To each his own and that includes reviews and reviewers. I have read many positive review and did before I bought mine (model 600). I have had absolutely no problems, it plays mp3's, vcd's, svcd's, etc. It plays cdr's and cdrw's. There is not a more versatile player out there for the money. Picture is great sound is pretty good, maybe a bit too much through-put to the center channel. I paid $199 6 months ago and now their newer comparable model is around $119. Hell, at these prices the thing is almost disposable. Depends on what you want. I like the ability to throw 150 mp3's on a CDRW at 10X-12X and be listening in my living room in minutes. I also like the ability to rip my home movies onto CDR/RW w/menu and enjoy them on my TV.
moi - look around, read many reviews and consider everyone's opinion before you buy. Going with one review or one opinion is not a good idea. If someone says only it "sucks" and doesn't own it, then discount that opinion immediately.
Good luck,
LJ