Originally posted by: Mo0o
Originally posted by: krylon
Originally posted by: Mo0o
Originally posted by: ja1484
Great, another list of movies that people think are great simply because they're weird but are in reality average with some superficial surrealistic gimmick. Some of you are thinking clearly with contributions like Apocalypse Now, et al. Memento and Pulp Fiction are excellent movies for reasons completely aside why people are posting them. Eschewing chronological order isn't interesting or special. The writing and overall plot arcs are what made both those films work. Pulp Fiction in particular survives on its plausible situational humor - the "funny because it's true" effect, so to speak.
I find it amusing that a Donnie Darko post was timewarped to the top.
Anyway:
Oh Brother Where Art Thou (For the genius writing and acting)
Black Hawk Down (For the phenomenal "boots on the ground" cinematography style)
The Dark Knight (For being the most profound social statement in film since 9/11)
The Dark Knight is a profound social statement? In which way? The contrived, cliche, scenario of who to rescue? The movie was the most overhyped movie of last year.
Way too self important to be entertaining, too shallow to be important.
Sounds like you.
Maybe, maybe not. Which of the following points do you disagree with:
Plot was pretty standard fare (thus not mind blowing)
Way too long, final two-face plot felt crammed in
Batman's voice became more and more ridiculous
The movie would have been fine if they had just ended it in the hospital scene w/ revealing Two Face. I think i'm just reacting against the ridiculous hype the movie got. In my opinion Iron Man was way more fun as a movie. Kept a tongue-in-cheek tone throughout the whole movie, lots of a great special effects and a script that moved along nicely. Who cares if it didnt attempt to tackle any moral dilemmas