Meanwhile, an Australian mining company is running battery EV locomotives.

MrSquished

Lifer
Jan 14, 2013
26,717
24,881
136
I honestly don't think America will recover for decades after this MAGA movement is gone, whenever that is. Or recover at all.

On literally every front they are destroying everything that made America great - from science, research, education, to infrastructure, to energy, to economy, to international relations, to the very basic moral and human decency that was left. There is literally no major stone they have left untouched in order to tarnish, destroy, or weaken. I mean it's pretty impressive how well rounded they are in their absolute evil.
 

brycejones

Lifer
Oct 18, 2005
30,321
31,377
136

nakedfrog

No Lifer
Apr 3, 2001
63,598
20,040
136
I'm happy our state at least pushed back against the absurd emergency order to keep a coal-powered plant open even though state law required it to stop and the nearby coal mine was no longer in operation and they've literally been planning to shut it down for years.

 

brycejones

Lifer
Oct 18, 2005
30,321
31,377
136
I'm happy our state at least pushed back against the absurd emergency order to keep a coal-powered plant open even though state law required it to stop and the nearby coal mine was no longer in operation and they've literally been planning to shut it down for years.

Here in Michigan we're still paying extra in our bills to keep a coal plant that we don't need operating. Meanwhile the rubes here are having constant shit fits fighting against utility scale solar installs. "Solar power is a scam".

Affordability is such a made up word.
 

hal2kilo

Lifer
Feb 24, 2009
26,586
12,688
136
Here in Michigan we're still paying extra in our bills to keep a coal plant that we don't need operating. Meanwhile the rubes here are having constant shit fits fighting against utility scale solar installs. "Solar power is a scam".

Affordability is such a made up word.
Oh, by the way, they are lasting longer than predicted.

 

brycejones

Lifer
Oct 18, 2005
30,321
31,377
136
Oh, by the way, they are lasting longer than predicted.

Yeah, around here though people keep repeating a talking point that they only generate 20% of their rated power after 5 years. Hell even the local district repeated a similar claim while approving a solar install. Something like 5-10% a year loss.
 

Muse

Lifer
Jul 11, 2001
41,347
10,466
136
I honestly don't think America will recover for decades after this MAGA movement is gone, whenever that is. Or recover at all.

On literally every front they are destroying everything that made America great - from science, research, education, to infrastructure, to energy, to economy, to international relations, to the very basic moral and human decency that was left. There is literally no major stone they have left untouched in order to tarnish, destroy, or weaken. I mean it's pretty impressive how well rounded they are in their absolute evil.
Doing Putin's wet-dream destruction of US hegemony.
 

nakedfrog

No Lifer
Apr 3, 2001
63,598
20,040
136
More like "owning the libs" and defeating anything gender. Science and knowing things has become feminine-coded in their mind.
Watched the recent Hank Green video about why coal is dumb, and he referred to it as "discourse-ocracy", not driven by any kind of data or facts, just being anti-woke basically, driven by the discourse among MAGA.
 

DisarmedDespot

Senior member
Jun 2, 2016
607
614
136
99% of the time battery-powered trains are stupid.

Article didn't mention it, but this one of the 1% where batteries make more sense than just electrifying the line. The ore trains do downhill fully loaded and only go back up after dropping the ore off, so they actually generate a big chunk of the power they use going back up. Honestly pretty clever!
 
  • Like
Reactions: hal2kilo
Dec 10, 2005
29,693
15,288
136
99% of the time battery-powered trains are stupid.

Article didn't mention it, but this one of the 1% where batteries make more sense than just electrifying the line. The ore trains do downhill fully loaded and only go back up after dropping the ore off, so they actually generate a big chunk of the power they use going back up. Honestly pretty clever!
I can think of a few other places they could make sense: passenger runs where you might not be able to full electrify without other substantial upgrades to extraneous infrastructure (eg, tunnels, underpasses, bridges). Batteries could allow for full line electrification, even if there are gaps that would be difficult to electrify..

But yes, overall, the rush towards battery trains is always kind of a big "why?" - just hang wires as we did generations ago.
 
  • Like
Reactions: sandorski

Paratus

Lifer
Jun 4, 2004
17,765
16,119
146
There’s a couple of massive 200-300 ton mining dump trucks that are solar fuel-cell / battery powered too.

  • Anglo American nuGen: This 300-ton mining truck is part of a zero-emission hydrogen system that uses a 2-megawatt hybrid powerplant, drawing power from a solar farm to produce green hydrogen on-site.
 
  • Like
Reactions: skyking

skyking

Lifer
Nov 21, 2001
22,885
6,050
146
I'm happy our state at least pushed back against the absurd emergency order to keep a coal-powered plant open even though state law required it to stop and the nearby coal mine was no longer in operation and they've literally been planning to shut it down for years.

I last worked out there in 2012. The old shovels were always a good sightseeing structure on plane rides.
 
  • Like
Reactions: nakedfrog

K1052

Elite Member
Aug 21, 2003
53,840
48,574
136
I can think of a few other places they could make sense: passenger runs where you might not be able to full electrify without other substantial upgrades to extraneous infrastructure (eg, tunnels, underpasses, bridges). Batteries could allow for full line electrification, even if there are gaps that would be difficult to electrify..

But yes, overall, the rush towards battery trains is always kind of a big "why?" - just hang wires as we did generations ago.

The biggest barrier to electrification are the Class 1 railroads and an American railroading culture who does not want to practice anything but ye olde railroading. The near total resistance to change to utilize methods/technologies from abroad that literally have solved all their complaints is really impressive.
 

Fenixgoon

Lifer
Jun 30, 2003
33,645
13,340
136
The biggest barrier to electrification are the Class 1 railroads and an American railroading culture who does not want to practice anything but ye olde railroading. The near total resistance to change to utilize methods/technologies from abroad that literally have solved all their complaints is really impressive.
But that requires capital investment. They need to maximize profit damnit!
 
Dec 10, 2005
29,693
15,288
136
The biggest barrier to electrification are the Class 1 railroads and an American railroading culture who does not want to practice anything but ye olde railroading. The near total resistance to change to utilize methods/technologies from abroad that literally have solved all their complaints is really impressive.
For sure. But infrastructure costs in the US are also a huge barrier too (my original thought was around state organizations that control their rails, like the MBTA, who have been resistant to electrification).
 
  • Like
Reactions: K1052

K1052

Elite Member
Aug 21, 2003
53,840
48,574
136
For sure. But infrastructure costs in the US are also a huge barrier too (my original thought was around state organizations that control their rails, like the MBTA, who have been resistant to electrification).

The one exception is Caltrain who jumped at the chance to get at the CAHSR money and their electrification has been a huge success. Basically everybody else yea not so much even if they could have gotten federal dollars for it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Brainonska511