In revisiting my memory of it, the fellow hiker who admonished me was a more determined tree-hugger than I have ever been. There is a self-righteous one-ups-man-ship dimension to these "expert" environmental exchanges. However, we're talking about pee. What do you think would be the best advice for a massive-gassive-lumpy-dumpy-poopy-doopy-plopper-soupy-happy-crappy?
There's this California State park or forest area up north, just west of Yreka. Yes -- trying to verify my dated memory about it, Google shows the Marble Mountains is W /SW of Yreka. There is also Klamath National Forest north of there. But the Marble Mountains have some pretty good lakes with what was then (2001) a bounty of trout. On the way up the mountains to a lake, we found a huge oak tree with a wonderful shade canopy over what seemed to be flat, comfortable camping ground. We stopped for lunch.
We had earlier encountered some cowboys on horseback with small herds of cows. They must've paid BLM for grazing rights, but this was a place where cattle ranching, wilderness parks, and national forest all converged.
We sat down under the oak canopy to have lunch. I had some cheese, crackers, jerky -- maybe some raisins. Then we began to notice all the green-bottle and blue-bottle flies buzzing around. And after that, we noticed ploppers and mounds, mounds and ploppers. It must have been the cigarette habit, or I might have picked up the scent earlier. Horse shit smells much better than cow-shit, and those mounds and ploppers were all cow excrement. And that was the end of our lunch.
But you don't want bears of any kind eating your shit. I'd seen dogs eat cat-shit, and it seemed that they liked it. If the bears like your shit, they may like you in ways that are unhealthy -- exposing you to extreme risk.