Local or nationwide? The nationwide plan with the largest included area (area not subject to roaming charges) for the monthly rate is probably Verizon's America's choice.
The current promo for AC includes 4000 night and weekend minutes.
$35 only gets you 300 weekday minutes (more minutes = more money), but the overall national footprint is awesome if you need it. Verizon is supposed to be pretty good in NJ, no?