- Mar 22, 2012
- 5,773
- 4
- 0
for fps games the mouse is superior for a few reasons. Mouse wheel to swap weapons. right click secondary fire or zoom is very intuitive, thumb buttons are super convenient for melee or reloads.
Hey, OP checking in here. I like both trackballs and mice, the reason I got a mouse and decided to try it was that I did feel like maybe on those occasions when I tried briefly playing CS:GO with the mouse that came with my wireless keyboard, there was something to it... something that at least aroused my curiosity enough that I thought it might be worth getting a legit gaming mouse and a nice pad.
But I must point something out here. Everything you're mentioning applies to modern trackballs just as much. The Logitech M570 has thumb buttons, a left and right click button (not even sure why you said that, did you think trackballs are just one large ball with no buttons or something? like Centipede? ) and a wheel... so, yea every single thing you listed is just as applicable to a trackball.
As I tweak it more and more I am enjoying the mouse, but make no mistake... I was a beast in Quake 1 1996, I was a beast in CS 1.2 and 1.6 and CS:S when I played consistently enough to hang... and I used trackballs allll the while. I've been damned good at a lot of online games whenever I played any one game consistently. Always with trackballs.
Trust me, you can be quite good with the right trackball, and a high level of familiarity with it. I think the reason you don't see professional gamers using trackballs much (though frankly who has actually gone and polled them to see if any use trackballs?) is the same reason you don't see a lot of them sitting there with VR goggles on.
It isn't so much a negative against the peripheral's actual worth and merit, but rather the fact that it's obscure, and most people aren't going to mess around with something obscure, harder to find, of which there is a more limited selection and let's face it... every kid who later became a pro gamer started off probably messing around on his parent's computer or older brother's computer and then a little later on the computers at school, before they were gaming at all or gaming seriously certainly. What did all of those computers have? Mice, not trackballs.
So if you use mice and everyone you know uses mice from birth (now in my case I'm old enough that there weren't mice when I was very young...) it's going to take a rather odd choice on your part to suddenly deviate from everything you know, go outside your comfort zone, and decide to learn to use a trackball.
Hell, I've always said having a trackball on my PC is like having a second password. Most people are loathe to try to use my PC because they hate to try to figure out the trackball.
But I assure you, as a consistent trackball user since 1989, they ARE good, one weakness though is that there are never anywhere near as many models on the market as mice, so you sometimes have to take what you can get, this was especially true in the past. The Logitech Trackman Marble FX wireless was the pinnacle IMO, and I wish they'd bring it back.
But some have been very good, others not so much... but yea, a more limited selection no doubt. They are also harder to get right than a mouse.
To some degree, a mouse is a mouse. What I mean is, they all adhere to the same basic shape (I know there's variation but it's always sort of... y'know, that mouse shape roughly) and the buttons are always going to be in the same spot at least for the major ones... the scroll wheel too, you start to see variation in the extra buttons that basic mice don't have of course.
But with trackballs, they have varied wildly in layout, how big is the ball? where is it located? how many buttons? what finger or fingers are you using to control the ball, index or thumb? etc etc etc.
So they are more obscure, harder to do right, fewer people even TRYING to do them right, and there is a huge cultural momentum against anyone starting to use them if they didn't before.
But they DO have advantages and things about them which make them damned nice sometimes. Trust us.
Here's my new mouse and it's pad next to my trackball:
