who work at fast food restaurants, grocery stores, etc.. They all make above minimum wage, and usually $3-4 dollars above minimum wage. Give me any 18 year old who knows how to use a computer and I will get them a job starting in the mid to high 20's extremely easily.. a little experience and they are making 35-40.. Thats not POOR, and thats not MINIMUM WAGE.
So, I completely challenge your suggestion that most jobs are temp and minimum wage, its simply NOT TRUE, and you DO NOT have the 'facts' to back it up. Here's what I think is happening.. First of all, I think the middle class is shrinking.. but, I don't think they are moving in the direction of 'poor', I think they are moving in the direction of rich. Almost everyone I have known in my 30 years of life is better now than they were when I was young.. They make more money, have a nicer house, drive nicer cars.. etc.. So, yes, the middle class may be shrinking, but I think its because they are getting wealthier in general.
I also think our definition of 'poor' is so jaded as to almost be laughable. In highschool (over 10 years ago now), we delivered thanksgiving dinners to 'poor' families who supposidly could not afford to purchase them for themselves. Well, just about every one of these families had a Nintendo, a huge TV, stereo, and all the kids were wearing designer shoes. Thats not POOR, thats people who have decided its more important to buy a nice TV and stereo than to feed their family. Poor to me means you are BARELY getting by.. ie, you don't have all the TV's stereos Nintendo's, etc.. And you can STILL barely afford food.. You are not wasting it on alcohol or drugs.. You are not wasting it on a car you can't afford, you aren't wasting it on name brand clothes.. I'm talking about you do all your shopping at Walmart, and you can barely afford it.. You get all your food at the cheapest place, and you buy only whats the best deal... you go to work every day (BOTH parents), and you STILL can barely afford it.. THATS poor..
I seriously doubt most people in this country are really 'poor' or just getting along.. I think the problem is our definition of poor is changing. Poor doesn't mean you can only buy 1 new Playstation game a month as opposed to 3-4...