• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

Man says electromagnetic sensitivity has forced him to live in his car :(UPDATE!:

waggy

No Lifer
Note: this thread has been updated with the court case. (Necro'd thread with a relevant update) -DrPizza


Man says electromagnetic sensitivity has forced him to live in his car

A Santa Fe man who says he suffers from electromagnetic sensitivity is suing his next-door neighbor for refusing to turn off her cell phone and other electronic devices.

Arthur Firstenberg, who has actively opposed the proliferation of wireless systems in public buildings, claims he has been made homeless by Raphaela Monribot's rejection of his requests.

Firstenberg and Monribot, who have homes only 25 feet apart in a west-side neighborhood, both declined to discuss the lawsuit Thursday.

Monribot's actions have effectively ousted Firstenberg from the house he bought last year and forced him to stay with friends or in his car, says a document filed Monday in state District Court by lawyer Lindsay Lovejoy Jr.

Firstenberg "cannot stay in a hotel, because hotels and motels all employ wi-fi connections, which trigger a severe illness," says the request for a preliminary injunction. "If (Firstenberg) cannot obtain preliminary relief, he will be forced to continue to sleep in his car, enduring winter cold and discomfort, until this case can be heard."

The case has been assigned to state District Judge Daniel Sanchez, who has yet to set a hearing.

/sniped because its a long article.


WTF? ok say he is really bothered by wi-fi and someone keeping the phone on. What right does he have to force someone else to stop useing them? if he does not want to be bothered move to a place that is free of people.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
They should test him. Lock him in a closet with a cellphone nearby and turn it on and off to see if he can tell.

If he actually pulls it off -- then he'd have a case.
 
They should test him. Lock him in a closet with a cellphone nearby and turn it on and off to see if he can tell.

If he actually pulls it off -- then he'd have a case.

no, no he wouldn't.

This will be gone quickly on a motion to dismiss, and hopefully the neighbor will get to recover her legal fees in defending this nonsense.
 
Ah, some people are nothing but money grubbing idiots. This same retard probably doesn't realize the fact that everywhere he is exposed to cellphone reception, he is receiving radiation from the cell towers, the same radiation that he blames his neighbor for making him sick.

Let him live on the streets, serves him right for being retarded.
 
They should test him. Lock him in a closet with a cellphone nearby and turn it on and off to see if he can tell.

If he actually pulls it off -- then he'd have a case.

no he wouldnt. he has no right to make other people live how he wants.

IF he actually has what he claims (wich i doubt) then his only option is to move somwhere where he is out of such radation wich is impossible.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arthur_Firstenberg

seems he has a history of lawsuits and is anti-techonology. he sued Senta Fe over offering free wi-fi and lost
 
no he wouldnt. he has no right to make other people live how he wants.

IF he actually has what he claims (wich i doubt) then his only option is to move somwhere where he is out of such radation wich is impossible.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arthur_Firstenberg

seems he has a history of lawsuits and is anti-techonology. he sued Senta Fe over offering free wi-fi and lost
Did I say he was retarded? I meant he was a freaking dumb-ass (and a douche).

Looks like "radio waves" are his crutch for being a born loser. "I couldn't finish school because of the Radio waves", or "I lost my job, because of radio waves." ect. I betcha he doesn't even realize that lights, his car, anything that uses electricity are also emitting radio waves.
 
People like that can be crazy!

There was a case where a dockworker believed the HID lighting was giving him cancer. He complained to the unions for seemingly forever and when his cries for desperation went unanswered he decided to take matters into his own hands with results he did not expect!

He comes into work one day carrying some extra items in his carry bag. Story is he goes into the men's room, strips butt naked, takes out a can of aluminum spray paint and covers his body from head to toe!

He walks around the workfloor telling everyone he feels safer. Frightened employees call 911 and the cops take him away.

He is fired and the only charge he receives - ironically - is destruction of federal property! Supposedly the washroom floor was defaced by overspray when he painted himself!

Yes the guy in the OP's story should be tested. If he is found mentally capable he should be sat in front of a bright screen and forced to watch cakefarts videos! Clockwork Orange style! 😀
 
So, does he turn off all of the electrical components in his car? Or does he drive some 25 year old model?
 
So, does he turn off all of the electrical components in his car? Or does he drive some 25 year old model?
Even 25 yo models have spark plugs. Unless his car is a 100 year old diesel hand crank, he has nothing to complain about.
 
He must be a vampire! He's raising a stink about EM sensitivity to cover for the fact that he can't tolerate sunlight 😛
 
no he wouldnt. he has no right to make other people live how he wants.

IF he actually has what he claims (wich i doubt) then his only option is to move somwhere where he is out of such radation wich is impossible.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arthur_Firstenberg

seems he has a history of lawsuits and is anti-techonology. he sued Senta Fe over offering free wi-fi and lost

Technically he might have somewhat of a case. One is not allowed to impede on ones ability to enjoy their property. Just like sound waves (from a stereo) or a bad odor can interfere, radio waves could do the same. Her cell phone/wifi might be sending signals that causes this guy grief.

I'm not saying I agree with this, or believe the guy, but its possible that if its a legit medical condition he *MAY* have a case. Depends on what the FCC's rules are.


As suggested this guy should just throw up a faraday cage. If a cell phone causes problems, its just as likely that CB radios, satellite tv/radio, am/fm radio, wimax, cellular (GSM/CDMA), and various other intergalactic radiation causes problems for him too.
 
Last edited:
tell him he's being bathed in ~12GHz signals from dish and directv, or tell him what those rectangular antennas you see from buildings and towers are for, maybe he'll freak out and leave.
 
There was a document about people that claim to suffer from electromagnetic hypersensitivity. They found quite a few even in country the size of Finland. One painted the inside of his house with some kind of special paint. Another lived outside her home in a trailer and one moved to Lappland. Like an hour away from civilization. Only one really annoyed others. He lived close to the ship docks and would call shipping companies to ask them to shut down their radars on the ship while they were docked.
 
Technically he might have somewhat of a case. One is not allowed to impede on ones ability to enjoy their property. Just like sound waves (from a stereo) or a bad odor can interfere, radio waves could do the same. Her cell phone/wifi might be sending signals that causes this guy grief.

I'm not saying I agree with this, or believe the guy, but its possible that if its a legit medical condition he *MAY* have a case. Depends on what the FCC's rules are.


As suggested this guy should just throw up a faraday cage. If a cell phone causes problems, its just as likely that CB radios, satellite tv/radio, am/fm radio, wimax, cellular (GSM/CDMA), and various other intergalactic radiation causes problems for him too.

actually no he does not. I have the right to enjoy my property. IF me enjoying my property is not breaking any laws (having a damn phone on is not against the law or even a wireless internet) then if something is bothering him that is his problem NOT MINE.


Not to mention as others said. ITS IMPOSSIBLE THAT ITS JUST THE NEIGHBOR. if he has issues with a cell phones radation then he can't walk in public. why? they are everywhere and not just when a cell phone is turned on.
 
actually no he does not. I have the right to enjoy my property. IF me enjoying my property is not breaking any laws (having a damn phone on is not against the law or even a wireless internet) then if something is bothering him that is his problem NOT MINE.


Not to mention as others said. ITS IMPOSSIBLE THAT ITS JUST THE NEIGHBOR. if he has issues with a cell phones radation then he can't walk in public. why? they are everywhere and not just when a cell phone is turned on.

you're both kinda right, though you're more right in this case. It's not an issue of breaking laws - this is purely nuisance tort law in that if you're doing something on your property that is preventing them from enjoying their property, they might have a claim. That said, nuisance law usually involves noxious fumes or super bright light shining in their windows, etc. It would move into trespass tort claims if something physically was crossing the line of property, like fertilizer runoff etc.

In this case, no court (outside of California maybe) would entertain a suit for nuisance or trespass on the theory that I can't watch tv/use the phone/use the computer in my own house.
 
I'm going way out on a limb here but it is possible for things like wifi to cause him problems. He could have some formation of bone or flesh that is resonant with the 1800-2400Mhz range and that could cause health issues.

There was a case years ago I read about where anytime a woman got near a local tv station tower she developed severe headaches that made her almost pass out. They determined with an MRI that she had a malformed bone structure near the cochlea of the ear that was resonant to that frequency.

It would be easy to check, give him a MRI and do some frequency testing.
 
They should test him. Lock him in a closet with a cellphone nearby and turn it on and off to see if he can tell.

If he actually pulls it off -- then he'd have a case.
Frakkin great idea.
Actually, one of the best ideas you have ever posted.
Though that's not saying a heck of a lot🙂
 
A little extreme but not much different then 911 conspiracy theory believers or the anti vaccine crowd or the people who think wind power makes them sick.

One wonders what kind of lawyer takes on a wacky case like this.
 
Back
Top