mbm5 accuracy?

Maverick2002

Diamond Member
Jul 22, 2000
4,694
0
0
Ok so I'm testing my second PSU on this new system I have. The first one I used was a 350watt iCute which was pretty low quality in terms of components and was cheap, so I wasn't surprised to see MBM displaying values within 10-15%+ variance on the different voltage lines. However, right now I'm using a 400watt Zalman ZM400A-APF. Just from sheer weight and components used I can tell this is a much higher quality PSU, with a lot more available juice (and significantly better combined voltage lines). However, MBM is still giving me some pretty ridiculous high/low readings, such as 1.34v and 1.6v on the 1.5v CPU line. My system isn't even that loaded:

Biostar mATX nforce2
2x256mb crucial PC3200
100gb WD SE HDD
GF3 Ti200
DVD-ROM, 12x burner
audio + lan onboard

The 3.3, 5 and 12v lines aren't as bad but still similar to those of the iCute PSU. So do voltages really jump that much? Or is MBM even after all these revisions still inaccurate? Or does the motherboard have something to do with it?

fyi the only other review I've seen that uses MBM5 claims to have used a much more powerful system yet the readings aren't as wild. any ideas?

I'll try and run some tests with my multimeter to confirm some of the readings.
 

bob4432

Lifer
Sep 6, 2003
11,717
44
91
between the biostar hardware monitor and mbm, i get two different readings. i question the accuracy of both. :(
 

Davegod

Platinum Member
Nov 26, 2001
2,874
0
76
- motherboard can have a lot to do with voltages
- mbm can be inaccurate
- so can be the bios, other programs
- sensors being inaccurate are the norm
- calculations from sensors are... well, often you'll notice significantly different temp and/or voltage readings after a BIOS update.