Just Curious... how much has the illegal problem in California has contributed to their economic fall out?

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

echo4747

Golden Member
Jun 22, 2005
1,979
156
106
In a recent telephone poll conducted in Ca. The question was asked How much of a problem do illegal aliens present to the state?

-30% of the respondents said it was a big problem
-70% peplied " No es problema"
 

mugs

Lifer
Apr 29, 2003
48,920
46
91

Xavier434

Lifer
Oct 14, 2002
10,373
1
0
Originally posted by: compuwiz1
Pssst, the illegals are not just in California. This is an everywhere problem.

This.

Does anyone want to talk about how Texas sets up their real borders 100 miles from their actual state borders in order to keep the cheap illegal labor in the state but away from the major cities? Next we can talk about how they hardly offer any social services to help out their legal citizens progress which also means that the illegals don't get jack either. Punish the legals to restrict the illegals? Meh...




The bottom line is that we are in way too deep over our heads. The process to become a legal citizen takes years and can be expensive. We have tons of illegals here which become legal after being here so long anyways. Their kids automatically become citizens which is all most of them ever hope for anyways. Our border patrols are not effective enough to really put a lid on the problem. The government and our people will NEVER search for them proactively and send them back home because it separates families and in some cases all we would be doing is sending them back home to go straight to prison (see Cuba). We all know they could do that if they really wanted to, but the reality of situation is that such an idea ever making it through legislation and signed into law is a pipe dream and might as well be forgotten.

I think we should start by doing two things. First, come up with a very efficient border patrol plan. Second, a complete overhaul of the system so that becoming legal is far more efficient, faster, and much cheaper. These two things need to be done simultaneously. Both of those parts are extremely important because that puts a lid on the problem and sets us up to effectively fix the current issues already within our borders. This overhaul will include making the current standards for NEW people trying to become a citizen from the outside much higher. I don't see any other way to heavily reduce the number of illegals coming into the country to the point where it is much more reasonable. As long as this country is a great place to be, they will continue to pour in unless we do that.

Next, we need to cut our losses somewhat. Since we will never see hardly any of the illegals sent home, we would be in a better off doing whatever we can to convince as many of them as possible to come forth and go through the process of becoming legal. We need to make the process for them very cheap if not free and we need to make the process faster which was what the overhaul was all about. If they are criminals then they don't Pass Go, but pretty much all of the other ones get in.

Now, I know a lot of conservatives really hate that cutting the losses idea but let's face the facts. They are already here leeching off the system and they are never going home at any rate that exceeds that which they are coming in. I hate it too, but we need to accept it. Allowing these people to basically be grandfathered into the system as long as they do not have a criminal record can only help us because then we will see them paying more in taxes and less will be able to abuse social service. Remember, just because they are illegal that doesn't mean they are lazy or poor and those that are....again, they are already here and they are here to stay.
 

shira

Diamond Member
Jan 12, 2005
9,500
6
81

shira

Diamond Member
Jan 12, 2005
9,500
6
81
Originally posted by: mugs
Forms printed in spanish are not an expense that you can attribute to illegal immigration.

Originally posted by: rpanic
10.5B a year in 2004.

http://www.washingtontimes.com.../20041206-102115-6766r

LA Times 2009, some of the costs.

http://www.latimes.com/news/lo...feb02,0,4875070.column

First link says $7.7 billion is for K-12 education, which is mostly paid for by property taxes. Everyone pays property taxes either directly or indirectly unless they are homeless.

Yes. Illegals pay their rent, which pays for the property owner's property taxes.

Of course, right-wing reactionaries only want to look at the debit side of the equation. What morons.
 

StormRider

Diamond Member
Mar 12, 2000
8,324
2
0
Originally posted by: Jaskalas
Originally posted by: wwswimming
Originally posted by: Citrixwhat would happen if Conan raised is sword of power and said with a mighty voice. NO MORE!

the food would rot in the fields and the trucks would have much less food to deliver
to the stores.

Sounds like ten million new American jobs.

Yeah, but I sometimes think that the "illegals" do a better job because they are probably grateful for being able to work here and feel that if they do good they will be rewarded in the end.

By contrast, some American kids might be so bored or pissed off working at Burger King, they might decide to take a bath in the sink and film it for youtube or spit in your food while you're not looking.
 

Drako

Lifer
Jun 9, 2007
10,697
161
106
The criminal population of California Jails is approaching 50% illegals.

Think of the money we could save by deporting them.
 

CrackRabbit

Lifer
Mar 30, 2001
16,642
62
91
Originally posted by: Xavier434


I think we should start by doing two things. First, come up with a very efficient border patrol plan. Second, a complete overhaul of the system so that becoming legal is far more efficient, faster, and much cheaper. These two things need to be done simultaneously. Both of those parts are extremely important because that puts a lid on the problem and sets us up to effectively fix the current issues already within our borders. This overhaul will include making the current standards for NEW people trying to become a citizen from the outside much higher. I don't see any other way to heavily reduce the number of illegals coming into the country to the point where it is much more reasonable. As long as this country is a great place to be, they will continue to pour in unless we do that.

Next, we need to cut our losses somewhat. Since we will never see hardly any of the illegals sent home, we would be in a better off doing whatever we can to convince as many of them as possible to come forth and go through the process of becoming legal. We need to make the process for them very cheap if not free and we need to make the process faster which was what the overhaul was all about. If they are criminals then they don't Pass Go, but pretty much all of the other ones get in.

Yes! I have been saying this for a long time now.
 

dahunan

Lifer
Jan 10, 2002
18,191
3
0
Originally posted by: StormRider
Originally posted by: Jaskalas
Originally posted by: wwswimming
Originally posted by: Citrixwhat would happen if Conan raised is sword of power and said with a mighty voice. NO MORE!

the food would rot in the fields and the trucks would have much less food to deliver
to the stores.

Sounds like ten million new American jobs.

Yeah, but I sometimes think that the "illegals" do a better job because they are probably grateful for being able to work here and feel that if they do good they will be rewarded in the end.

By contrast, some American kids might be so bored or pissed off working at Burger King, they might decide to take a bath in the sink and film it for youtube or spit in your food while you're not looking.

^^^ Agreed... American children are lazy and have too much entitlement belief.. as though the system and their parents owe them.

If no illegals were here to do farm labor and such I would bet that Americans would bitch and moan about farm labor and get stupid politicians to force some changes in pay and such which in turn would require them to demand higher prices for their product.

But one of the frustrating things is Illegals are being hired on as drywall and concrete and construction laborers .. thereby lowering the wages of all legal citizens who wish to do this work
 

cyclohexane

Platinum Member
Feb 12, 2005
2,837
19
81
Originally posted by: Xavier434
Originally posted by: compuwiz1
Pssst, the illegals are not just in California. This is an everywhere problem.

This.

Does anyone want to talk about how Texas sets up their real borders 100 miles from their actual state borders in order to keep the cheap illegal labor in the state but away from the major cities? Next we can talk about how they hardly offer any social services to help out their legal citizens progress which also means that the illegals don't get jack either. Punish the legals to restrict the illegals? Meh...




The bottom line is that we are in way too deep over our heads. The process to become a legal citizen takes years and can be expensive. We have tons of illegals here which become legal after being here so long anyways. Their kids automatically become citizens which is all most of them ever hope for anyways. Our border patrols are not effective enough to really put a lid on the problem. The government and our people will NEVER search for them proactively and send them back home because it separates families and in some cases all we would be doing is sending them back home to go straight to prison (see Cuba). We all know they could do that if they really wanted to, but the reality of situation is that such an idea ever making it through legislation and signed into law is a pipe dream and might as well be forgotten.

I think we should start by doing two things. First, come up with a very efficient border patrol plan. Second, a complete overhaul of the system so that becoming legal is far more efficient, faster, and much cheaper. These two things need to be done simultaneously. Both of those parts are extremely important because that puts a lid on the problem and sets us up to effectively fix the current issues already within our borders. This overhaul will include making the current standards for NEW people trying to become a citizen from the outside much higher. I don't see any other way to heavily reduce the number of illegals coming into the country to the point where it is much more reasonable. As long as this country is a great place to be, they will continue to pour in unless we do that.

Next, we need to cut our losses somewhat. Since we will never see hardly any of the illegals sent home, we would be in a better off doing whatever we can to convince as many of them as possible to come forth and go through the process of becoming legal. We need to make the process for them very cheap if not free and we need to make the process faster which was what the overhaul was all about. If they are criminals then they don't Pass Go, but pretty much all of the other ones get in.

Now, I know a lot of conservatives really hate that cutting the losses idea but let's face the facts. They are already here leeching off the system and they are never going home at any rate that exceeds that which they are coming in. I hate it too, but we need to accept it. Allowing these people to basically be grandfathered into the system as long as they do not have a criminal record can only help us because then we will see them paying more in taxes and less will be able to abuse social service. Remember, just because they are illegal that doesn't mean they are lazy or poor and those that are....again, they are already here and they are here to stay.

sounds like a sound plan. OP should run for governor of Ca.
 

Socio

Golden Member
May 19, 2002
1,732
2
81
Originally posted by: shira

Again, this report doesn't indicate how much illegals pay into the system.

In many, many cases, state income axes are withheld from the pay of illegals, but they don't file tax returns and don't get valid refunds.

That would be the exception not the rule, even then they could only be using either a fake Social Security number or a stolen one as they can not obtain a real one due to their illegal status.

The fact is the only taxes they all pay are taxes like sales taxes, gas taxes because they can not be avoided.
 

StormRider

Diamond Member
Mar 12, 2000
8,324
2
0
Originally posted by: Socio
Originally posted by: shira

Again, this report doesn't indicate how much illegals pay into the system.

In many, many cases, state income axes are withheld from the pay of illegals, but they don't file tax returns and don't get valid refunds.

That would be the exception not the rule, even then they could only be using either a fake Social Security number or a stolen one as they can not obtain a real one due to their illegal status.

The fact is the only taxes they all pay are taxes like sales taxes, gas taxes because they can not be avoided.

You neglect to mention the benefit that their lower wages also means lower prices for all. Most people say they are willing to pay higher prices if it means hiring more US workers but don't realize the impact having to pay higher prices means until it hits them -- witness the pain from higher gas, energy and food prices.

To me no matter what happens with "illegals" in the end we will all pay some type of cost. Whether that cost goes into higher prices for products or whether it goes into subsidizing some of the wages for undocumented workers and their families. Personally, I would rather have the later because I truly feel that immigrants (whether "illegal" or "legal") provide a net positive benefit to our country -- it has always been this way and I don't see why it shouldn't be this way now or in the future.

 

rpanic

Golden Member
Dec 1, 2006
1,896
7
81
Originally posted by: shira
Originally posted by: mugs
Forms printed in spanish are not an expense that you can attribute to illegal immigration.

Originally posted by: rpanic
10.5B a year in 2004.

http://www.washingtontimes.com.../20041206-102115-6766r

LA Times 2009, some of the costs.

http://www.latimes.com/news/lo...feb02,0,4875070.column

First link says $7.7 billion is for K-12 education, which is mostly paid for by property taxes. Everyone pays property taxes either directly or indirectly unless they are homeless.

Yes. Illegals pay their rent, which pays for the property owner's property taxes.

Of course, right-wing reactionaries only want to look at the debit side of the equation. What morons.

2 to 5 families of illegals living in a house or apartment are not paying much compared to what they are costing our schools. And those are just the costs that don?t even count the loss of quality, so citizens either move to areas with better schools or pay for private school.

Why have schools deteriorated so much in California? I know I would never put my kids in some of the schools I went to as a child now because of them.

They don?t pay anything near to what they take in services.
 

MovingTarget

Diamond Member
Jun 22, 2003
9,002
115
106
Originally posted by: boomerang
Originally posted by: MovingTarget
Originally posted by: piasabird
People in California like slaves.

Yeah, them Okies aren't as cheap as the used to be! :p

So, lets see....

Drain on law enforcement: check
Depress wages in job markets: check
Fewer opportunities for citizens and legal immigrants: check
Drain on public services and infrastructure: check
Increase in fraud over taxes (from SS fraud): check

I'd say they are a drain. California is being overrun at this point. Too bad it has become too much of a feel-good political hot potato for the government to actually DO anything about it.
You forgot the most important one.

Pelosi sees no problem with any of it and would like to see the entire U.S. sharing the burden: check

It isn't just Pelosi. I have yet to see any party get serious about immigration reform. Besides, Californians pretty much have to support it as they would love to export some of their illegal population to the rest of the states.
 

chess9

Elite member
Apr 15, 2000
7,748
0
0
Originally posted by: shira
Originally posted by: mugs
Forms printed in spanish are not an expense that you can attribute to illegal immigration.

Originally posted by: rpanic
10.5B a year in 2004.

http://www.washingtontimes.com.../20041206-102115-6766r

LA Times 2009, some of the costs.

http://www.latimes.com/news/lo...feb02,0,4875070.column

First link says $7.7 billion is for K-12 education, which is mostly paid for by property taxes. Everyone pays property taxes either directly or indirectly unless they are homeless.

Yes. Illegals pay their rent, which pays for the property owner's property taxes.

Of course, right-wing reactionaries only want to look at the debit side of the equation. What morons.

Three great 'hits' in a row! You should be batting cleanup for the Indians. (They need the help.)

Anyway, yes, blaming the illegals is easy to do. If all illegals left California tomorrow, a Friday, by Monday the state would be in total gridlock.

The people who give their blood sweat and tears for this country have never gotten their due. As I noted in another thread, this has happened to the Chinese, the Blacks, WOMEN, Jews (Triangle Shirt Waist Factory Fire?), Hispanics, Italians :) , and Native Americans. In the 1850's the goldrushers were putting Indians into slavery in CALI. They also killed a lot of them.

Take a close look at American history and it ain't pretty.

-Robert
 

Budmantom

Lifer
Aug 17, 2002
13,103
1
81
Originally posted by: Drako
The criminal population of California Jails is approaching 50% illegals.

Think of the money we could save by deporting them.


(let me see if I can put a liberal spin on this)

They are creating jobs for Californians!!!
 

Budmantom

Lifer
Aug 17, 2002
13,103
1
81
Originally posted by: shira
Originally posted by: mugs
Forms printed in spanish are not an expense that you can attribute to illegal immigration.

Originally posted by: rpanic
10.5B a year in 2004.

http://www.washingtontimes.com.../20041206-102115-6766r

LA Times 2009, some of the costs.

http://www.latimes.com/news/lo...feb02,0,4875070.column

First link says $7.7 billion is for K-12 education, which is mostly paid for by property taxes. Everyone pays property taxes either directly or indirectly unless they are homeless.

Yes. Illegals pay their rent, which pays for the property owner's property taxes.

Of course, right-wing reactionaries only want to look at the debit side of the equation. What morons.

So if they were deported it would bring rental prices down?

Sounds like a positive to me.

 

Budmantom

Lifer
Aug 17, 2002
13,103
1
81
Originally posted by: echo4747
In a recent telephone poll conducted in Ca. The question was asked How much of a problem do illegal aliens present to the state?

-30% of the respondents said it was a big problem
-70% peplied " No es problema"



LOL

 

WaTaGuMp

Lifer
May 10, 2001
21,207
2,506
126
Originally posted by: wwswimming
Originally posted by: Citrixwhat would happen if Conan raised is sword of power and said with a mighty voice. NO MORE!

the food would rot in the fields and the trucks would have much less food to deliver
to the stores.

watch the "illegals" work for 5 minutes on a hot day and it might change your
perspective. they bust their asses doing work that most Americans are too
spoiled to do.

i've lived around the "illegals" for about 30 years and i have no problem with
them. 2 of my 4 neighbors are "illegals" and they are good neighbors - quiet,
help pitch in taking care of the building, etc.

The problem isn't just about people being spoiled, if the pay was worth it people would take the jobs. The issue is then prices would rise and people would then bitch. I personally feel if things had to cost more to get rid of illegals then so be it. We have a business here in Cali and a few other states called In N Out burger, PLENTY of white people work there because they take care of the employees, its fast food yet the income and benefits are worth working there.
 

JACKDRUID

Senior member
Nov 28, 2007
729
0
0
Originally posted by: Citrix
im just curious. i dont live in cali but i hear about and have read about the big money problem they are having out there. and i got to thinking. cali is pretty liberal with paying and enabling illegals to live in the state. how much money does the state of cali pay out in social serives that directly benifits illegals? you know things like public schools. thousands of government forms printed in spanish, healthcare....


what would happen if Conan raised is sword of power and said with a mighty voice. NO MORE!

ALOT less than a friction compare to what we spend on military, needless tax reduction for rich people, wasteful spending for the last 8 years.
 

Socio

Golden Member
May 19, 2002
1,732
2
81
Originally posted by: StormRider
Originally posted by: Socio
Originally posted by: shira

Again, this report doesn't indicate how much illegals pay into the system.

In many, many cases, state income axes are withheld from the pay of illegals, but they don't file tax returns and don't get valid refunds.

That would be the exception not the rule, even then they could only be using either a fake Social Security number or a stolen one as they can not obtain a real one due to their illegal status.

The fact is the only taxes they all pay are taxes like sales taxes, gas taxes because they can not be avoided.

You neglect to mention the benefit that their lower wages also means lower prices for all. Most people say they are willing to pay higher prices if it means hiring more US workers but don't realize the impact having to pay higher prices means until it hits them -- witness the pain from higher gas, energy and food prices.

To me no matter what happens with "illegals" in the end we will all pay some type of cost. Whether that cost goes into higher prices for products or whether it goes into subsidizing some of the wages for undocumented workers and their families. Personally, I would rather have the later because I truly feel that immigrants (whether "illegal" or "legal") provide a net positive benefit to our country -- it has always been this way and I don't see why it shouldn't be this way now or in the future.

A, The ONLY one that profits from illegals are their employer! We could very well be paying the same price for goods with minimum wage, tax paying workers with the employer taking a hit on his profit or at least made to compete fairly with everyone else who has hired legal immigrant and American employees.

B, Besides that, saving 25 cents on a loaf of bread is not by any stretch of the imagination worth the Billions of dollars a year they cost, thus they are not , have not and never will be a benefit, they are a 100% detriment.
 

WaTaGuMp

Lifer
May 10, 2001
21,207
2,506
126
Originally posted by: Socio
Originally posted by: StormRider
Originally posted by: Socio
Originally posted by: shira

Again, this report doesn't indicate how much illegals pay into the system.

In many, many cases, state income axes are withheld from the pay of illegals, but they don't file tax returns and don't get valid refunds.

That would be the exception not the rule, even then they could only be using either a fake Social Security number or a stolen one as they can not obtain a real one due to their illegal status.

The fact is the only taxes they all pay are taxes like sales taxes, gas taxes because they can not be avoided.

You neglect to mention the benefit that their lower wages also means lower prices for all. Most people say they are willing to pay higher prices if it means hiring more US workers but don't realize the impact having to pay higher prices means until it hits them -- witness the pain from higher gas, energy and food prices.

To me no matter what happens with "illegals" in the end we will all pay some type of cost. Whether that cost goes into higher prices for products or whether it goes into subsidizing some of the wages for undocumented workers and their families. Personally, I would rather have the later because I truly feel that immigrants (whether "illegal" or "legal") provide a net positive benefit to our country -- it has always been this way and I don't see why it shouldn't be this way now or in the future.

A, The ONLY one that profits from illegals are their employer! We could very well be paying the same price for goods with minimum wage, tax paying workers with the employer taking a hit on his profit or at least made to compete fairly with everyone else who has hired legal immigrant and American employees.

B, Besides that, saving 25 cents on a loaf of bread is not by any stretch of the imagination worth the Billions of dollars a year they cost, thus they are not , have not and never will be a benefit, they are a 100% detriment.

Hence lies another issue, the companies don't want to take a hit on their profits. Not to mention if the company is a publicly traded company they wanna try and maintain profitability because of share holders. So not JUST the company profits from it, but for the most part I agree.