I've got 5 of these drives from various rebate offers (Fry's, OD etc.) they usually are about $50 after rebate, so this is pretty hot - until you consider that these days you can get a drive twice that size for $60 after rebate.....
Plus, out of five of these, I've had two fail - at least the RMA process is painless, if it fails within the first year.
If these were Seagate (quiet, reliable and 5 year warranty) this would be hot, Maxtor is warm.