Jay Cutler says - "Volume over Weight"

Status
Not open for further replies.

z1ggy

Lifer
May 17, 2008
10,010
66
91
http://forums.anandtech.com/newthread.php?do=newthread&f=52

There's nothing fancy about four-time Mr. Olympia Jay Cutler's chest workout, yet few men were ever able to keep up with him. Here's how he built his Sandow-winning chest with heavy weights, high volume, short rest intervals—and not a single set taken to muscle failure!

Q JAY, HOW WOULD YOU SUMMARIZE YOUR APPROACH TO CHEST TRAINING?
Well, I'd hardly say it's unique given that I've done the same thing for 20 years. Honestly, I don't do anything different. I stick with straight sets, nothing fancy. I don't do any kind of advanced-training techniques like dropsets.

MOST BODYBUILDERS EMPLOY ALL SORTS OF INTENSITY BOOSTERS. HOW IS IT THAT YOU'VE MANAGED TO DO SO WELL BY DOING ONLY STRAIGHT SETS?
Because it's always worked for me. I don't understand why I would want to change something that's working. I never incurred any significant injuries and I was continually making gains over the years, so I didn't see the need to change things up.

THE FIRST EXERCISE IN YOUR ROUTINE IS OFTEN CONSIDERED THE MOST IMPORTANT BECAUSE YOU CAN ATTACK THE WEIGHTS BEFORE FATIGUE SETS IN. HOW DO YOU CHOOSE WHAT YOU DO FIRST?
The first exercise in my routine is almost certainly a compound [multi-joint] exercise. With this kind of movement, you can push the most weight because more muscle groups are involved in the lift.




For those reasons, I always started my chest workout with a dumbbell or barbell movement. You get better range of motion with free weights, but later in my career I focused more on machines because of the degree of safety they afford.

I'm a big user of the Hammer Strength decline machine, but those didn't even exist, at least in my gym, when I first started training in 1991.

DO YOU START WITH A PARTICULAR BENCH ON CHEST DAY?
I never really had any weak [chest] areas that I needed to significantly bring up, so I varied things up but not a whole lot. For one, it depended on the gym I was in; I traveled a lot and was always training in a new facility. Occasionally that allowed me to try out new equipment, but sometimes I was limited, as well. For one, not every gym has dumbbells that go up to 200 pounds.

Rather than making arbitrary changes in my workout, if I had a good workout, I'd continue doing it. Usually after a while you see diminishing returns, but I never made changes for the sake of making changes. If I liked a workout, I stuck with it.

I never believed in the theory that you had to change things up week to week to elicit changes. I believe that if you train to your fullest potential, if you exert the most you possibly can, you're gonna grow as long as your diet and sleep patterns are in sync with your training.

YOU RELIED MORE ON MACHINES IN YOUR LATER COMPETITIVE YEARS?
I went to machines later on because I feared injury. As I got more and more successful, it seemed like other bodybuilders were increasingly suffering from bad injuries, and frankly it was about the only thing that didn't happen in my career.


"I WANTED TO STAY ON TOP, SO I WAS DOING THE THERAPY SESSIONS, I WAS DOING THE TRAINING, AND I WAS DOING EVERYTHING AS PROPERLY AS POSSIBLE."
As I rose to winning the Olympia and I was having great success, I wanted to stay on top, so I was doing the therapy sessions, I was doing the training, and I was doing everything as properly as possible.

As I got older, I became afraid of throwing around the crazy weights because I was so strong. I could use 200-pound dumbbells and I could do 500-pound bench presses for reps. It seemed like everyone else who used those kind of weights sooner or later ended up with an injury.

So I switched things around a little bit to try to exhaust my muscles a little more rather than just trying to keep going heavier.



HOW IMPORTANT ARE WARM-UPS BEFORE HITTING THOSE KINDS OF WEIGHTS?
Being in Vegas, you get warm just by getting to the gym, so I really don't need a warm-up per se. But I still do several lightweight sets, what I call "feel" sets. It helps get my mind into the movement, develop a feel for the motion, getting under the weight.

Then I start pyramiding up, doing at least 3-4 working sets. So, on my first exercise I'm doing 6-7 sets total.

DO YOU TAKE ANY OF THOSE SETS TO FAILURE?
"IN MY 20 YEARS OF TRAINING, I'VE NEVER TRAINED TO FAILURE ON ANY SET. EVER."
In my 20 years of training, I've never trained to failure on any set. Ever. I always trained with a weight in which I could do 8-12 repetitions.

For sure I could use more weight, but my focus wasn't on building even more strength or training to failure—rather it was on volume.

You can't do both high volume and high intensity; you have to pick one or the other. I'm a 20-set guy, I'd do 20 sets no matter whether the body part was chest or biceps. It didn't matter. For back it was up to 30 sets. Your nervous system can take only so much abuse.

For me, for anyone, doing high volume and training to failure—even past failure—is just too much. I never felt it was even necessary to try a technique like forced reps.

I learned the concepts of lifting mainly through my trainer Chris Aceto, and it became fundamental that we'd never do a set for fewer than 8 reps.

SO YOU DON'T GO ANY LOWER THAN EIGHT REPS WHEN TRAINING?
With deadlifts I'd go as low as 6, but for everything else it was 8-12. Obviously I could do more weight, but I never felt I had to prove anything, so I never did.

SO CAN YOU TELL US WHAT YOUR MAX BENCH PRESS IS?
I have no idea.

IS THERE ANYTHING UNIQUE ABOUT YOUR TRAINING STYLE THAT WOULD CAUSE SOMEONE TO SAY, "THAT'S HOW JAY CUTLER TRAINS?"
A lot of guys who watched my training videos thought they could keep up with me because I don't train past failure. They come here and train with me but they end up gassing out. They can't keep up the pace.

That's because my rest time is just 45-60 seconds max between sets. Most of the time I'd rest only as long as my workout partner, which was usually no more than about 45 seconds.


"A LOT OF THE GUYS BACK IN THE DAY, FROM ARNOLD TO GASPARI, TRAINED THIS WAY WITH VERY LITTLE REST BETWEEN SETS, AND I REALLY THINK THAT'S WHAT BODYBUILDING IS ABOUT."
A lot of the guys back in the day, from Arnold to Gaspari, trained this way with very little rest between sets, and I really think that's what bodybuilding is about. It's about volume training, going in there and getting the muscle full, and damaging the tissue and then getting out of the gym so the process of repair can take place.

ARE GUYS OVERLY CONCERNED WITH HOW MUCH WEIGHT THEY CAN LIFT?
If they're bodybuilders, they shouldn't be. Some guys can bench press tons of weight; other guys can't. Everyone's got particular lifts they're fairly strong on. I was one of those guys who could never curl a lot of weight but I had almost 23-inch arms.

Just about every guy in there could curl more weight than me. Again, weight wasn't the variable I was most concerned about.

MANY LIFTERS MEASURE PROGRESS IN TERMS OF WEIGHT LIFTED OR TOTAL REPS, BUT PROGRESSIVE OVERLOAD IS ALSO ACHIEVED BY REDUCING REST INTERVALS. THAT'S WHAT YOU PREFERRED?
You're right. People want to judge progress only by how much they can lift. That's absolutely backward from what bodybuilding really is. I don't believe that strength has anything to do with what we do [as bodybuilders]. Again, rest intervals are one of the many variables in bodybuilding—it's not only about the weight!

SINCE YOU DIDN'T GO BY WEIGHT, HOW DID YOU JUDGE THE EFFECTIVENESS OF A WORKOUT?
You know, I judged them by how sore I was afterward. At my peak and in my earlier years, I'd get incredibly sore. I mean I'd be sore for days and days and days.


"THERE'S A NUMBER OF FACTORS INVOLVED IN SETTING UP YOUR TRAINING SPLIT. FOR ME IT INCLUDED TRAVEL, EATING PATTERNS, SLEEP, AND RECOVERY."
The split I followed meant each body part was trained once every 5-7 days. But I'd take longer if I didn't feel recovered. And if I didn't feel recovered, I just wouldn't train. So that's how I came up with 5-7.

Really, there's a number of factors involved in setting up your training split. For me it included travel, eating patterns, sleep, and recovery.

WE HAVEN'T TOUCHED ON IT, BUT HOW IMPORTANT WERE SINGLE-JOINT EXERCISES ON CHEST DAY?
We haven't touched on it because I was never really a believer that there was much benefit in fly movements. With chest training, there are only so many things you can do, so it was lots of types of presses to get the contractions to build a full chest. It's less about lifting the weight than feeling the contraction.



I don't know about that. I mean, I get the guy is one of the best, but you're telling me that doing 20 sets at 8-12 reps is going to get your bigger than doing 6-8 sets of 4-6 reps? I know right now I currently do sets of 8, and on most days, the most sets I can do before I am too fatigued is generally 10. After 10 sets I'd go from curling say, 30-35lb dumbbells down to 15 or 20lb. At that point, am I really gaining? Or just over working my muscles to the point of possible injury?

Please share your thoughts.
 

AntonioHG

Senior member
Mar 19, 2007
893
590
146
www.antoniograndephotography.com
PEDs. Steroids. Etc help a lot.

No normal person could take that amount of volume. Sore for days = way too much volume or not enough frequency.

I did about 30 sets total for my SL Madcow 5x5 including the warmup. 15 sets with working weight. That's squat, bench, row and then I added in some chest fly and cable row just because I like them. I could probably leave those out because there's only so much growth you can stimulate in a day. http://ftcy.me/9wr8s6

If you want to gain, get on a program, eat enough to gain weight and be sure you're aiming for progressive overload. You squat 225lbs x 5 now? In 5 months you're doing 225lbs x 15 = gains. Or, you go from a 1 rep max of 275lbs to 325lbs = gains.
 
Last edited:

Zivic

Diamond Member
Nov 25, 2002
3,505
38
91
What works for him is not going to necessarily be the best for an unenhanced, not genetically 1%'er.

You need to lift heavy at some point. You need to gain strength, control of the muscle/movements...
Build the foundation before you paint the walls.

In the last couple years I've taken what I have learned in the gym and refined things a lot. The heavy lifting can't be done forever as much I would like it to. What becomes essential is overloading the muscles... With increased intensity, weight and or volume. Maybe reducing resting time. What I think is most important is knowing what to work towards in terms of a feeling. I am big believer in not burning you muscles out. Work towards the pump. Work towards the feeling that I can not do the movement again, not because it burns, but because your muscles are so full and contracted that the weight just won't move. This rep range varies with each person and the amount of weight used.
 

Koing

Elite Member <br> Super Moderator<br> Health and F
Oct 11, 2000
16,843
2
0
What works for him is not going to necessarily be the best for an unenhanced, not genetically 1%'er.

You need to lift heavy at some point. You need to gain strength, control of the muscle/movements...
Build the foundation before you paint the walls.

In the last couple years I've taken what I have learned in the gym and refined things a lot. The heavy lifting can't be done forever as much I would like it to. What becomes essential is overloading the muscles... With increased intensity, weight and or volume. Maybe reducing resting time. What I think is most important is knowing what to work towards in terms of a feeling. I am big believer in not burning you muscles out. Work towards the pump. Work towards the feeling that I can not do the movement again, not because it burns, but because your muscles are so full and contracted that the weight just won't move. This rep range varies with each person and the amount of weight used.

This.

Cutler is MUCH stronger than most guys and has built his base. Now he can do whatever he wants to get his results.

Koing
 

z1ggy

Lifer
May 17, 2008
10,010
66
91
Genetics and roids go a long way with just a little lifting. You don't have to be strong to build muscle using TUT methods.

Seems almost as silly as Broz before Hoez System, but with roids anything is possible:
http://www.t-nation.com/free_online_article/most_recent/max_out_on_squats_every_day

LOL 13 sessions a week.

And thanks from you other guys for the input. I knew this would be kind of dumb as in "follow what this pro lifter who's been on roids before does" and apply it to me.

Even though I've been in the weight room since age 13, I'm still probably considered a novice because I continue to make gains. I guess that I just wanted to make sure I am approaching this with the right mindset and technique.

Say I follow MAX OT for the full 26 weeks (which I am doing btw), do I just... keep going? I'd consider that to be a high intensity work out from my point of view. To change it up, would I drop my weight a bit and do more volume for.. 1.. 2.. 12 weeks? How often do I really need to change my routine to get gains? I figured just adding on more weight until I stall is enough "change", and then I'd deload until I can push through my plateau.

Overall, I'm not looking to be Jay or Ronnie. I don't care if I can squat 505 (would be cool, but I won't be mad if I can't). I want to look good, double body weight dead lift, squat 315 and bench 275 for reps. All while keeping my body fat no higher than 12%. Obviously a long road ahead of me, which is okay. It's just comforting to know I am not wasting my time in the gym lifting the wrong way.
 

Zivic

Diamond Member
Nov 25, 2002
3,505
38
91
LOL 13 sessions a week.

And thanks from you other guys for the input. I knew this would be kind of dumb as in "follow what this pro lifter who's been on roids before does" and apply it to me.

Even though I've been in the weight room since age 13, I'm still probably considered a novice because I continue to make gains. I guess that I just wanted to make sure I am approaching this with the right mindset and technique.

Say I follow MAX OT for the full 26 weeks (which I am doing btw), do I just... keep going?

if you are still making good progress I would.

I'd consider that to be a high intensity work out from my point of view.
it is, if done correctly. my problem with max-ot is I got caught up in the weight and stopped focusing on how I felt. I would stop listening to my body and insist on moving the big weight. don't get me wrong, that needs to be done, but not every workout for 10+ yrs.

To change it up, would I drop my weight a bit and do more volume for.. 1.. 2.. 12 weeks?
How often do I really need to change my routine to get gains? I figured just adding on more weight until I stall is enough "change", and then I'd deload until I can push through my plateau.

When i did maxot, just upping the reps to the 8 range was enough. then I added in an accessory lift after a few weeks. just little changes. I would say try for 4-8 wks.

Overall, I'm not looking to be Jay or Ronnie. I don't care if I can squat 505 (would be cool, but I won't be mad if I can't). I want to look good, double body weight dead lift, squat 315 and bench 275 for reps. All while keeping my body fat no higher than 12%. Obviously a long road ahead of me, which is okay. It's just comforting to know I am not wasting my time in the gym lifting the wrong way.


use the program as a base. keep it as a point of reference. add things to it, take some things away. You'll find things that work better for you, and others not so much.

I was watching marc lobliner talk about how that in BB people are technique/form critics and how only in this "sport" the novice will critique the pros and how they lift. I say in some regards it is justified. When a key ingredient in a pro's makeup is drugs, you can get away with some things an enhanced athlete cannot. Not saying this in a bad way, but 8 sets of X-lift for example isn't going to translate into gains for us, like it would them. for the most part, i am a believer that the drugs actually make things harder for the pros in the sense that it gives them the capacity to train harder, heavier, and longer. and to get the most out of them, this is what they need to do. most amateurs have the illusion they train hard, when in reality they don't. I don't train as intensely as I could every workout, but when I look around my gym, I am training harder than those around me -> still doesn't mean I'm training hard. On the pro level, you have to train hard all the time... the drugs help to allow this.

I'm kind of rambling, but what works for a pro level athlete taking drugs isn't likely the first thing i would try for my personal gains
 

z1ggy

Lifer
May 17, 2008
10,010
66
91
Well currently, I am cutting so I dropped weight slightly and am doing most of my sets for 8 reps. Before I was doing 5-6 reps. I only have about 4 more lbs to go on my cut before I am going to go back to eating more and going for gains.

Also, I think I am going to stop following BB.com. They spew tons of shit to tug at thehearts of people like me, and I'd imagine a lot of others, too. Today they posted a pic with a flabby out of shape guy, next to a pic of supposedly the same guy with a caption "What can you do in 6 weeks?"

Total BS. There is NO way that guy went from a flapjack to a jacked dude in 6 weeks, I don't care how hard he worked. The person had almost no muscle, then went to looking like Hugh Jackman in Wolverine. Sure, he may have done this in 6 months to 1 year, but 6 weeks my ass. I hate how these companies basically lie to us to get us to buy their product, etc etc. That's why I have never been a huge supplementer. It may well work for some people, but how much time and money will I be investing for 5-10% more gains? I've done perfectly well just using protein power and creatine. I know other things work, like BCAA so I do take those, but I don't go nuts with fat burners and pre-works, etc.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.