It has nothing to do with smoothness. Any high-end 2013 phone will be smooth. An HTC One which came out in March, with a Snapdragon 600, is still extremely smooth (and it just got updated to 4.3 as well).
It's more an issue with the manufacturer's "skin", and carrier add-ons. For example, on a GS4 GPE, there are 8 quick-setting toggles. On a GS4 with TouchWiz, there are 18 toggles.
Google's development pace is very fast. 4.3 brought TRIM support, and 4.4 is supposed to be a pretty major update. Some manufacturers are better than others about updates; HTC only took 2 months to update to 4.3 while Samsung will take 3 months. That doesn't sound like a lot, but it is a lot when new flagship devices are coming out every 6-8 months, and new revisions of Android are out every 3-4 months.
I had both the Optimus G and now the G2 on AT&T. While I rooted and played with ROMS on the Optimus G, I ended up back to stock, simply because it wasn't that bad and everything in the phone just worked better (signal, camera, battery life, etc) under stock ROM. Sure it wasn't the absolute latest or slimmest android ROM version, but lately, all the new versions don't seem different enough for me to even care as long as the core thing I care about work fine. Hopefully KitKat will show some changes that make it actually different and interesting again.
With my new G2, I did root, but simply so I could freeze some of the AT&T bloat, but the actual stock ROM again is pretty nice, so I don't have any urging to play with other 3rd party ROMS. Is the stock ROM perfect? No, but it's just as im-perfect as most others are in the long run and is acceptable in daily usage. Plus I don't have to be worried about what version of the radio or other driver issues that playing with ROM's had me fretting over. While playing with ROM's can be fun for a while with all the different options and doohickeys, eventually I just want my shit to work and be acceptable in daily usage. This G2's stock ROM seems quite good in that regard.
This phone has awesome battery life for the screen size and power. Yes the back middle buttons throw me off once in a while, but not enough to make me disregard the phone's other strengths.
Don't you guys have Loki working now? If so, make sure to root and flash a (Loki powered) custom recovery before the next OTA.I will eventually root to delete bloat and backup my phone, and to also tweak a little things on the stock rom
I've had a bit more time to play with the phone.
The phone itself works okay for an android phone, and is mostly a function of the software so quirks it has are common to all android devices running 4.2.2. The speaker phone is average, and everyone seems to be able to understand me and I can hear them. Nuff said.
The camera is awesome for a phone camera. Best pictures I've seen out of a smart phone, iPhone 5s included. It has a bit of trouble with really low light, but the images are acceptable. I may be behind the times, but I don't see the need to carry a pocket camera anymore, this phone has blurred the line between $200 compact camera and built-in phone camera imho. Yes, it's still not quite as good as a separate camera, but if it's all you have you won't be disappointed by the images if you have time to frame the shot correctly.
The battery life is good, I used the phone from 7 in the a.m. until about 9 p.m. and it was at 48%. My old phone was always sitting on the charger at work and home, so this is a revelation for me lol.
I put a slim urethane case on it so I don't care if the backios glossy or not, and the physical size is acceptable to me. The buttons on the back I'm getting used to. I find that turning it on by tapping twice works well, but I still have to turn the phone around to hit the power button to turn it off, my fingers don't have the muscle memory for doing it automatically yet.
Apps are individual, so I won't comment on what I installed. I disabled most of the junk installed on the phone, customizing a phone of course is highly personal, and I don't like a lot of extra stuff running in the background. I can say "cheese" myself right before I press the shutter 🙂
Overall, I like it. It was $99 on amazon and activation was easy.
It is now also recommend by consumer reports.
http://m.androidauthority.com/lg-g2-consumer-reports-314314/
The sound quality was not that great
Actually, it's not "much" better, if at all. The Note 2 had an excellent implementation of its Wolfson DAC. And you aren't going to get even 14 bits of resolution from the hardware of a portable device anyway.But the sound quality with headphones is much better, especially since the G2 supports 24bit/192kHz FLAC files.
Wolfson DAC
Loving mine so far.
The battery life is by far the best I've used on a phone this size. (I'm talking you S4, HTC One, and Nexus 4)
This phone is very compact and feels solid in hand.
The Camera performance has me impressed - LG is really making strides here.
Overall based on the initial Camera/Battery life info on the Nexus 5 I think I made the right call.
So question -- people who got it from AT&T -- is the bootloader encrypted/locked?
G2 if you want AOSP/CM.I'm returning the iPhone5s I got from Tmobile 13 days ago today. I am leaning on the G2 or Note 3. Which would you guys go for? Hm...