Is this a PSU problem?

Skypix7

Senior member
I've been chasing problems with my new system for 8 weeks.

Latest symptom of wierdness (after having disappearing IDE drive...that reappeared, OS installs that worked...then kluged (vista 64 and XP, learned the dual boot lesson the hard way)), the latest symptom is a usb card reader that, when I simply touched the connector to the port, set off a 4-beep sequence which Asus says is a system timer error.

My memory is good, I've already tested that.

The error repeated several times. Asus tech said rma the board. But then I plugged in another USB device, a joystick. No problem, installed fine (I'm on OS install #7!), then I plugged in the card reader again...no problem!

Called the system tech that I bought the system from (All PC Zone), and he said perhaps the cheap power supply they sell with the system (Okia 600W atx) is the culprit and I've got too much on the system or ...blah blah blah...everytime I call he's got a new suggestion, nice guy but how much troubleshooting can a person take?

Here's what I've got on the system:

Windows Vista 64bit
Asus P5W DH Deluxe
Quad core 6600
8GB Kingston DDR 2 667 memory
nVidia 7600 GS PCI e
2 SATA drives (500GB and 320GB)
2 IDE drives (250GB x 2)
3 SATA DVD burners (2 Asus 1814 and one Pioneer, all DL)
One of the Asus drives is currently disconnected because whenever I hit Del to go into bios during the splash screen, the post list of drives would hang on that DVD drive. When I disconnected it, it would post properly and go right to bios.

The techie also said maybe I was overloading the board.

One other symptom:
the beeping thing started last night when the USB connector on the card reader accidentally touched the USB port. That was the first time, and it crashed the system during an install of a program. I had to uninstall the program, reinstall (it's working now), but the beeping continued.

My main question I guess: should I replace the power supply with a better one, or am I looking at some other glitch here? Right now it's working fine, but given all the strange things that have happened the last 2 months, does anyone see a pattern or clue here that might help return me to stable computing?

 

Zap

Elite Member
Oct 13, 1999
22,377
7
81
Originally posted by: Skypix7
The techie also said maybe I was overloading the board.

How can you overload a board?

It could possibly be the power supply. What video card do you have?
 

Skypix7

Senior member
Zap, the card is an nVidia 7600 gs. I had some issues with the driver and Vista 64 but seems stable now.

The techie said although the board is supposed to be able to handle everything that can plug into it, maybe it was too many things.

He also said to phase out my ide drives, as they will fail sooner or later, being engineered to last only 2 to 3 years.

 

AmberClad

Diamond Member
Jul 23, 2005
4,914
0
0
Originally posted by: Skypix7
He also said to phase out my ide drives, as they will fail sooner or later, being engineered to last only 2 to 3 years.
WTH :confused:...

There are manufacturers out there that offer 5 year warranties on their hard drives, including IDE ones. I have an IBM Deskstar IDE drive (circa 2001) that's still running just fine. I wonder if the techie had a few bad experiences with the infamous 75GB "Deathstar" IBM Deskstar...
 

Zap

Elite Member
Oct 13, 1999
22,377
7
81
All HDDs will fail, sooner or later. The interface has nothing to do with longetivity.

If your PSU really puts out 600W, then it should be able to handle your system just fine. I'm not familiar with Okia PSUs though.
 

Skypix7

Senior member


EDIT: new wierdness.

Maybe this will make sense to someone...while transferring files from one drive to another, (images in Adobe Bridge) it was going too slow so I cancelled the move...or tried to. It crashed Bridge and the system, complete frozen lockup.

I rebooted and everything was fine...except two of the drives were missing! Just not showing at all. this happened yesterday too, with one drive not showing up after boot.

I shut down the system, turned off the power switch, let it sit for 30 seconds, powered back up, rebooted...all drives present and accounted for. Transferring files now without any problem.

So again the question is: Deal? or no Deal? Power Supply? or Motherboard?

or something else I'm too iggerant to know about?
 

Zap

Elite Member
Oct 13, 1999
22,377
7
81
My vote would be for the power supply, but these problems are kind of difficult to figure out without having the system in front of me.