Just a random thought about bailouts profits and outsourcing

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

halik

Lifer
Oct 10, 2000
25,696
1
81
Originally posted by: Robor
Originally posted by: Pneumothorax
Originally posted by: TheRedUnderURBed

I have a lot of respect for union guys pouring steel for 40 years, a lot more then the guy who landed the 100k a year job because he can kiss the best ass.
Edit: It sounds like I am trying to start a blue/white collar flame war but I am sleepy, time to work. Yay 6am, flame me if you want.

That's the problem with the "Big 3" and alot of the financials, most of them are run by the "good 'ol boy's club CEO's" coming out of Ivy league schools and such. Like "Yeah, I knew your father when we went to Yale together, so I'm giving you this $1,000,000 per year job."
In contrast, the top 30+ execs salaries at Toyota (all added up) equals Ford Mullaly CEO's pay. And who loses billions and who makes billions?

Is that (bolded) 100% accurate? If so, WTF!? :shocked:

Yeah got link?
 

Pneumothorax

Golden Member
Nov 4, 2002
1,182
23
81
Originally posted by: halik

Yeah got link?

Here Toyota Exec earns less than 1 mil

And Here "Even before this auto sales meltdown, the Japanese automaker?s top ten execs earned less money COMBINED than Ford?s Alan Mulally, Chrysler?s Bob Nardelli and GM?s Rick Wagoner (individually)"

It states all the Toyota Execs total earn $40.5 million. I think I misquoted it should've been the top 10 (oops my bad, I'll own up to it) (Skulks in corner with dunce cap)
 

Engineer

Elite Member
Oct 9, 1999
39,230
701
126
Originally posted by: masteryoda34
US workers in Japanese based manufacturing plants in the US make significantly less than their Big Three counterparts. (When you calculate all benefits, pensions, etc.)

Maybe but Toyota in Georgetown, KY topped the average pay/benefits of the "current" UAW employee on the assembly line last year in pay/benefits. Seems it's the legacy workers (previous pensions, healthcare, etc.) that has the big 3 under the bus.
 

brandonbull

Diamond Member
May 3, 2005
6,365
1,223
126
Originally posted by: TheRedUnderURBed
Originally posted by: bozack
Originally posted by: Ozoned
Outsourcing is a function of the free market. Ultimately, it is the consumer that decides if it will succeed or fail. Organize your community, quit buying cheap shit, and the jobs will come back.

Outsorcing isn't always about cheap, in some cases scaleability is the major issue with price a secondary conern.

Some areas certain trades and the labor to support them are a dying breed and were before many started to outsource.

It is unfortunate as I think manufacturing is nothing to be ashamed of but it appears that many in the US don't aspire to be a factory worker, tailor, or laborer and thus not much emphasis is placed on training for such jobs...combine that wtih unions that keep costs of labor high and when compared to other companies you are already behind.

If we actually manufactured stuff again unions would have more of a place, sell more then you buy is such a simple concept. Training our people to be office cubicle zombies will bite us in the ass sooner or later.
And you say actual tradesmen are overpaid?
Management on their fat asses and grown men on the phone/front of a computer all day is not exactly "hard work", not the kind that built the middle class.
I have a lot of respect for union guys pouring steel for 40 years, a lot more then the guy who landed the 100k a year job because he can kiss the best ass.
Edit: It sounds like I am trying to start a blue/white collar flame war but I am sleepy, time to work. Yay 6am, flame me if you want.

Pouring steel for 40 years sounds like a mindless task for someone who wishes to take the easy road. I had to pay for my own training/education by way of college and I have to continue to pay and work for my training because I don't sit back and do mindless factory work.
 

Steeplerot

Lifer
Mar 29, 2004
13,051
6
81
Originally posted by: brandonbull


Pouring steel for 40 years sounds like a mindless task for someone who wishes to take the easy road. I had to pay for my own training/education by way of college and I have to continue to pay and work for my training because I don't sit back and do mindless factory work.
In other words,
You went into debt to be a person with no skill in actually producing anything, it is not looking good for this country.
 

alien42

Lifer
Nov 28, 2004
12,876
3,303
136
Originally posted by: TheRedUnderURBed
Originally posted by: bozack
Originally posted by: Ozoned
Outsourcing is a function of the free market. Ultimately, it is the consumer that decides if it will succeed or fail. Organize your community, quit buying cheap shit, and the jobs will come back.

Outsorcing isn't always about cheap, in some cases scaleability is the major issue with price a secondary conern.

Some areas certain trades and the labor to support them are a dying breed and were before many started to outsource.

It is unfortunate as I think manufacturing is nothing to be ashamed of but it appears that many in the US don't aspire to be a factory worker, tailor, or laborer and thus not much emphasis is placed on training for such jobs...combine that wtih unions that keep costs of labor high and when compared to other companies you are already behind.

If we actually manufactured stuff again unions would have more of a place, sell more then you buy is such a simple concept. Training our people to be office cubicle zombies will bite us in the ass sooner or later.
And you say actual tradesmen are overpaid?
Management on their fat asses and grown men on the phone/front of a computer all day is not exactly "hard work", not the kind that built the middle class.
I have a lot of respect for union guys pouring steel for 40 years, a lot more then the guy who landed the 100k a year job because he can kiss the best ass.
Edit: It sounds like I am trying to start a blue/white collar flame war but I am sleepy, time to work. Yay 6am, flame me if you want.

you seem to have quite the anti-intellectual and anti-progressive ideas. maybe the 1800's would have suited you better. come to think of it, wtf are you doing on the internet?
 

ElFenix

Elite Member
Super Moderator
Mar 20, 2000
102,405
8,583
126
so if the mexican/chinese/indian/vietnamese/whereeverese were insourced you'd be ok with that?
 

JS80

Lifer
Oct 24, 2005
26,271
7
81
Originally posted by: TheRedUnderURBed
If we have to bail these guys out then whatever, I am fine with a LOAN to be paid back by US taxpayers.
But why should it not be attached to a clause like "No more outsourcing".

I hear the arguments for outsourcing "to stay competitive in a global economy etc." and they got their way. And yet they still failed miserably all the time paying crap wages in Mexico and India and stuff.
And now they want US Taxpayers money? The same ones who they layed off?

Makes them seem twice as incompetent when thought of this way, not considering that other countries doing well (Japan) can afford to pay union wages to their Domestic employees.

Your thoughts? Am I off base here?

Because ideas like that are exactly what causes economic weakness.
 

Steeplerot

Lifer
Mar 29, 2004
13,051
6
81
Originally posted by: JS80


Because ideas like that are exactly what causes economic weakness.

Uhh, yeah, actually producing something to sell is the downfall of our economy.

If you haven't noticed, outsourcing our industry and training our workers to be cubicle zombies has been a fail for us.
 

Steeplerot

Lifer
Mar 29, 2004
13,051
6
81
Originally posted by: alien42


you seem to have quite the anti-intellectual and anti-progressive ideas. maybe the 1800's would have suited you better. come to think of it, wtf are you doing on the internet?

Nothing anti-intellectual or anti-progressive about actually having something to show for your WORK.
Guess you are trying to show that good 21st century hard-working American spirit you hear so much about.
No wonder we are known as lazy fatasses worldwide.
 

CaptainGoodnight

Golden Member
Oct 13, 2000
1,427
30
91
Originally posted by: masteryoda34
Some general numbers off the top of my head that I caught on a newscast the other day.

Big Three Average Labor Cost ~ $73 / hour / worker (With all benefits, etc included.)

Domestic Japanese Plant Labor Cost ~ $45 / hour / worker (With all benefits, etc.)

Also, the difference is that the Domestic Japanese Plant workers still have their jobs.
 

JS80

Lifer
Oct 24, 2005
26,271
7
81
Originally posted by: TheRedUnderURBed
Originally posted by: JS80


Because ideas like that are exactly what causes economic weakness.

Uhh, yeah, actually producing something to sell is the downfall of our economy.

If you haven't noticed, outsourcing our industry and training our workers to be cubicle zombies has been a fail for us.

How can you even have a valid opinion on trade when you have no idea how trade theory works? Keep digging that ignoramus hole.
 

Strk

Lifer
Nov 23, 2003
10,197
4
76
Originally posted by: brandonbull
Originally posted by: TheRedUnderURBed
Originally posted by: bozack
Originally posted by: Ozoned
Outsourcing is a function of the free market. Ultimately, it is the consumer that decides if it will succeed or fail. Organize your community, quit buying cheap shit, and the jobs will come back.

Outsorcing isn't always about cheap, in some cases scaleability is the major issue with price a secondary conern.

Some areas certain trades and the labor to support them are a dying breed and were before many started to outsource.

It is unfortunate as I think manufacturing is nothing to be ashamed of but it appears that many in the US don't aspire to be a factory worker, tailor, or laborer and thus not much emphasis is placed on training for such jobs...combine that wtih unions that keep costs of labor high and when compared to other companies you are already behind.

If we actually manufactured stuff again unions would have more of a place, sell more then you buy is such a simple concept. Training our people to be office cubicle zombies will bite us in the ass sooner or later.
And you say actual tradesmen are overpaid?
Management on their fat asses and grown men on the phone/front of a computer all day is not exactly "hard work", not the kind that built the middle class.
I have a lot of respect for union guys pouring steel for 40 years, a lot more then the guy who landed the 100k a year job because he can kiss the best ass.
Edit: It sounds like I am trying to start a blue/white collar flame war but I am sleepy, time to work. Yay 6am, flame me if you want.

Pouring steel for 40 years sounds like a mindless task for someone who wishes to take the easy road. I had to pay for my own training/education by way of college and I have to continue to pay and work for my training because I don't sit back and do mindless factory work.

As opposed to writing code for 40 years, which is fun and exciting......
 

Xavier434

Lifer
Oct 14, 2002
10,373
1
0
Originally posted by: brandonbull
Pouring steel for 40 years sounds like a mindless task for someone who wishes to take the easy road. I had to pay for my own training/education by way of college and I have to continue to pay and work for my training because I don't sit back and do mindless factory work.

How many hours have you spent working in the manufacturing industry which allows you to make such a statement in some sort of credible and educated fashion?

...or are you just blowing smoke because you have some kind of superiority complex over them?
 

brandonbull

Diamond Member
May 3, 2005
6,365
1,223
126
Originally posted by: Xavier434
Originally posted by: brandonbull
Pouring steel for 40 years sounds like a mindless task for someone who wishes to take the easy road. I had to pay for my own training/education by way of college and I have to continue to pay and work for my training because I don't sit back and do mindless factory work.

How many hours have you spent working in the manufacturing industry which allows you to make such a statement in some sort of credible and educated fashion?

...or are you just blowing smoke because you have some kind of superiority complex over them?

I spent the better part of 12 years between a tour in the US Navy and another 7 years working full time as a electricain/maintenance mechanic to put myself into a "superiority complex" by getting an MIS degree. One job I worked where they did plastic extrustion for the medical and airline industries and the other was making styrofoam cups.

Is that good enough for you?

I stand by my opinion on factory work.
 

Xavier434

Lifer
Oct 14, 2002
10,373
1
0
Originally posted by: brandonbull
Originally posted by: Xavier434
Originally posted by: brandonbull
Pouring steel for 40 years sounds like a mindless task for someone who wishes to take the easy road. I had to pay for my own training/education by way of college and I have to continue to pay and work for my training because I don't sit back and do mindless factory work.

How many hours have you spent working in the manufacturing industry which allows you to make such a statement in some sort of credible and educated fashion?

...or are you just blowing smoke because you have some kind of superiority complex over them?

I spent the better part of 12 years between a tour in the US Navy and another 7 years working full time as a electricain/maintenance mechanic to put myself into a "superiority complex" by getting an MIS degree. One job I worked where they did plastic extrustion for the medical and airline industries and the other was making styrofoam cups.

Is that good enough for you?

I stand by my opinion on factory work.

That justifies your experience, but not a superiority complex which is nothing but counter productive. You have the right to your opinion about what is and isn't a mindless job, but do you equate what you consider mindless work to less important work? Personally, I think that the manufacturing of aluminum and copper materials is incredibly crucial to this country considering how much we use it. That is by far more important than say developing the next state of the art HDTV even though that task is far more complex and requires the minds of great electrical engineers amongst other things.

Besides, manufacturing jobs are the only thing many of these people know. Many of these workers have no other skills and they do not have a military career to back them up which might help them with financial aid to go to college. What would you have these people do? Get laid off thanks to automation only to find no other work and resorting to crime or social services in order to make ends meet for their families? That sounds really expensive and pointless. I don't want to hold up progress, but how many people's lives do we have to crush in order to do it? Where is the line drawn and why?
 

Steeplerot

Lifer
Mar 29, 2004
13,051
6
81
Originally posted by: brandonbull
Originally posted by: Xavier434
Originally posted by: brandonbull
Pouring steel for 40 years sounds like a mindless task for someone who wishes to take the easy road. I had to pay for my own training/education by way of college and I have to continue to pay and work for my training because I don't sit back and do mindless factory work.

How many hours have you spent working in the manufacturing industry which allows you to make such a statement in some sort of credible and educated fashion?

...or are you just blowing smoke because you have some kind of superiority complex over them?

I spent the better part of 12 years between a tour in the US Navy and another 7 years working full time as a electricain/maintenance mechanic to put myself into a "superiority complex" by getting an MIS degree. One job I worked where they did plastic extrustion for the medical and airline industries and the other was making styrofoam cups.

Is that good enough for you?

I stand by my opinion on factory work.

In the end it is your opinion, some men like using their hands and creating things, some like to sit behind a desk and kiss ass.
Both jobs are necessary, but in the long term I would much rather have a skilled US workforce who can actually produce things, fix their own stuff (it is sad how few young men I know have any clue how to repair their own cars/washing machines/etc. never poured concrete, layed a brick, painted a house) in case or economy ever went sour we are not going to climb our way back up to the top with interior decorators or middle management. These folks will probably starve to death while attending a meeting on how not to starve or what color accents the wheel that a useful person had to reinvent for them.
 

JS80

Lifer
Oct 24, 2005
26,271
7
81
Originally posted by: TheRedUnderURBed
Originally posted by: brandonbull
Originally posted by: Xavier434
Originally posted by: brandonbull
Pouring steel for 40 years sounds like a mindless task for someone who wishes to take the easy road. I had to pay for my own training/education by way of college and I have to continue to pay and work for my training because I don't sit back and do mindless factory work.

How many hours have you spent working in the manufacturing industry which allows you to make such a statement in some sort of credible and educated fashion?

...or are you just blowing smoke because you have some kind of superiority complex over them?

I spent the better part of 12 years between a tour in the US Navy and another 7 years working full time as a electricain/maintenance mechanic to put myself into a "superiority complex" by getting an MIS degree. One job I worked where they did plastic extrustion for the medical and airline industries and the other was making styrofoam cups.

Is that good enough for you?

I stand by my opinion on factory work.

In the end it is your opinion, some men like using their hands and creating things, some like to sit behind a desk and kiss ass.
Both jobs are necessary, but in the long term I would much rather have a skilled US workforce who can actually produce things, fix their own stuff (it is sad how few young men I know have any clue how to repair their own cars/washing machines/etc. never poured concrete, layed a brick, painted a house) in case or economy ever went sour we are not going to climb our way back up to the top with interior decorators or middle management. These folks will probably starve to death while attending a meeting on how not to starve or what color accents the wheel that a useful person had to reinvent for them.

Yea, keep thinking like cavemen. I'm sorry but it takes about an hour to learn how to mix concrete, lay a brick or paint a house, but it takes many years to learn how to be an engineer, etc.
 

Steeplerot

Lifer
Mar 29, 2004
13,051
6
81
Originally posted by: JS80
Originally posted by: TheRedUnderURBed
Originally posted by: brandonbull
Originally posted by: Xavier434
Originally posted by: brandonbull
Pouring steel for 40 years sounds like a mindless task for someone who wishes to take the easy road. I had to pay for my own training/education by way of college and I have to continue to pay and work for my training because I don't sit back and do mindless factory work.

How many hours have you spent working in the manufacturing industry which allows you to make such a statement in some sort of credible and educated fashion?

...or are you just blowing smoke because you have some kind of superiority complex over them?

I spent the better part of 12 years between a tour in the US Navy and another 7 years working full time as a electricain/maintenance mechanic to put myself into a "superiority complex" by getting an MIS degree. One job I worked where they did plastic extrustion for the medical and airline industries and the other was making styrofoam cups.

Is that good enough for you?

I stand by my opinion on factory work.

In the end it is your opinion, some men like using their hands and creating things, some like to sit behind a desk and kiss ass.
Both jobs are necessary, but in the long term I would much rather have a skilled US workforce who can actually produce things, fix their own stuff (it is sad how few young men I know have any clue how to repair their own cars/washing machines/etc. never poured concrete, layed a brick, painted a house) in case or economy ever went sour we are not going to climb our way back up to the top with interior decorators or middle management. These folks will probably starve to death while attending a meeting on how not to starve or what color accents the wheel that a useful person had to reinvent for them.

Yea, keep thinking like cavemen. I'm sorry but it takes about an hour to learn how to mix concrete, lay a brick or paint a house, but it takes many years to learn how to be an engineer, etc.

Wow, I thought there was some ignorance here, but you take the cake.
A few hours to learn a trade? If you even had the slightest clue you would know that concrete for example includes quite a bit of engineering on the fly to calculate load balancing for structures, correct mix, pressures on foundation/load carrying, how to deal with water tables if working below the surface, ventilation for larger structures underground, safety. You do not even know, please quit embarrassing yourself.
The only thing you are going to know how to do in a few hours is screw up a garden path in your yard, god help us if you actually had to build something that lasts for a 80 years that people would live/work in day in day out.
 

JS80

Lifer
Oct 24, 2005
26,271
7
81
Originally posted by: TheRedUnderURBed
Originally posted by: JS80
Originally posted by: TheRedUnderURBed
Originally posted by: brandonbull
Originally posted by: Xavier434
Originally posted by: brandonbull
Pouring steel for 40 years sounds like a mindless task for someone who wishes to take the easy road. I had to pay for my own training/education by way of college and I have to continue to pay and work for my training because I don't sit back and do mindless factory work.

How many hours have you spent working in the manufacturing industry which allows you to make such a statement in some sort of credible and educated fashion?

...or are you just blowing smoke because you have some kind of superiority complex over them?

I spent the better part of 12 years between a tour in the US Navy and another 7 years working full time as a electricain/maintenance mechanic to put myself into a "superiority complex" by getting an MIS degree. One job I worked where they did plastic extrustion for the medical and airline industries and the other was making styrofoam cups.

Is that good enough for you?

I stand by my opinion on factory work.

In the end it is your opinion, some men like using their hands and creating things, some like to sit behind a desk and kiss ass.
Both jobs are necessary, but in the long term I would much rather have a skilled US workforce who can actually produce things, fix their own stuff (it is sad how few young men I know have any clue how to repair their own cars/washing machines/etc. never poured concrete, layed a brick, painted a house) in case or economy ever went sour we are not going to climb our way back up to the top with interior decorators or middle management. These folks will probably starve to death while attending a meeting on how not to starve or what color accents the wheel that a useful person had to reinvent for them.

Yea, keep thinking like cavemen. I'm sorry but it takes about an hour to learn how to mix concrete, lay a brick or paint a house, but it takes many years to learn how to be an engineer, etc.

Wow, I thought there was some ignorance here, but you take the cake.
A few hours to learn a trade? If you even had the slightest clue you would know that concrete for example includes quite a bit of engineering on the fly to calculate load balancing for structures, correct mix, pressures on foundation/load carrying, how to deal with water tables if working below the surface, ventilation for larger structures underground, safety. You do not even know, please quit embarrassing yourself.

lol you just proved my fucking point. You think brick layers understand the engineering part of the trade? The engineers tell the brick layers what to do and brick layers just fucking lay brick. That's why they call it unskilled labor.

Manufacturing in the US is a bad use of resource. Americans are developed enough that they can move on to doing more sophisticated things and leave the manufacturing to emerging countries.

Once again, you fail at trade theory.
 

Steeplerot

Lifer
Mar 29, 2004
13,051
6
81
Originally posted by: JS80


lol you just proved my fucking point. You think brick layers understand the engineering part of the trade? The engineers tell the brick layers what to do and brick layers just fucking lay brick. That's why they call it unskilled labor.

What is with the cursing? You are sounding quite childish at this point.
Tradesman do understand this part.
Bricklaying is not unskilled labor, maybe the guy who carrys the bricks, but that is manual labor. A bricklayer needs to know many jobs at once.
I do not know if you are thinking about some temp employee on site to carry stuff around, you have no clue what being a professional entails though obviously.

Just curious, since we are using masonary as an example, have you ever DONE this work? Ever known a actual tradesman?
Yo do realize that one part of these jobs is just part of it also, you need to know carpentry, engineering/architecture, have knowledge of basic geography of the area and what is underground and how soils interact.
Like I said, just stop. The white collar/blue argument collar does nothing but divide the workers anyhow, shouldn't have brought it up.
 

JS80

Lifer
Oct 24, 2005
26,271
7
81
Originally posted by: TheRedUnderURBed
Originally posted by: JS80


lol you just proved my fucking point. You think brick layers understand the engineering part of the trade? The engineers tell the brick layers what to do and brick layers just fucking lay brick. That's why they call it unskilled labor.

What is with the cursing? You are sounding quite childish at this point.
Tradesman do understand this part.
Bricklaying is not unskilled labor, maybe the guy who carrys the bricks, but that is manual labor. A bricklayer needs to know many jobs at once.
I do not know if you are thinking about some temp employee on site to carry stuff around, you have no clue what being a professional entails though obviously.

I'm glad you think the illegal mexican day laborer is skilled labor. Why stop outsourcing to just outside the US? Why don't you go learn to farm and knit clothes. That way you don't have to outsource your food and clothing to other Americans trades you can do on your own.
 

Steeplerot

Lifer
Mar 29, 2004
13,051
6
81
Originally posted by: JS80


I'm glad you think the illegal mexican day laborer is skilled labor. Why stop outsourcing to just outside the US? Why don't you go learn to farm and knit clothes. That way you don't have to outsource your food and clothing to other Americans trades you can do on your own.

Some of those illegals are far more intelligent then a lot of US born kids the same age, quite a few do not even work and live at home I know of.
At least these guys know trades and how to fix something if it needs to be done.
Elitist much? You really are coming off like a child calling someone a caveman for knowing a actual trade and working.
 

Kirby

Lifer
Apr 10, 2006
12,028
2
0
Originally posted by: JS80
Yea, keep thinking like cavemen. I'm sorry but it takes about an hour to learn how to mix concrete, lay a brick or paint a house, but it takes many years to learn how to be an engineer, etc.

:laugh: :laugh: :laugh:

That's probably the most ridiculous thing I've ever heard.