I used to like Little Caesar's. When they started the Extra Most Bestest I gave them a try (hadn't had them in like 3 decades). And they were pretty good as long as you got it fresh or without sauce (which they'd have to make fresh). But then we kept getting undercooked pizzas so we stopped going there (think the last one I got was the pretzel crust and it was ok but wasn't much different from their normal crust other than had salt and butter flavor added). I'd get their thin crust but then you're getting like half the pizza and its only good fresh.
Pizza Hut isn't too terribly priced (can get 2+ medium 1 topping pizzas for $5 each, recently they've had specials for large 3 topping for $7.99). They have other stuff on the $5 menu too (double order of breadsticks, their P'zone, some pasta thing, I think wings, and some deserts). And if you love toppings they do 50% off specials pretty often (so their Lover's line is like ~$9 for a large).
Costco is tough to beat on price. Although I didn't find their pizza to be great non-fresh either. And its often really greasy (and the grease being nuclear hot). I usually just settle for a slice or two in the food court versus getting a full pizza to take.
I've recently tried a pizza from a couple of convenience store chains here since they were promoting and figured why the fuck not. QuickTrip is offering a good size (larger than the chains, but not Costco sized) pizza for $9.99. It was decent (not spectacular but pretty good, I'd put it roughly in line with a normal cheap option from Pizza Hut). Circle K's is about the same size (but less crust to theirs) special one topping for $5.99. Its closer to Little Caesar's in quality (I'd take their crust over Little Caesar, but the rest is similar I think, maybe cheaper on the cheese and pepperoni).
I think they're pretty good, actually, but yeah they gotta be fresh. Otherwise they're kinda "meh."
Their Crazy Bread is off the f'ing hook, though. So good. Oh and that butter garlic sauce (I use it for dipping the crust in) is awesome.
Did you permanently fry your taste buds so its the only way you can taste flavor? Their Crazy Bread is terrible. Its like they just put shitloads of awful flavoring into cheap overcooked breadsticks. The flavoring is fucked up too, almost like they put cilantro or something in there, where it mostly tastes like "italian herbs and spices" but then has some extra weirdness that you know isn't right.
Oh and fuck garlic butter sauce. I don't know who the fucking assholes that convinced all the pizza chains to be slathering that shit on everything for awhile there but it made pizza worse (and often even if you asked them not to put it they'd either still put it or their pans would be coated with it from cooking other pizzas so it'd still end up on your pizza), and makes leftover pizza an abomination. Garlic bread is good. Garlic butter on pizza is for people that want to pretend they're being true to pizza's origins but too cheap to order from an authentic Italian pizza place and get authentic Italian pizza. Thankfully that fad is mostly dying.
You can gar-lick my balls after I dip them in that shitty garlic sauce.
