<< Yes I agree that it is RUDE, and most definately UNTRUE, but even if it is not racist, it is still an ignorant, generalization that should be left unsaid. >>
Hmmm, so you chide ME for being the "resident english teacher," yet you take it upon yourself to be the resident speech police???
<< The effect of the staement could arguably be just as offensive as a "racist" statement. I just don't get what AmusedOne is after here; prejudice, racism, bigotry, discrimaination etc..it's all bad, and hurtful. Is it the label of RACISM that he is having a problem with? I mean what's the point of arguing about semantics when someone has been insulted?
At worst, the people should be corrected in their usage of the word RACISM, but to me that is really insignificant. Is AmusedOne the resident English teacher here? >>
Hans, the charge of "racism" is one of the most damaging accusations one can level in today's society. More so than any social, or national bigotry charge.
We are all bigots in one way or another, as we all prefer one thing over another thing in our lives. The simple act of having an opinion makes us bigoted. And that opinion IS offensive and unpleasant to anyone who has the opposite opinion.
However, racism is an especially hurtful and damaging form of bigotry that goes far beyond what has been discussed. It's not "semantics," Hans. There is a distinct difference between insulting someone for something that is NOT inherent, i.e., culture, beliefs, politics, etc... and insulting someone for something that IS inherent, i.e., color, disability, looks, etc.
That you think this is insignificant only shows that you've taken this "hurtful" thing too far.
As Mwilding pointed out, we've become a nation of thin skinned pussies. People ARE going to have an opinion of you, your beliefs, your politics, and your country. Not ALL are going to be positive. Get over it.