I once had 3 naga jolokia stick-blended into tomato soup; I posted about it...
Star Wars is a bit overrated.
Having negative emotions/arguments against things that are 'overrated' is, by definition, allowing others to determine your point of view. It's an attempt to get out of the social-construction of enjoyable that fails in its very inception.
Take it out of context though and rate them as just films and they lose a lot of their magical aura.
I disagree with a-historical understanding of film. Not to say that a film shouldn't hold up over time, but rather the technical merit of a film should be understood in its context and if a story seems pat, trite or even derivative you should take into account when it was made.
A few examples: The twilight-zone is the very basis of a number of modern scifi movies/tv epesodes; further every episode of the original start-trek is highly predictable because of the number of times the ideas from that show have been repeated. Similarly, while the hero's journey is trite by today's standards: the magic of bringing it into the stars and integrating far-eastern philosophy was revolutionary.
Star-wars holds up today for myriad reasons, by dismissing it as over rated you ironically allow the group to decide your tastes and, there by, lose out on the contemporary enjoy-ability and an understanding of its historic influence on cinema.