Let's talk about bathroom scales (Updated)...

deadken

Diamond Member
Aug 8, 2004
3,196
4
81
I really like this forum. I visit read and post here whenever I can. I've enjoyed reading about what others do to reach goals and have learned a few things along the way.

In this section, a lot of focus is placed upon what we weigh. A lot of people include their body weight as a necessary statistic in their OP. As I work on myself (trying to be more healthy, gain stamina, lose weight, etc...) it occurred to me that I am using a 15+ year old plain jane bathroom scale. I'm guessing the overall accuracy isn't quite as important as it providing a week to week comparison as to how I'm doing (IOW: the numbers don't matter as much as the comparison). When a co-worker asked what my target weight is, I honestly replied that I don't know, I am just trying to be happy with the way I look naked in the mirror.

So, I'd like to ask what others here use to track their weight? Is a typical old spring type bathroom scale sufficient? I've seen digital scales for as cheap as $20, are they any more accurate? Perhaps more importantly, are the digital scales more consistent than spring scales? I remember when the tri-beam scale was king. I'm assuming that there is a reason that my doctors office still has one. I figure that if I weigh myself at the doctors and then come home and weigh myself, I should have a good idea how close my scale is.

I do know that I have a hard time reading exactly what my weight is on my current scale. It has a full circle and the needle moves to the number (as opposed to where the numbers move to the needle). Of course, even when I zero it out, a couple of bounces and it usually is off by a pound or more again.

I'm considering buying this (http://www.amazon.com/Precision-Digi...V2&cdSort=best) scale from Amazon, and I figured I'd ask here first. Frankly, it isn't a big investment, but I figured I'd ask first.

So, please feel free to post about what you use, how important you feel your weight is, whether or not you feel the mirror is a better tool than the scale, enlighten me about how body mass index is far superior than a scale, etc... Please feel free to post something funny!

EDIT: Ughh... During my research into scales, I saw a person talking about being sure that a scale is placed on a hard floor. Well, the feet on my scale are all off, so I usually place it on the bathroom mat. Today, I weighed myself as I usually do and then moved the scale to the tile portion of the floor. Boom! I gained 2 pounds.... Ughh... So, I tried it again, still 2 pounds heavier. I moved the scale back to the mat and I tried again. Sure enough I got 2 pounds lighter. I guess it takes about 2 pounds of weight to fully compress that bathroom mat. Great, I just started researching scales and I've already gained 2 pounds! I know it doesn't matter, because I've always put the scale on the mat, so my weight loss is just as many pounds. But, it's just that I'm heavier than I thought right off the bat. Let's see what happens when I buy a new scale.
 
Last edited:

Jwyatt

Golden Member
Mar 22, 2000
1,961
0
76
Hi Deadken,
I've been paying alot of attention to scales lately. I have a post on here to solicit votes for a weight loss challenge im doing online at healthywage.com Check it out.

Anyways. cheap digital scales are finiky. The ones i have tested are of Walmart and target verity, and a nice digital scale at our local YMCA. There is anywhere from 1 - 4 lbs difference in the scales at any given time. We have what we call the fat scales and skinny scales sitting in our bedroom floor. But sometimes they switch. The fat scales will show less than the skinny scales do. Its crazy. I'm not sure of the reasoning. Sometimes you can weigh once cool im down 2 lbs. then weight 20 seconds later. ugh i just put 2lb back on.

One thing to watch out for, i noticed you said you put them on tile floors. Tiles can be uneven. I use my foot to tap all corners to make sure the scales are not "rocking" on any corner. That can give inaccurate or non repeatable readings.
Both of the ones at home are Health O Meter. Just make sure you put them on a level surface, and use the same scale to weigh in. Dont change up. It just confuses things.
Good luck on your weight loss journey.

PS i need votes for our weight loss challenge. I suggest if you want to loose to head over to healthywage and give it a shot.
Please vote for team TIRED OF THE SPARE AT

https://www.healthywage.com/leaderboards/team_standings/?team_challenge=52&secondary_filter=5
 

futurefields

Diamond Member
Jun 2, 2012
6,470
32
91
I just use some $20 scale i got on amazon. I moved it 3 inches to the left the other day, and gained 2 lbs.
 

spacejamz

Lifer
Mar 31, 2003
10,922
1,572
126
Bought scale a few weeks ago...pretty happy with it so far...

http://www.amazon.com/GoWISE-USA-Dig.../dp/B00CZPF5L2

I know the body fat measurement is pretty close but not sure about the muscle mass, bone mass or body water percentage as I have never had those measure before.

On my previous digital scale you had to tap a button, wait a few seconds before you got on the scale...this one, you just step on it...
 

z1ggy

Lifer
May 17, 2008
10,010
66
91
I use the regular one at the gym that counter balances your weight. The electronic scale ones are never reliable for me...
 

lord_emperor

Golden Member
Nov 4, 2009
1,380
1
0
I've only been at this for 2 months but I'm well aware of the limitations of my cheap scale. It can read as much as 10lbs different depending how I stand on it and I know at least for the value I settled on it was 10lbs higher than my doctor's scale.

However the way I see it as long as it's consistently inaccurate it's good enough for measuring changes and trends.
 

purbeast0

No Lifer
Sep 13, 2001
53,452
6,297
126
i got this one a couple months ago and like it a lot.

http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00...?ie=UTF8&psc=1

i had to get a new one also because one of the bottom things came off of my other one and it made it lopsided.

also, when weighing yourself, be sure to do it at the same time every week when you weigh in. you will weigh much different in the morning than at night. even if you've taken a dump or not will make a difference.
 

Koing

Elite Member <br> Super Moderator<br> Health and F
Oct 11, 2000
16,843
2
0
I did a lot of research in to this and it's a joke. Basically to get *accurate* scales you would have to spend north of £250.

I settled on this:
http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Seca-807-...en_BathroomAccessories_SM&hash=item35d4a4354d

Get some reasonable digital scales. They should at least track your weight reasonably well even if you don't have an accurate absolute weight of yourself.

I compete in weightlifting comps 3-5x a year so I need to keep my weight reasonable. I have use to the clubs calibrated comp scales as well. It's a horror show thinking you are 94kg but in reality you are 94.3 - 94.5kg on comp scales! You have to then lose 0.3-0.5kg by the end of the weigh in which is a maximum of an hour or they won't let you compete.

Bro's scales were out by 0.8kg but luckily he didn't drink any extra water and only had to lose 0.25kg to make 69kg. Not ideal.

Koing
 

killster1

Banned
Mar 15, 2007
6,205
475
126
so you really have no need for a super accurate scale.. as long as its consistent is all that matters.. ithink its funny you thought it would be fine on carpet ;P guess you not use scales much in your life.. i have 5$ glass digital one that is consistent i think they all work about the same as long as you stand in same spot one foot on each side and dont jump on before it says 0.0 its fine.
 

hans007

Lifer
Feb 1, 2000
20,212
18
81
I splurged for an omron 510 or something from amazon. Like $55 . pretty neat scale. Has a lot of interesting features
 
Last edited:

solsa

Member
Jul 27, 2014
109
0
0
The idea of knowing your body fat precentage sounds good but that kind of scales that actually work are not easy to find and they are pricey. Best is to get something simple and accurate. Sure, you can know if you are progressing if the scale is consistent but not accurate, but that does not make accuracy unimportant.
Here is a good list of accurate weight scales.
 

stylefungus

Junior Member
Nov 30, 2015
1
0
0
I have been in the scale business for 30 years and all I can say is that yes you can now and then get a good scale for little money but if you want the best reading a hard level surface is best. If you still cannot get good scale calibration then you may have to up your spending. I do not carry anything like this so dont look to me please but if you can spend a few extra bucks do it
 

Spineshank

Diamond Member
Jun 8, 2001
7,728
1
71
I use the regular one at the gym that counter balances your weight. The electronic scale ones are never reliable for me...

Yeah, my gym scale seems to be about 3 pounds off of my bathroom scale. But mine was like $20. Im sure the gym one is a little better.
 

Carson Dyle

Diamond Member
Jul 2, 2012
8,173
524
126
I have been in the scale business for 30 years and all I can say is that yes you can now and then get a good scale for little money but if you want the best reading a hard level surface is best. If you still cannot get good scale calibration then you may have to up your spending. I do not carry anything like this so dont look to me please but if you can spend a few extra bucks do it

It's basically common sense that a hard level surface is best. But how can you tell if you have "good scale calibration" short of using reference weights?

For someone who has been in the business for 30 years, even if you don't carry bathroom or medical scales, I would think you'd know enough to maybe make a recommendation or two.

About 10 or 12 years ago I bought a Detecto balance beam physician's scale for about $150. It's not as precise as I'd hoped. Depending on how you slide the balance, it can give you readings that vary by a pound or more. I've learned to do it exactly the same each time so that the readings are at least consistent. Someday I'm going to blow $400 or $500 on a good digital medical scale.