Maryland Teacher Calls Room Full Of Blacks Students "Punk Ass N-word"

Page 3 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.
Mar 11, 2004
23,444
5,852
146
The really sad thing is when you work in a school you see it evolve right in front of you. 1st graders all pretty much act the same no matter race or ethnicity but as they go through the grades things change depending mostly on the home situation. Until we are able to discuss these issues frankly without being called racist when you point out that bad behavior is not a cultural thing nothing will change.

Once people realize that just because you're not out calling them slurs and saying they should not be in your country, you can absolutely still be pushing for things that result in actual racism (which again is not just the overt hatred spouted by few).

Literal segregation is actually happening in this country (and its not just in the South either) and it is growing. Its not called that (for very obvious reasons, although since many of the things setup by the Civil Rights Movement to address some of these issue, that actually were making progress in helping to improve these things, have been struck down so it frankly is probably just a matter of time before they drop all pretense about it), but it absolutely is happening (there's a good Frontline episode that covers one of the ways this is being accomplished, via creating townships to create new school districts for instance; its also a major reason for the rise in charter schools).

But you're not interested in discussing how outright racist policies (redlining for instance, which is why many cities to this day still show fairly segregated populations) helped create these situations and that just because you get rid of the overt methods, it won't magically fix the issue overnight, or even within decades, especially if you don't much to actually address the underlying issues. And you're outright delusional if you think race has nothing to do with it.

And that's the rub. People say they it shouldn't be about race, but look at this thread and look how people immediately reacted. People joked about it being racist, and the serious posts are trying to act like race has nothing at all to do with it (dismissing the long history that absolutely plays a role in the economic conditions that people act like welfare - which they heavily imply goes to a certain race despite the truth being that most welfare recipients are not that race - is the sole cause of).

The problem is that, white people see that they are being afflicted in many of the same ways, and thus think their grievances are being lessened by pointing out how in spite of the literal battles fought over race, it still is making it very difficult for certain races to make real progress. And likewise, just because progress has been made, people don't want to accept that there's still a chasm that needs to be overcome. The worst part is that they don't see how addressing it for other races can also help to address it for themselves, and stop supporting the people that are perpetrating it (and the really baffling part is they can absolutely see this as you see them talk about how politicians let corporations dictate things, and then they keep voting in people that are so blatantly doing that, ones that outright campaign on how they're going to help corporations and tout trickle-down-economics in everything but name because of what a total complete failure that is yet people just hear "less taxes" and don't see what is actually being done).

[Note, I'm not saying that they should be supporting Democrats or liberals either as many of them are no better, they just need to see that the people they are voting in are selling them out - unfortunately many of them in wanting to do that effectively pushed in even worse ones, so called "fiscal conservatives" that are really just corporate shills or even worse a President that epitomizes all the things they claim they hate. And so we'll keep making the same mistakes (as we have for decades). People need to start noticing the odd coincidence where Presidents that push trickle-down-economic models leaves us with what far too consistently gets called "the worst recession since the Great Depression" and how that keeps setting us back.]

Any of the decrepit old nuns at my school would have controlled that room with just a look.

Of course they were fully backed by the merciless hand of God.

And by parents who were paying the tuition and had given express consent, encouragement even, to smack the ever living shit out of any student who was misbehaving, had misbehaved, or had the potential to misbehave at some point in the future.

I knew plenty of people that went to schools like that and they acted out far more because of it. They also tended to turn into far more abusive people as they got older (either self-abusive via drugs/alcohol, or abusive to others). And in spite of all the promises they made they turned out exactly like the people they claimed they wouldn't be like, after their mid 20s suddenly believing that the abuse molded them into a perfect model adult, by golly if only they'd been getting worse beatings for longer then they'd have really made something of themselves! So goddamnit why can't their kid just straighten the hell up, spoiled new generation!

Oh they're getting slapped around by a merciless invisible hand. Its not any Christian God though.

You do realize it has been scientifically shown that doing that has negative impact on people's psychology, right? As in, it fucks up people into adulthood (higher rates of mental illness has been shown for instance).

Don't really see anything in this video that the kids are doing to justify them being hung out to dry by everyone here. They are sitting around murmuring cause some kid was getting booted the heck out of class. Not sure what happened before the video, there is no context given.

But these damn Millenials! They've ruined everything! And PC culture! And see racist stereotypes exist for a reason! Here, let me tell you about how I was beaten as a kid and I turned out totally fine, so see these kids just need a good ass kicking and that'll solve everything! I totally never acted like this as a kid (but hey I'll tell all the stories of the crazy shit we used to do that you can't do now because its so unsafe or we'd get in trouble for harmless pranks now! Did I mention I don't understand irony?) Also here let me tell you a personal story (anecdotes > all) about how black people are the most racist now because they're doing reverse racism!

Let's pretend like we know the perfect answer without knowing the situation at hand. We'll proselytize about all manner of things, especially things we explicitly claimed have nothing to do with this (its weird how people say its others injecting race yet they're the ones immediately joking about it, trying to dismiss that the racial situation has any involvement by dismissing how it directly impacts the things they blame for it, or offering up their own personal anecdotes about how racial stereotypes hold true, right? nah...), we'll act like things are both far more complex than they are but then act like those have simple solutions (and completely ignore that there's some complexity but its hardly beyond addressable, and will have a somewhat complex solution, that might not work as well as expected but that is hardly an out and out failure).

And how many of those same people bitch about how you can't trust the media because they just push an agenda? Yet, on just about every topic they immediately jump to conclusions and do exactly all of the things they complain incessantly about?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Brainonska511

skull

Platinum Member
Jun 5, 2000
2,209
327
126
Don't really see anything in this video that the kids are doing to justify them being hung out to dry by everyone here. They are sitting around murmuring cause some kid was getting booted the heck out of class. Not sure what happened before the video, there is no context given.

I'm surprised too considering I keep getting banned for supposedly being racist. Not only did I not see anything that outrageous it wasn't the right thing to say. There are alot of things she could of said to get there attention besides the n word. Am I one of the few people here that have went to a school like this? Is that why last time I got banned for stereotyping people, might be because I've seen stereotypes hold true live and in person. Fuckin yuppies in there little bubble.



Read the rules. You have an issue with the mods or the moderation? Make an MD thread.

https://forums.anandtech.com/threads/anandtech-forum-guidelines.60552/
Number 12


esquared
Anandtech Forum Director
 
Last edited by a moderator:

pauldun170

Diamond Member
Sep 26, 2011
9,531
5,758
136
We've had the occasional teacher have a breakdown in class. Breakdowns that were caused by outside factors and had very little to do with the students.

The teacher in the video failed. She lost it and it doesn't matter what words or phrases she used. It doesn't matter that it occurred in Baltimore. It doesn't matter if the kids were black.
If you can't handle an unruly class of teenagers then the job isn't for you. If you can't set the tone of the classroom or maintain it then you need to find another job.
 

AznAnarchy99

Lifer
Dec 6, 2004
14,695
117
106
We've had the occasional teacher have a breakdown in class. Breakdowns that were caused by outside factors and had very little to do with the students.

The teacher in the video failed. She lost it and it doesn't matter what words or phrases she used. It doesn't matter that it occurred in Baltimore. It doesn't matter if the kids were black.
If you can't handle an unruly class of teenagers then the job isn't for you. If you can't set the tone of the classroom or maintain it then you need to find another job.

My english teacher threw a desk out the window once. He wasn't fired.
 

CountZero

Golden Member
Jul 10, 2001
1,796
36
86
I honestly don't think this is the answer. I went to grade school in Alexandria City Public Schools and they did not allow corporal punishment yet they were able to discipline students effectively and maintain control of schools and classrooms even through the desegregation period that took place between 1962-1972. I then attended Fairfax County Public Schools for Middle and High School where corporal punishment was allowed yet it was 99% a threat rather than a reality. It mostly meant the you could be grabbed and slammed up against a locker when you got too much out of control. Again discipline and good order was kept. The major difference was the WWII generation parents of the baby boomers fully backed the actions of the teachers in the classrooms and the administrators. When I got in trouble in school I was more afraid of what would happen if they decided it needed to be elevated to the point of calling my parents rather than just dealing with it internally. All of my peers were the same.

You nailed it. When I was a kid Adults were a unified front to be concerned with. A single Adult correcting you was enough as you didn't want them to reach out to your parents. Now adults are nothing. A parent will yell at an adult that dares to correct their child. I can't fathom being a teacher in an age where parents don't consider you a peer but an enemy that is unfairly judging their angel. A roadblock to be overrun.

In places like this school it is even worse. I went to school in a crappy part of New Orleans for a short time and it was quite eye opening. It isn't just welfare kids that have issues its also the kids of the working poor. They barely have enough hours in the day to work for food on the table let alone be involved in their kid's lives. Then you look around the school, violence the norm, the kids that are the best off are gang bangers and drug dealers (which are basically one and the same). When science class is interrupted because outside the windows a kid is bleeding out from a deal gone bad it kind of makes photosynthesis seem unimportant to your immediate needs. And climbing out of it looks impossible. That was only Jr. High, we moved before high school so I can only imagine how much worse it got.
 

AznAnarchy99

Lifer
Dec 6, 2004
14,695
117
106
If you throw a desk out the window at work, that's usually a sign you need to move on or get some help.

Lol the guy was wacky but he really cared about his students which is also why he would get so pissed the fuck off when people weren't "serious" 100% of the time.

He ended up having his first kid and attitude in his own words after were "I have my son to look forward to so IDGAF what you all do now".
 
Mar 11, 2004
23,444
5,852
146
I realized I didn't actually address the video itself. Eh, the kids were being dicks (nothing like I expected), and the teacher's reaction was pretty awful. Without knowing the situation, I'm not going to blanket condemn either one. Hopefully the teacher didn't mean it and actually is sorry for having done that (and not just sorry she got caught), and hopefully the kids aren't like that all the time, and that maybe this can bring about something positive.

But chances are it'll just spur a media outcry and a bunch of blather with people shouting opinions and nothing worthwhile be accomplished, further dividing people.

There does seem to be some benefit to charging for school. My wife went from a SE MI public school where she was getting responses from parents like "I don't care if my kid skips class." and "Don't bother me about their failing grades" to a private school that charges $4k for tuition and now gets responses like "You will get an apology from my child tomorrow and please let me know if you don't see an immediate attitude change" followed quickly by scolding the child "I don't pay thousands of dollars a year for you to screw off"

I'm sure there are other factors like the inclination to seek out a better school that weeds out some families but I still think there is something to it esp given the research into the Paradox of value.

That said she has a friend who works in a very expensive private school and there are issues with parents thinking the high cost buys their child automatic As.

I'm not sure why you're under the impression that people don't get charged for school. Just because public schools are generally mostly supported by property taxes does not mean they aren't charged (many of them you absolutely do still pay fees for having your child attend, and a lot of them even that is pushing what they can afford, my mother struggled ).

Also, sorry but if they're affording 4K tuition, they're almost certainly not poor (as 4K would be like 1/3 of their income, hell even if you stretch it and say 20k, 20% of the income for one child for strictly schooling is going to put a hurt on them, as their home cost will likely be close to 50% of their income, and food and transportation will add). Even if its not in a noticeably wealthy area, that is absolutely not as poor as a lot of areas. I can understand that you're likely making the point by isolating that as a factor (I'm assuming that you're inferring the economic prosperity was similar between the areas?), but 4K tuition would be out of reach for a very sizeable amount of people, and these people are the ones that need better access to education, because without it, that perpetuates into the future and so they fail at helping their children learn. That's what people don't get. A major reason the parents fail their children is that they were failed themselves. Simply put a lot of people never learn how to support and nurture their children's development because they don't have a real model for it. And using physical abuse as the means of forcing compliance actually negatively impacts this.

Didn't mean to come off so critical towards you as you offered a serious and thought out response. I don't really agree with what you're proposing even though I would even agree there could be some truth to it, but I think its other factors that are the bigger issue and thus would better represent what you noticed. Especially the latter part is more directed at the attitude of others.

Kinda reminds me of school whenever a Substitute Teacher was brought into class. I recall the Principle giving us a lecture after one Substitute refused to return after one day.

Yep. And I'm calling outright bullshit on the people acting like kids were never like that when they were in school. Hell a lot of schools outright just accept it and so treat days when a substitute is in, they wouldn't even try to teach the normal lesson plan as they know the kids will dick around.

Life is going to hand them welfare and foodstamps. That's the reality. They don't have to learn anything, they don't have to graduate, they don't have to become productive members of society because they've been taught that shit doesn't matter. There's no incentive to be anything else as long as that safety net is there.

You grossly overestimate how much welfare there is available, how easy it is to get, and how much it actually helps. No that is not the reality. Seriously you really need to actually learn about welfare and the people on it. Stop buying into the fabled welfare monsters. I see a lot of people with anecdotes about welfare people, and generally they don't hold up to scrutiny because people assume or project beliefs without knowing the actual situations. I've been around and dealt with plenty of such people and there's aspects to a lot of the anecdotes and claims that I've seen, but I also see people completely dismiss a large multitude of other factors that play a significant role. They do this because people like to break complex issues down into simple black and white. This is rarely if ever the reality of the situation.

And that's why the system fails. It starts at home, if parents value education the kids will learn no matter what the school does. And if the kids are demonspawn of welfare junkies who understand that the government provides for them no matter what level of lowlife they are and education doesn't matter as long as you get a welfare check, then that's what the kids learn. If the kid walks into class with the attitude of "I refuse to learn and you can't make me" then that is indeed the case. The schools can't make a kid learn if the kid refuses. The old lead a horse to water dilemma.

I can't explain why we keep throwing good money at this problem when there's no chance that the system can work. Instead of segregating kids by race segregate them by desire. If you want to learn, take a seat and here's today's lesson. If you refuse, there's the door, get the fuck out. Why pretend that the current education system is working? It can't if the parents are the ones sinking it.

The problem is that you're completely ignoring that the parents might have been failed and so they don't even understand the value of education. They got bumped through the education system and that's what they know and that's what they expect. And plenty of them even still do value education but they don't know how to help their children actually realize it because they never were given real opportunity or model to follow. They know they can't properly teach their children, but they don't know how to help when their child fails. And they will, and there's nothing wrong with that. But instead of saying "that's ok, let's keep working at it" they get labeled as failures and ostracized, and it spirals from there.

Every step of the way is a major challenge and full of frustrations. Teachers often can't offer enough help, and that's if the teacher even knows how to address it. They get frustrated and if the parent can't help them there's not a lot they can realistically do. But they try. I know you and a lot of people want to act like its just a matter of them not trying or not even caring to try, but that's absolute nonsense.

That you can't see how ridiculous it is for you to be approaching things by just dismissing them as "demonspawn" and "junkies" shows that if there's anyone that can't be realistic about this, it is you. And your general attitude and beliefs with regards to welfare don't seem to be based on anything but the boogeyman version pushed by certain people, whilst the actual facts often strongly show far more complexity and nuance (if not outright dispute your claims).

You can't explain it because you're fundamentally not even trying to actually understand the situation. The irony of you, whilst clearly not knowing what you're talking about, lecturing about the failures of our education system...

Segregation in general is a pretty bad thing. Like holy shit, do you even seriously listen to what you're saying? How exactly are you going to segregate by desire anyway? (Actually isn't that what college effectively works like? But hey I guess we should start that in preschool...) Who gets to be the arbiter? This is where someone might interject about how Einstein was a poor student because he didn't really care about learning as a kid to point out how awful what you're proposing is, but then that's not really true (Einstein being a bad student, not that what you're saying isn't incredibly stupid because it definitely is).

Why pretend? Its not pretending as much as it is that you're wrong? The reality is that, while it has a great many flaws, our education system is in fact working overall (literacy rates, graduation rates, and a multitude of other metrics are at all time highs; of course you wouldn't know that if you just listen to people like yourself and our President elect, but then we know how little he values actually knowing what the fuck he's talking about or not talking out of his ass facts be damned). Literally, every new generation of people is, despite all the claims to the contrary, smarter than the ones that preceded it as a whole as we're finding out that knowledge does in fact carry over (and that's why when there's been systemic neglect, as most minorities, but especially one certain one has experienced, in our country, it is very tough to break that cycle and the results of that neglect will persist, and progress will be slow). That's not to say we can't improve (we absolutely can) or that we aren't failing to provide adequate education to a lot of people (we absolutely are).

Actually no, you know what? If you don't want to actually learn what the fuck you're talking about, then you need to get the fuck out. You seriously have an almost complete and total lack of understanding of just about anything you're talking about in this thread. I'd even go as far as to say you and people like you are the biggest problem facing education in America. You made it through school (hell I'm assuming you even got a degree) a certain way so if it worked for you it should work for everyone. Yet you're condemning children for not learning whilst showing that you can't even be bothered to actually research the things you're spouting off about and actively just fabricating a reality to prop up your own beliefs.

After reading your posts, and being reminded of how prevalent similar beliefs and attitudes to yours is, I'm frankly more concerned with the outright lack of learning that people do once they're finished with school.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Brainonska511

MrSquished

Lifer
Jan 14, 2013
26,074
24,405
136
But these damn Millenials! They've ruined everything! And PC culture! And see racist stereotypes exist for a reason! Here, let me tell you about how I was beaten as a kid and I turned out totally fine, so see these kids just need a good ass kicking and that'll solve everything! I totally never acted like this as a kid (but hey I'll tell all the stories of the crazy shit we used to do that you can't do now because its so unsafe or we'd get in trouble for harmless pranks now! Did I mention I don't understand irony?) Also here let me tell you a personal story (anecdotes > all) about how black people are the most racist now because they're doing reverse racism!

Let's pretend like we know the perfect answer without knowing the situation at hand. We'll proselytize about all manner of things, especially things we explicitly claimed have nothing to do with this (its weird how people say its others injecting race yet they're the ones immediately joking about it, trying to dismiss that the racial situation has any involvement by dismissing how it directly impacts the things they blame for it, or offering up their own personal anecdotes about how racial stereotypes hold true, right? nah...), we'll act like things are both far more complex than they are but then act like those have simple solutions (and completely ignore that there's some complexity but its hardly beyond addressable, and will have a somewhat complex solution, that might not work as well as expected but that is hardly an out and out failure).

And how many of those same people bitch about how you can't trust the media because they just push an agenda? Yet, on just about every topic they immediately jump to conclusions and do exactly all of the things they complain incessantly about?

Seriously a whole bunch of the first posters to respond to this thread jumped to a million conclusions. Poverty, inner city, parenting, lack of punishment, throw parents in jail, etc, etc, etc....

All based upon the same video everyone got to watch, and nobody posted a different article or video or source that could explain their rationale.

Ultimately the video is short and really shows nothing to justify those reactions. It's one kid standing up getting kicked out of class for something we have no idea about, and the rest of the kids sitting down talking about what was going on, most likely. Or just talking. Perhaps her students are really demon spawn, like some here assumed immediately. Or perhaps it was a humdrum situation the entire time. Are there problems in schools today? Sure. Is it possible to break them down by income levels and race? Possibly. Haven't seen anything here to show jack shit about that though. Just a bunch of jump to the conclusion judge, jury and executioner conclusions. Then a bunch of reactions that called the teacher out for what is, actually, the only clear thing on that video. Her yelling and screaming then uttering an ooopsie daisy phrase.
 

Pulsar

Diamond Member
Mar 3, 2003
5,224
306
126
A lot of the blame has to be on her for taking such a crappy job. Go find a school where kids are more normal and want to learn. Don't hang out in a shit hole school just cause its a job. I would have been out of there the 1st day most likely once i saw how the class behaved.

You are kidding me, right? I've been in both, and you get just as many little shitheads in any type of school. Some classes are good, some classes are not. But blaming HER for where she works and believing that is the root cause of the problem? Holy crap.
 
Nov 29, 2006
15,921
4,491
136
You are kidding me, right? I've been in both, and you get just as many little shitheads in any type of school. Some classes are good, some classes are not. But blaming HER for where she works and believing that is the root cause of the problem? Holy crap.
Never said it was the root cause of the problem. But willingly hanging out in said shitty environment is 100% on her. She is free to go elsewhere. She's not a slave.
 

Exterous

Super Moderator
Jun 20, 2006
20,603
3,824
126
I'm not sure why you're under the impression that people don't get charged for school. Just because public schools are generally mostly supported by property taxes does not mean they aren't charged (many of them you absolutely do still pay fees for having your child attend, and a lot of them even that is pushing what they can afford, my mother struggled ).

I'm not sure why you're under the impression I said there wasn't a charge for public school. I certainly never said that. That said, at least in Metro Detroit, there are numerous programs available that cover the ancillary costs like lunches, pencils, books, backpacks, field trips etc.

Also, sorry but if they're affording 4K tuition, they're almost certainly not poor (as 4K would be like 1/3 of their income, hell even if you stretch it and say 20k, 20% of the income for one child for strictly schooling is going to put a hurt on them, as their home cost will likely be close to 50% of their income, and food and transportation will add).

I never said the parents paid the entire or afforded the entire tuition. I said the school charges the tuition. They partner with numerous entities within the Metro Detroit area for scholarships and backing - not all of which are academic based as there is an awareness of the various difficulties in education in the area. While most pay at least some of the tuition there are students that attend the school for no out of pocket tuition expenses although there is still a 'charge' for the education for them in terms of time and effort to get the assistance needed - and any education standards their assistance may require. (I simply picked the parent examples from actual quotes that quickly came to mind.)

Even if its not in a noticeably wealthy area, that is absolutely not as poor as a lot of areas.

I'm interested to know how you discerned its location simply on the basis of the tuition cost esp given that it is entirely possible to have a school in a poor area and still charge for tuition. Is it in the poorest and most destitute area of Detroit? No. Is it still a poor area - well its in the top 5 ranking of 'Poorest cities in Michigan' so I would argue that counts as a pretty firm 'Yes'
 

child of wonder

Diamond Member
Aug 31, 2006
8,307
176
106
Simple solution. Receiving government benefits requires being on birth control. Random piss test to verify. Bonus payments for getting a government paid vasectomy. Extra benefits if kids get good grades in school.

Stop letting people breed new generations of moochers.
 

spacejamz

Lifer
Mar 31, 2003
10,989
1,723
126
You just know that she has to deal with the blame of why little johnny is failing and not getting an education on top of everything else too.

picture-1.png
 
  • Like
Reactions: Linflas