Originally posted by: Engineer
Timing might have worked well this time but most people can't time the market. I know people who took it out after a huge chuck of the drop and sure, they didn't drop to the bottom...but the market has now recovered to a point "higher" than what they jumped out at. I guess if enough people jumped out it would drop and they would look like geniuses and if they all jumped back in, again, looked like a genius when the market rocketed up.
Besides, nobody ever advised to start looking at all cash unless you were less than 5 years from retirement. Nobody suggested that 14 years worth of gains would have been wiped out in 1.5 years.
I read an article that stated that if you missed out on the 20 single largest days of the S&P 500 during the 90's, not only did you miss the profit, but you would have been negative. (No, I don't have a link, sorry).
I would never take my money out, but in Dec. I changed 100% of my portfolio into a stable principle fund that so far as gained me 2% for the year. Looking at the rest of the investment options, all of them were well in the negative (some around 30-50%) for the year and I would have lost thousands of dollars. Once things start to pick up, I'll change my portfolio mix and buy back into the more moderate risk things.
So it's more about investing smart than just pulling out.
