I have a 17" Sony Trinitron 200SX that is still going strong after almost 7 years.

(although, it cost me $600+ when I bought it new!)
On the other hand, I had a MAG Innovision 19" (actually a ProView VM900E) that died after only one and a half years. One day it simply would not power on anymore and the fuse was not blown.

Make sure the monitor you buy comes with a three year warranty. The MAG had a three year warranty, but if it was purchased from Best Buy or Circuit City, then the warranty was only ONE YEAR. Since I bought it at BB, I got screwed. The MAG was cheap and junky, and the screen had such a curve to it, it was kind of like looking at a bubble! The glare was horrible compared to my new NEC.
I now have a 19" NEC Flat Screen 97F which is MUCH crisper than the MAG ever was, and it cost about the same ($180 after coupon & $50 rebate).
They way I look at it, if the monitor has a three year warranty, you probably won't ever need to use the warranty. If the monitor has a one year warranty, plan on replacing the monitor after about a year and a half. YMMV...