Legends of Automotive History

Arkaign

Lifer
Oct 27, 2006
20,736
1,379
126
I'm going to start writing some short posts on cars that I think are legendary, and were/are serious influences on automotive history, culture, and perception. This is obviously a subjective/opinionated and largely unscientific endeavour, but I think it'll be fun regardless. Btw, the fact that I'm starting with the 3-series doesn't mean it ranks #1 in my opinion, it just happens to be the first in the series that I'll be writing. Others soon to follow will be the Corvette and Taurus (reasons to be explained at the time of release). Thanks for reading, hope you enjoy, and any and all feedback and posts will be welcomed heartily.

In today's automotive culture, it seems almost a given that the BMW 3 series is a well-respected and popular entry-level luxury car, though the rising excellence of competitors has somewhat diluted the dominance it once held in it's grasp.

In the beginning of our story, we have to look at BMW and their offerings. In Europe in the 60s, BMW had evolved a series of mid/small-sized sporty sedans and coupes that culminated with the 2002 in 1968. Americans weren't able to buy them outside of very rare circumstances, but the word was out amongst the enthusiasts : you can buy a classy, light, quick, and efficient car, and it handles like a dream! Successful imports by independent businessmen showed the potential for this recipe to be a success in North America.

After a few years of this small-time success, BMW decided to formally launch a North American presence in 1975, at the same time the 3-series was launching in Europe. A short two years passed, and in 1977 (the year I was born), the 3-series was premiered in the US, with the E21 320i models. Two engines were available, and though they produced just 100 and 110 hp respectively, they were quite competitive with other vehicles on the market in terms of power/weight. And of course that handling helped things along nicely. 2 door models were the only option, and the now-familiar 4-round-headlight look started lurking down many urban playgrounds in our country.

In 1982, BMW premiered the E30 revision, and things started to look much closer to what we have today. 4-door models, and even station wagons were produced, with many different engine models from economic 1.6L choices all the way to special 238hp Evo models. Even AWD was available on certain models. The luxury aspects increased, and this is the era when BMW really began to gain serious respect in the industry at large. It was very hard to find another vehicle that offered the same recipe of style and performance in such a package. In the era of ~200hp Vettes, the E30 M3 was a compelling statement of world-class performance in a practical package, quickly becoming the most successful road race car in history. Sales in the US skyrocketed for the entire 3-series linup. And other companies began looking closer at what was happening.

In 1991, BMW showed they were ready to bring the 3 series into the new decade with a further evolution of the vehicle. Ever more options and engine choices were offered, and the size of the vehicle crept up slightly to increase practicality. The trademark handling and style were carried over, aside from the enclosure of the classic BMW round-light front clip. Maximum power rose to 321hp on certain M3 models, and the 6-speed manual option was a fresh choice to contrast against the more common 5-speed options of competitors. By this time, the 3-series was becoming a ubiquitous, and somewhat generic, presence on our roads. Competitors, rightly jealous of the highly consistent sales numbers, began in earnest to try to field decent alternatives to this proven vehicle.

By 1998, when BMW released the E46 version, things had began to heat up. Audi, having gone through the doldrums of shoddy, underperforming vehicles for much of their previous years, had begun to produce cars which were truly worthy of a hard look. In 1997 their 2nd-gen S4 was released, and the overall package of AWD, Turbo, nicely sculped looks, and extensive options presented a real challenge to BMW's previously unquestioned dominance in the market they had almost single-handedly created. The normal A4 models were also respectable and well-balanced alternatives to the 3 series as well. BMW responded with a further evolution of their 3-series in the E46. It was hugely successful, and brought ever higher levels of refinement and performance to the table. During the same time, however, the field continued to widen. Makes such as Cadillac, Lexus, Infiniti and Acura joined a surprisingly diverse group of companies that wanted a piece of the lucrative sport-compact/entry market. Buying a 3-series was no longer a no-brainer decision.

That brings us to the new model, the E90/92/93 series. Two serious changes occur : the resurgence of a Forced Induction model, and the first-ever 8-cylinder 3 series. There are gadgets galore to choose from (and to annoy some), and the styling is the most controversial departure yet seen in a 3 series. The competition is better than ever, with 2nd, 3rd, and higher-gen vehicles from a dizzying array of competitors all offering unique counterpoint to the previously unchallenged dominance of BMW's self-created market.

What does all this mean? I think it can be said safely that if BMW hadn't started us down this road roughly 4 decades ago, we might not have such gems as the G35/G37 series, the CTS, the A4/S4, and so on. It was also a huge milestone in bridging the gap between luxury and performance, and the M3 series have proven that a healthy serving of both can be quite rewarding, both to car companies and to the drivers lucky enough to afford them. Is the 3 series perfect? Is it for everyone? Far from it, but it is nearly indisputably one of the most important cars in modern history. If you bought a new car in the last decade, there is a decent chance that the design was at least somewhat influenced by the venerable 3 series. What is in store for the future of the 3 series? I'm guessing we've seen most of the drastic changes already, my best fortune telling would reveal increases in fuel economy and overall efficiency, as opposed to ground-breaking performance leaps. It's only a matter of time before the dominance of the 3 series in the class that it created will be eclipsed by worthy competitors.

Thanks for reading. I welcome any/all feedback and comments.
 

exdeath

Lifer
Jan 29, 2004
13,679
10
81
"Americans weren't able to buy them outside of very rare circumstances"

Ah, explains why today the BMW emblem is coveted and by posers and flaunted as a status symbol by the American lower class leasing their way to the appearance of middle/upper class, when everywhere else in the world or to people with real money it's just another car.

Kind of the same thing with cell phones.

But still I don't know of any auto makers that compare to what BMW offers, they have kind of carved a niche for themselves. Sure there are better handling and more powerful sports cars, and there are more expensive and luxurious luxury cars, but there aren't a whole lot that have the perfect balance of sporty and luxury. It's a jack of all trades master of none ride that gives you a little bit of everything in equal proportions and I can't think of anyone that does that better than BMW.

In video games it's common to see cars with 100% on one slider and 25% on another slider, etc. A BMW is balanced and is like 50% on every single slider.
 

Arkaign

Lifer
Oct 27, 2006
20,736
1,379
126
Originally posted by: exdeath
"Americans weren't able to buy them outside of very rare circumstances"

Ah, explains why today the BMW emblem is coveted and by posers and flaunted as a status symbol by the American lower class leasing their way to the appearance of middle/upper class, when everywhere else in the world or to people with real money it's just another car.

Kind of the same thing with cell phones.

Americans weren't able to buy them outside of very rare circumstances because there was no BMW USA operation.

Any decent car might have a group of 'posers' that buy them. But the fact remains that the 3 series is *very* good at what it is. It basically created a class of car that didn't exist before : a performance-oriented light luxury class.

BTW, the American 'status symbol' is now having a 5,000lb SUV that goes to the mall and the grocery store.
 

exdeath

Lifer
Jan 29, 2004
13,679
10
81
Edited my post and added commentary on BMW.

Originally posted by: Arkaign
BTW, the American 'status symbol' is now having a 5,000lb SUV that goes to the mall and the grocery store.

With 26" chrome wheels, 15 TVs that are mounted so as to show people outside the vehicle how many TVs you have rather than for the passengers entertainment, and never more than two people in it, and has never seen a speck of mud...
 

Arkaign

Lifer
Oct 27, 2006
20,736
1,379
126
Originally posted by: exdeath
Edited my post and added commentary on BMW.

Originally posted by: Arkaign
BTW, the American 'status symbol' is now having a 5,000lb SUV that goes to the mall and the grocery store.

With 26" chrome wheels, 15 TVs that are mounted so as to show people outside the vehicle how many TVs you have rather than for the passengers entertainment, and never more than two people in it, and has never seen a speck of mud...

Thanks for your additional input. I think you're spot on. It wasn't always that way though, in the E30/E36 M3s, they truly were the masters of their domain. An E30 M3 was able to chew up the road well in excess of the Vettes of the era, and even step on the toes of things like Ferrari 328s and the like.

I think two things have changed :

(1)- Other makes have started offering models squarely targeted at the 3-series, usually RWD, small/midsized, good luxury features, and 'sporty'. The perfect example of this is the Cadillac CTS. Cadillac, which only a decade earlier seemed doomed to endlessly produce uninspiring blobs of mushy mediocrity, the automotive equivalent of Metamucil. Now they have 'V' versions, and very competitive suspension/transmission/engine options. Also notable are the G35/G37, TL, IS350, etc, etc.

(2)- HP war in the sports-car world and beyond. In the mid-90s, Camrys and Accords were dwelling in the 140-160hp range for the most part, and Vettes were only beginning to exceed the 300hp range. In this time frame, an M3 could be dominant of most cars, and competitive with most of the best, at a pretty reasonable price (for what it is). Flash forward to today, and even Hyundai is prepping a 300+hp V8 RWD model, Vettes are stratospherically awesome, the Accord is pimping nearly 300hp, and the CTS is perhaps the finest American sporty sedan to yet be released.

Both of these developments leave the 3-series a bit off the pace from their previous dominance. They are still excellent cars, but as you rightly say, they are merely well-rounded, and true masters of no particular domain.
 

exdeath

Lifer
Jan 29, 2004
13,679
10
81
Interesting, all cars like the G35 that I can think of that are similar to BMWs sport/luxury balance are all relatively new cars that haven't been out for a while...

I look at E46 M3 prices from time to time and ponder it as a daily no fuss no hassle cruiser when I'm in those in between moods where the Camry just doesn't cut it, but the Cobra is overbearing or I just don't want to drive it (dirt parking lots at fair grounds most recently).
 

Arkaign

Lifer
Oct 27, 2006
20,736
1,379
126
Originally posted by: exdeath
Interesting, all cars like the G35 that I can think of that are similar to BMWs sport/luxary balance are all relatively new cars that haven't been out for a while...

Yeah I think it took awhile for other companies to decide to tackle that market. It's good for us though, we have more good choices than ever before, and it's particularly awesome to see Cadillac representing the Americans with an excellent product.
 

ayabe

Diamond Member
Aug 10, 2005
7,449
0
0
Originally posted by: exdeath
Interesting, all cars like the G35 that I can think of that are similar to BMWs sport/luxury balance are all relatively new cars that haven't been out for a while...

I look at E46 M3 prices from time to time and ponder it as a daily no fuss no hassle cruiser when I'm in those in between moods where the Camry just doesn't cut it, but the Cobra is overbearing or I just don't want to drive it (dirt parking lots at fair grounds most recently).

Sounds like you need a Subaru :p
 

T2urtle

Diamond Member
Oct 18, 2004
3,432
3
81
Originally posted by: Arkaign
Originally posted by: exdeath
Edited my post and added commentary on BMW.

Originally posted by: Arkaign
BTW, the American 'status symbol' is now having a 5,000lb SUV that goes to the mall and the grocery store.

(1)- Other makes have started offering models squarely targeted at the 3-series, usually RWD, small/midsized, good luxury features, and 'sporty'. The perfect example of this is the Cadillac CTS. Cadillac, which only a decade earlier seemed doomed to endlessly produce uninspiring blobs of mushy mediocrity, the automotive equivalent of Metamucil. Now they have 'V' versions, and very competitive suspension/transmission/engine options. Also notable are the G35/G37, TL, IS350, etc, etc.

When introduced, the IS300 and the g35 were solely out to tackle the 3 series market. But it wasn't exactly fine tuned. Because Lexus still left their soft cushy ride in the IS300. The g35 gave the 3 series a good run for the money, both offered coupes and sedans, as well as X- platforms. One thing i felt that was on the g35 side was they backed it up with a VQ engine which gave it a SLIGHT edge.
 

Arkaign

Lifer
Oct 27, 2006
20,736
1,379
126
Originally posted by: JulesMaximus
Just what we need...more people sucking on BMW's ass.

Am I to assume that you don't like the CTS? The G35/37? The TL? Etc, etc?

I don't think everything BMW does is great, nor do I even think that the 3 series is still dominant in the class that it created, but I acknowledge its unique significance and historical excellence nonetheless.

What is it about BMW that polarizes people so much? Just some of the douchebag drivers? Because you get that with any brand to one degree or another. Well, except maybe the obviously embarrassing brands that nobody wants to talk about one way or the other.
 

JulesMaximus

No Lifer
Jul 3, 2003
74,584
985
126
Originally posted by: Arkaign
Originally posted by: JulesMaximus
Just what we need...more people sucking on BMW's ass.

Am I to assume that you don't like the CTS? The G35/37? The TL? Etc, etc?

I don't think everything BMW does is great, nor do I even think that the 3 series is still dominant in the class that it created, but I acknowledge its unique significance and historical excellence nonetheless.

What is it about BMW that polarizes people so much? Just some of the douchebag drivers? Because you get that with any brand to one degree or another. Well, except maybe the obviously embarrassing brands that nobody wants to talk about one way or the other.

I don't like the CTS. I do like the G35/37 and the TL though.

I've owned 2 BMW 3 series cars over the years. They were decent driving cars but they were fairly expensive to maintain and not very reliable.

BTW-I'm sure you've all heard this one before: What's the difference between a rose and a BMW?





















With a rose the prick is on the outside. :p
 

JulesMaximus

No Lifer
Jul 3, 2003
74,584
985
126
Originally posted by: DivideBYZero
Originally posted by: JulesMaximus
Just what we need...more people sucking on BMW's ass.

It will balance out those sucking on the teat of Lotus. ;)

Yeah, between Jeremy Clarkson and myself...that makes 2. :laugh:
 
Mar 10, 2005
14,647
2
0
Originally posted by: JulesMaximus
Originally posted by: DivideBYZero
Originally posted by: JulesMaximus
Just what we need...more people sucking on BMW's ass.

It will balance out those sucking on the teat of Lotus. ;)

Yeah, between Jeremy Clarkson and myself...that makes 2. :laugh:

there's a lotus dealership just ouside of boston. from what i've observed, sales were pretty good for such a marque. at least they were before the dollar lost value. if it were within reach, i would gladly take one home.

edit: if i had my pick of the bunch, the 2002 is on the short list. is there a work-around for the last cylinder oil starvation?
 

DarkThinker

Platinum Member
Mar 17, 2007
2,822
0
0
Originally posted by: DivideBYZero
Originally posted by: JulesMaximus
Just what we need...more people sucking on BMW's ass.

It will balance out those sucking on the teat of Lotus. ;)

I was just thinking....it would have been interesting to see how well JulesMaximus would have scored on the Top-Gear Cock`o`Meter that one time he drove the Lotus :p
 

Arkaign

Lifer
Oct 27, 2006
20,736
1,379
126
Originally posted by: DarkThinker
Originally posted by: DivideBYZero
Originally posted by: JulesMaximus
Just what we need...more people sucking on BMW's ass.

It will balance out those sucking on the teat of Lotus. ;)

I was just thinking....it would have been interesting to see how well JulesMaximus would have scored on the Top-Gear Cock`o`Meter that one time he drove the Lotus :p

lol ... "we have a NEW RECORD!!!!"
 

rh71

No Lifer
Aug 28, 2001
52,844
1,049
126
BMW, IBM... innovators. They will face their critics but at the end of the day... they're still the giants for being at the forefront.
 

alimoalem

Diamond Member
Sep 22, 2005
4,025
0
0
Originally posted by: rh71
BMW, IBM... innovators. They will face their critics but at the end of the day... they're still the giants for being at the forefront.

qft