Is it truely possible to be 'best friends' with a girl?

Page 3 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

Carl Uman

Diamond Member
Jan 29, 2000
6,008
2
81
According to Chris Rock if your best friends with a girl then you made a wrong turn somewhere :) LOL
bacially d_ck in glass case... in case of emergency just break glass ROTFLMAO
 

Descartes

Lifer
Oct 10, 1999
13,968
2
0
I have one friend in particular whom I feel absolutely no attraction to, and I'm completely myself around her. She's the same, and it's nice. We were even semi-together at one point, but that didn't change things.
 

linuxboy

Elite Member
Oct 9, 1999
2,577
6
76
Is there anyone out there that has a best friend that is a girl and.... Are NOT attracted to them "like that"? Is it possible???

In the world of the everyday, for most people, discovering love and sexuality immediately places these two rich experiential aspects of human life into predefined social constructs. As such, a sexual attraction carries with it, for many people, the desire to objectify and control and the desire to enter into a socially-approved mode of engagement, such as dating. In male-female interaction, especially among young people who have are not in a recognized class of available/unavailable, sexual overtones are present, even if sexuality is not because the potential for an escalation of committment in terms of norms of conduct (friendship, dating, engagement, marriage), is available. In all cases, this is true, since there the possibility for more in the future and with heterosexual friends, an offer will not cause aversion. This possibility and the prevalent view that dating includes exploration of sexuality (recent studies in adolescent behavior show that girls are defining new sexual norms and are unwilling to engage in sexual acts outside of relationships defined as gf/bf) creates if not overt tension, then covert tension due to mutual recognition of possibilities. Always, unless availability changes at which point people are classified as one social construct or another (again, friend, date, fiancee, mate is what seems to occur in western societies).

With that in mind, back to your question. My answer depends on your very wording. If friendship is recognized as an insitutuion and places limits on modes of interaction by creating norms and if the particular relationship isn't defined by the people, and if the people are attached to culture and society in such a way that they want to engage in the social constructs, it is possible, but the "more" daemon may potentially haunt.

If the people have enough knowledge (my emphasis on age and pointing out of young people in the first paragraph) of the world, of themselves, and of Good, then they are strong and do not require social constructs and can meet one another in life without worry. This is typical of same-sex friendships and can occur in male-female interaction, but rarely does, because as I have already said, expectation is there and people are conditioned by society. In this case, the answer again is yes, a friendship and a meeting if the minds is possible between people of different genders, though often in these cases the relationship is close and most people who find this sort of relationship wind up entering commitments on a marital level or at least in the preliminary dating levels.

That's for possibility. Personally for me, yes it is possible and yes I do have friendships with females, all of which during the past 4-5 years have not reached sexuality on my part, although I question your definition of "best" since every friendship I have is close and personal and potentially fits this label. Having spent some time thinking about people's needs, desires, cravings, etc, I noticed that many females, especially younger ones, want companionship with males to discover individual differences. They would like to do this in a safe way without the sexual overtones and without expectations. Ideally, this would occur frequently and equality would prevail. However, as OT demonstrates, so many personal issues of esteem, of worth, and of genuine need for intimacy creates problems for either or both parties, possibly destroying a friendship. Females have told me "I wish I could have a close male friend, just to talk to and enjoy spending time with and not having to think about marriage". That's what I am to them since it's a good experience. Long-term commitments frighten people; they think it means giving something away and fail to focus on the benefits (helloooo tax breaks and deductions :D).

Knowing this, I have and strive to have interactions with females since mutual benefit can come about through discovery and a sharing of life with people. This issue is brought up very early in these types of interactions to ensure safety and understanding as well as eliminate barriers to disclosure, trust, and intimacy.

It sounds strange since my ideas and definitions are built up on a single concept of love as agape, but I guess I say it's possible because I'm not only good at using linux, I know how unix-users feel as well.

Now let me address something HC posted, since this is a mutual interest and judging from the number of posts in this thread, something she'd like to know more about.


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Originally posted by: HotChic
So does that mean that my close guy friends are bound to 'like' me sooner or later? I won't buy that, I know them, I frequently know who they're interested in, and I don't think any of them see me as being someone they could ever date.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------


Ah, how naive. Trust me, most guys that become friends with girls... are ATTRACTED to that girl and would have a relationship with her at the drop of the dime. Don't delude yourself, that's how it is, they wouldn't be associating with you if they didn't find you attractive. Now, if they already have girlfriends and hang out with you, then it may be less of an issue, but if they are single, there is some level going on there.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

so true, why do you females think guys approached them to begin with? Surely not to say, hey that girl looks like shed be a good friend 99% of the time after this guys are friends with the girl because they couldn't get with her and are just hanging around hoping for a chance. Of course there are still isolated incidents of this not being true, but not most of the time


The purist idealist in you misses this truism, HC. This may be missed because people fear potential rejection and as you pointed out before "much more goes on in guys' minds than they let on". The forces of attraction (in young people particularly) create unnoticed dynamics and unnoticed overtones. For most males, friendship is just a way to show how desirable they are in the hopes of eventually "taking it to the next level". This is because of fundamental human drives of empathy and companionship and because society, and often parents, place such a high emphasis on marriage. The life trajectory of a typical person is school, college, job, marriage, home purchase, saving for retirement, work/career, raise kids, set them free, retire and enjoy the money. For most people, mate-seeking is absolutely huge so in their eyes for reasons of continuity and for reasons of personal happiness and need-fulfillment. The potential exists, unless it conforms to some definition I've made above or fits some new norm I have not heard or seen (certainly possible) or thought of.

If you define 'like' as infatuation or sexual attraction (there is a huge ambiguity of terms here and people often have unclear views on the dynamics of this whole phnomenon), then that too is likely, even if briefly or in moments of "detached aesthetic appreciation" because males ARE visual creatures and most of them objectify. The ones who claim otherwise, are automatically subject to extreme scrutiny. If you really examine, you'll see there is a deviancy between words and behavior most of the time. mmm :)

In your case, I don't know if what I say truly applies (but I think it does, I've come up across so few exceptions that it's a near certainty), since you hang out with some really weird people. :D ;)

Cheers ! :)
 

Spac3d

Banned
Jul 3, 2001
6,651
1
0
Originally posted by: rbloedow
Yes, my best friend is a girl - but she's also a lesbian :)

Does she have a phone number? Is she by any chance an exhibitionist??

I don't think its possible for a guy and a girl to be friends. We aren't thinking with our brain when we meet new girls, so there is already something in the way of having a real friendship :p

Spac3d
 

Ryan

Lifer
Oct 31, 2000
27,519
2
81
Originally posted by: Spac3d
Originally posted by: rbloedow Yes, my best friend is a girl - but she's also a lesbian :)
Does she have a phone number? Is she by any chance an exhibitionist?? I don't think its possible for a guy and a girl to be friends. We aren't thinking with our brain when we meet new girls, so there is already something in the way of having a real friendship :p Spac3d

Trust me, she doesn't mess with guys, even if they wanna look. Sorry :)
 

linuxboy

Elite Member
Oct 9, 1999
2,577
6
76
Originally posted by: lawaris
se*x is what drives us all

Freud's ideas are widely rejected by modern scholars and I think the crack he used prevented him from real understanding. If a person looks at a painting and art and does not feel any appreciation or any understanding of Beauty, I question that person's system and his humanity in general.

Cheers ! :)
 

BD2003

Lifer
Oct 9, 1999
16,815
1
81
Yes, its possible, but the purely platonic relationship does not exist.

It is possible to be best friends with a girl and not want to be in a relationship with them. Its certainly possible for girls not to want to have sex with the guy in said friendship.

But theres one simple fact that anyone who denies is lying to themselves. Given the chance to hit it with no guilt, purely in hypothetical fantasy land, the answer is and will always be a yes.

Outside influences obviously stop it from happening, but that doesnt mean its not there.

Hell, lets be real, given the chance to have sex with practically anyone decent looking in a vaccum with absolutely no ill consequences, just about every guy would do it. (And I mean no ill consequences absolutely absolute, no guilt, noone else knows, noone else will ever find out, purely hypothetical.)

So girls, no, all of your friends do not want to have a relationship with you. But they do want to have sex with you. All of them. Ask them and theyll deny it, but its the truth.
 

CKDragon

Diamond Member
Jan 22, 2001
3,875
0
0
The more I read this thread the worse I feel... if anyone needs me I'll be in Hot Deals worrying about good, soulless money. :p

CK
 

brisco

Senior member
Apr 17, 2001
420
0
0
Yes you can. I'm happily married to one girl and one of my best friends is female and not my girlfriend nor was she ever.

Have I thought about what would be different if my best friend and I were together and I was not married to my wife? Sure I have but I have no desire to even try to make that change and I doubt she does either.

You just gotta think with the right part of your body!
 

Orsorum

Lifer
Dec 26, 2001
27,631
5
81
So girls, no, all of your friends do not want to have a relationship with you. But they do want to have sex with you. All of them. Ask them and theyll deny it, but its the truth.

To an extent, it's the truth. :D
 

Doodoo

Golden Member
Feb 14, 2000
1,423
0
76
It can be if you don't let ur hormones get in the way. Me and this girl use to be best friends...then we went out for 8 months...now we don't speak anymore. And now me and this other girl are really close...but shes my best friends ex...so i dunno. One nite her drunk friend told me she likes me...and i kinda like her too...but shes my best freinds ex so im not sure whats gonna happen. Me and my cousin's current girlfriend are really close. She's like a sister to me and i know shes totally off limits, so i guess bein best friends with a girl is possible.