Is Israeli a US ally or political liability?

Page 4 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

zhangjohn

Junior Member
Dec 20, 2010
17
0
0
you should know better as a chinese, for the same reason chinese are hated in many asian countries.

places like indonesia and filipines they are scape goats, in riots chinese get targeted.

and that is just for the stereotype that they are rich.

Yes, that's true. So I think maybe jealous is the original reason, religion is just a excuse.
 

Lemon law

Lifer
Nov 6, 2005
20,984
3
0
I somewhat question zhangohn dragging into a Western thread the current and Past History of the Chinese nation.

But still the history of Chinese nation is still as important in world history, compared to "Western history". But still even today, China has little impact on regional Western history.

And even now as Chinese economic power has risen in the past 20 years, China is seemingly Neutral on Israeli Palestinian issues.
 

kylebisme

Diamond Member
Mar 25, 2000
9,396
0
0
China is seemingly Neutral on Israeli Palestinian issues.
I can see how it might seem that way if you leave it to our media to inform you on the matter, but if you bother took look at their voting record at the UN, you'll find that isn't actually the case.
 

kylebisme

Diamond Member
Mar 25, 2000
9,396
0
0
No you don't John. If you look through the UNSC and UNGC resolutions on the issue, you'll find that rather than remaining neutral, China consistently votes against Israel's refusal to respect international law along with the vast majorty of the word. For instance, here is the UNSC vote on "on a durable and fully repected ceasefire and the full withdrawal of Israeli forces from the Gaza Strip" which China voted in favor on along with everyone but the the US.
 

Lemon law

Lifer
Nov 6, 2005
20,984
3
0
KyleBisme, all you have proved in your post is that China is staying basically neutral.
While China basically votes the same as most of the rest of the world.

Sooner or later China will become a major diplomatic player, just as the USA did some 110 to 120 years ago. But for now, China is basically voting safe regarding Israel.

Now the China is a major economic rising power, sooner or later, IMHO, China will choose to exercise the diplomatic power that always inevitably follows economic power,
but its doubtful that exercise will be in the mid-east.

But in summation, it is hard to see either Kyle or John being wrong when they are basically saying the exact same thing.

In the case of the USA, they burst onto the world diplomatic and military stage during the Spanish American war. But at the time there was no UN type international bodies. Twenty years later the US was perhaps the #1 military power. As for China, they are only slowly arming, where they will be in 20 years is anyone's guess.

But to some extent there is the Eastern mind set. American's play smash mouth football, the Chinese play the game of Go. I fully expect the Go analogy to be not understood by most, but there may be the few who appreciate it.
 

0roo0roo

No Lifer
Sep 21, 2002
64,795
84
91
nope, for a long time america was playing the game of go with the middle east, so you saw what that go em:p maybe you don't understand your own analogy.
 

kylebisme

Diamond Member
Mar 25, 2000
9,396
0
0
KyleBisme, all you have proved in your post is that China is staying basically neutral.
No, I pointed out the fact that China consistently votes yes to resolutions against Israel, rather than siding with Israel or remaining neutral by abstaining from voting like a few countries do.
 
Last edited:

Infohawk

Lifer
Jan 12, 2002
17,844
1
0
But to some extent there is the Eastern mind set. American's play smash mouth football, the Chinese play the game of Go. I fully expect the Go analogy to be not understood by most, but there may be the few who appreciate it.

Go is not that complicated of a reference, so get off your high horse. The dumb thing is you trying to summarize the difference between eastern and western attitudes to Israel by comparing football to Go. You really are stupid.
 

Lemon law

Lifer
Nov 6, 2005
20,984
3
0
Go is not that complicated of a reference, so get off your high horse. The dumb thing is you trying to summarize the difference between eastern and western attitudes to Israel by comparing football to Go. You really are stupid.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Just keep telling yourself that and say what me worry, as for me its no skin off my ass.

As for me, all I can see that most of my predictions are coming to pass.

As for me, I am more patient, I never expect immediate gratification.

But somehow you ignore the other significant mega historical event, namely the rise of China after centuries of self imposed Chinese isolation.

As for you Infohawk, please join the chicken man in TLC, who thinks the past is the most reliable predictor of the future. And stick your head in the sand with the strategy of an Ostrich, as you ignore all the radical changes swirling around you.
 

Infohawk

Lifer
Jan 12, 2002
17,844
1
0
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Just keep telling yourself that and say what me worry, as for me its no skin off my ass.

As for me, all I can see that most of my predictions are coming to pass.

As for me, I am more patient, I never expect immediate gratification.

But somehow you ignore the other significant mega historical event, namely the rise of China after centuries of self imposed Chinese isolation.

As for you Infohawk, please join the chicken man in TLC, who thinks the past is the most reliable predictor of the future. And stick your head in the sand with the strategy of an Ostrich, as you ignore all the radical changes swirling around you.

I certainly will keep pointing out your idiotic comments where you try to pass yourself off as someone who is intelligent. What predictions? Saying "Israel will fall" is not a prediction. Put a date on something and you'll actually have something to talk about.
 

Lemon law

Lifer
Nov 6, 2005
20,984
3
0
I certainly will keep pointing out your idiotic comments where you try to pass yourself off as someone who is intelligent. What predictions? Saying "Israel will fall" is not a prediction. Put a date on something and you'll actually have something to talk about.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
And now Infohawk really shows why he has no vision. As you somehow assume I welcome the fall of Israel. When we should instead realize that the larger win win goal is to have Israel become an accepted and welcome part of the mid-east. Because the delusion is that over long range time, its absurd to assume that Israel can forever maintain its military hegemony in the mid-east region.

If nothing else, Israeli arrogance makes Israel a magnet for international terrorism. As Israel at the same time becomes the number one destabilizing force in the mid-east, in a very world that is heavily dependent on that mid-east stability.

If you read the pages of Haaretz, many Jews in Israeli agree with me, that the wise thing for Israel to do now, is to help the formation of a Palestinian State.

But point granted, that is not the Israeli pig party settler position, as they think long term Israel can forever pig it all, and in so doing, they bet Israel can retain it all, or lose it all in the process. Just one year ago Israel had some mid-east allies, and now they demand the USA back Israeli to the hilt at the cost of the USA losing all international credibility.

But on that latter point does the Israeli Bozo Netanyuhu strategy ball game hinges on. If the US merely abstains, the Bozo Netanyuhu stupidity is total toast.
 

Infohawk

Lifer
Jan 12, 2002
17,844
1
0
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
And now Infohawk really shows why he has no vision. As you somehow assume I welcome the fall of Israel. When we should instead realize that the larger win win goal is to have Israel become an accepted and welcome part of the mid-east. Because the delusion is that over long range time, its absurd to assume that Israel can forever maintain its military hegemony in the mid-east region.

If nothing else, Israeli arrogance makes Israel a magnet for international terrorism. As Israel at the same time becomes the number one destabilizing force in the mid-east, in a very world that is heavily dependent on that mid-east stability.

If you read the pages of Haaretz, many Jews in Israeli agree with me, that the wise thing for Israel to do now, is to help the formation of a Palestinian State.

But point granted, that is not the Israeli pig party settler position, as they think long term Israel can forever pig it all, and in so doing, they bet Israel can retain it all, or lose it all in the process. Just one year ago Israel had some mid-east allies, and now they demand the USA back Israeli to the hilt at the cost of the USA losing all international credibility.

But on that latter point does the Israeli Bozo Netanyuhu strategy ball game hinges on. If the US merely abstains, the Bozo Netanyuhu stupidity is total toast.

I didn't ask for your standard rant. So you have no predictions... If you do, state the prediction and a date. Otherwise, you're just the boy who cried wolf.