KyleBisme, all you have proved in your post is that China is staying basically neutral.
While China basically votes the same as most of the rest of the world.
Sooner or later China will become a major diplomatic player, just as the USA did some 110 to 120 years ago. But for now, China is basically voting safe regarding Israel.
Now the China is a major economic rising power, sooner or later, IMHO, China will choose to exercise the diplomatic power that always inevitably follows economic power,
but its doubtful that exercise will be in the mid-east.
But in summation, it is hard to see either Kyle or John being wrong when they are basically saying the exact same thing.
In the case of the USA, they burst onto the world diplomatic and military stage during the Spanish American war. But at the time there was no UN type international bodies. Twenty years later the US was perhaps the #1 military power. As for China, they are only slowly arming, where they will be in 20 years is anyone's guess.
But to some extent there is the Eastern mind set. American's play smash mouth football, the Chinese play the game of Go. I fully expect the Go analogy to be not understood by most, but there may be the few who appreciate it.