Iran's Houthis fire missiles at global shipping, risk closing red sea

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

How should we respond to missile fire at merchant ships?

  • Declare War on Yemen

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Declare War on Iran

    Votes: 5 14.7%
  • Alternative response

    Votes: 23 67.6%
  • No response is needed

    Votes: 6 17.6%

  • Total voters
    34
  • Poll closed .

brycejones

Lifer
Oct 18, 2005
29,271
29,568
136
It's really too bad that your suicide attempts weren't successful.
You're projecting again
Ok? So you are a horrific nazi supporter like the rest of them. I think I know some of your posting history. We'd be better off if people like you moved to mars and let actual humans with souls run the joint. Go with Elon and the rest of that trash.

How does it feel to be born without a soul?

edit: I just had to look at a few of your posts. You are that person that we'd be better off as a species if you didn't exist. A cockroach with a keyboard.
To be fair the chat bot did at least use complete words this time. Someone must have fixed the bug with it only posting random letters in call caps.
 

K1052

Elite Member
Aug 21, 2003
51,589
44,174
136
Is 88 In the theater right now? Also not sure if helios has ever shot down a bm. The ones in theater have the capability to intercept bms though.

I don't think it is.

HELIOS isn't going to be useful against cruise or ballistic missiles at that power level but good for drones.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Leeea

Zorba

Lifer
Oct 22, 1999
15,613
11,255
136
Economic response, up to and including a blockade?
It sounds interesting, if only because our capacity to intercept is rather huge. So currently they pose a low threat to our war ships. Commercial ships are another matter entirely. We may not have the ammo efficiency or physical coverage to protect all ships in transit. Any time we intercept a drone with a missile, we lose the economic exchange. I think Yemen might be willing to suffer in exchange for taking down the Suez canal for literal years, potentially. But we should certainly start with posing this challenge to them, and see if they want us to escalate to find a solution.

As for letting the Saudis take the gloves off, that could be an ideal solution. They too are probably tired of receiving missile attacks.
We can protect those ships flying the Stars and Stripes, the others can pay a protection fee or fly the Stars and Stripes. If you want to flag your ship in Panama or Liberia ask their navies to come protect your ass, or sail around the Cape of Good Hope.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Leeea

Leeea

Diamond Member
Apr 3, 2020
3,799
5,566
136
what we should do is bomb all redneck red areas in the deep south and midwest and start to fix this country finally.
no.

They are Americans also. They have value to offer. They work, hard.

Violence is not the answer. That is what the Russians want you to believe. That is what Trump wants you to believe.

We can do better. It will be hard, but we can move beyond it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ivwshane and Zorba

Jaskalas

Lifer
Jun 23, 2004
35,276
9,471
136
We can protect those ships flying the Stars and Stripes, the others can pay a protection fee or fly the Stars and Stripes. If you want to flag your ship in Panama or Liberia ask their navies to come protect your ass, or sail around the Cape of Good Hope.
Effectively blocking something as vital as the Suez Canal has massive economic and geopolitical ramifications.
Wars have certainly been started for less. The Houthi's actions are a true casus belli. Though I get the impression from posters here that we are not interested in immediately fronting the defense of the high seas or global commercial shipping. Currently, Pentagon appears to be drawing up plans of action. Perhaps the administration considers this more of a priority than the America people. Then again, it is the Pentagon's job to plan for everything.
 

Zorba

Lifer
Oct 22, 1999
15,613
11,255
136
Effectively blocking something as vital as the Suez Canal has massive economic and geopolitical ramifications.
Wars have certainly been started for less. The Houthi's actions are a true casus belli. Though I get the impression from posters here that we are not interested in immediately fronting the defense of the high seas or global commercial shipping. Currently, Pentagon appears to be drawing up plans of action. Perhaps the administration considers this more of a priority than the America people. Then again, it is the Pentagon's job to plan for everything.
Egypt took over the Suez Canal and makes the money off of it, they can defend it. The EU gets the majority of shipping through the Suez Canal, they can defend it. Israel is committing war crimes, if they want their shipping they can go defend it. If they attack a US ship, we can respond accordingly. No reason to expand the conflict that we are already on the wrong side of.
 

MrSquished

Lifer
Jan 14, 2013
25,944
24,262
136
…and there’s the loud part. Out loud even.
Oh you fucking poor simpleton. I was trolling, and I caught a long time admirer stalker of mine.

I mean long time obsessed. Amusing.

Also, if PC geeks entire village was bombed, come on, we all know we'd be better off as a species. Seriously.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: pcgeek11

Meghan54

Lifer
Oct 18, 2009
11,684
5,225
136
We can protect those ships flying the Stars and Stripes, the others can pay a protection fee or fly the Stars and Stripes. If you want to flag your ship in Panama or Liberia ask their navies to come protect your ass, or sail around the Cape of Good Hope.
Did you know that in 2019 (latest year that has world count) for Oceangoing Self-Propelled, Cargo-Carrying Vessels of 1,000 Gross Tons and Above — the US has 0.4% of world count— 182 vessels out of 43,779 vessels worldwide?


Excel table 1-24 on that page

Our flagged ocean-going cargo fleet is minuscule.
 

Zorba

Lifer
Oct 22, 1999
15,613
11,255
136
Did you know that in 2019 (latest year that has world count) for Oceangoing Self-Propelled, Cargo-Carrying Vessels of 1,000 Gross Tons and Above — the US has 0.4% of world count— 182 vessels out of 43,779 vessels worldwide?


Excel table 1-24 on that page

Our flagged ocean-going cargo fleet is minuscule.
Look at that, each one can have two personal navy ships to protect them. The other 43,600 ships can pay for security from a mercenary force.

I assume all the ships working on oil rigs in the gulf are excluded with one of the exceptions.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Dave_5k

iRONic

Diamond Member
Jan 28, 2006
8,120
3,437
136
Oh you fucking poor simpleton. I was trolling, and I caught a long time admirer stalker of mine.

I mean long time obsessed. Amusing.

Also, if PC geeks entire village was bombed, come on, we all know we'd be better off as a species. Seriously.
Shitlol

You fucking POS, the only thing you ‘caught’ was a case of look at me I’m a pathetic POS calling for the extermination of my political opponents.

Shitlol
 
  • Like
Reactions: pcgeek11

MrSquished

Lifer
Jan 14, 2013
25,944
24,262
136
Shitlol

You fucking POS, the only thing you ‘caught’ was a case of look at me I’m a pathetic POS calling for the extermination of my political opponents.

Shitlol
I've practically been goaded by the biggest pseudo intellectual moronic so-called Democrat in this forum to support a preemptive attack against the shit hole red states and didn't take that stupid bait. I mean Christ you're a fucking moron.

Would you like me to send nudes to you too you pathetic fucking obsessed little person?

We all know there are tens of millions of shit Nazi righties in this country, and all I've seriously proposed is being prepared for their fascism and prepping for a national divorce peacefully , but I'm glad I'm inspiring at least some of you fuckers into some passion.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: pcgeek11

Greenman

Lifer
Oct 15, 1999
21,872
6,248
136
Ok? So you are a horrific nazi supporter like the rest of them. I think I know some of your posting history. We'd be better off if people like you moved to mars and let actual humans with souls run the joint. Go with Elon and the rest of that trash.

How does it feel to be born without a soul?

edit: I just had to look at a few of your posts. You are that person that we'd be better off as a species if you didn't exist. A cockroach with a keyboard.
As far as my mental health issues which included a suicide attempt at 18, which was thirty years ago, I haven't posted that in ages. Look, you barely post here until your recent 'nobody wants to work for you' because they are lazy thread, but turns out you are just a shithead post and nobody wants to work for scumbags. You must really have a hard on for me to dig that deep and that long ago. Fucking hilarious. Obsess much? Loser.

Want me to send you a nude?
Every now and then I push the "see ignored content" button and stuff like this pops up.
Though often related, mental illness and hate are a bad combination. The only advice I can offer is that if you can get past feeling weak and helpless, you'll find the hate and anger will recede. They won't go away, but the rage you feel will abate to tolerable levels.
Best of luck to you.
 
  • Like
Reactions: pcgeek11

[DHT]Osiris

Lifer
Dec 15, 2015
16,992
16,117
146
We can protect those ships flying the Stars and Stripes, the others can pay a protection fee or fly the Stars and Stripes. If you want to flag your ship in Panama or Liberia ask their navies to come protect your ass, or sail around the Cape of Good Hope.
I don't want the US Navy becoming a mercenary force, I'd rather we mandate that we'll only protect ships flying the same flag as any other warship in theatre. Let that region just bristle with a multinational Navy, see who starts spraying bullshit around at that point.
 

Zorba

Lifer
Oct 22, 1999
15,613
11,255
136
I don't want the US Navy becoming a mercenary force, I'd rather we mandate that we'll only protect ships flying the same flag as any other warship in theatre. Let that region just bristle with a multinational Navy, see who starts spraying bullshit around at that point.
Yeah, by protection fee, I meant to a third party mercenary force, not the US Navy. Poor choice of wording on my part.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: [DHT]Osiris
Dec 10, 2005
27,712
12,179
136
As for world police. If someone wants an escort, services are available for a fee. Why am I paying for it? Why do I care about a Nigerian flagged oil tanker going to China?
Because we greatly benefit from a world built on free trade and the post-WW2 institutions and practices we helped to create and shape?

I don't think reverting to a multipolar world governed by spheres of influence is something that would be in the US national interest.
 

KMFJD

Lifer
Aug 11, 2005
31,805
50,094
136
Could make Israel allow food and water into Gaza, that would be a great start to getting the Houthi's to stop...but nah instead it's always the most stupid bloodthirsty option

1702834685737.png
 

pcgeek11

Lifer
Jun 12, 2005
22,183
4,918
136
what we should do is bomb all redneck red areas in the deep south and midwest and start to fix this country finally.

…and there’s the loud part. Out loud even.

Oh you fucking poor simpleton. I was trolling, and I caught a long time admirer stalker of mine.

I mean long time obsessed. Amusing.

Also, if PC geeks entire village was bombed, come on, we all know we'd be better off as a species. Seriously.


LOL You were caught and hoisted on your own Petard and exposed for being a vile and nasty person. Now you are back pedaling frantically.

Not stalking at all. Sometimes I have to laugh at your silly posts.
 

Jaskalas

Lifer
Jun 23, 2004
35,276
9,471
136
but nah instead it's always the most stupid bloodthirsty option
Firing missiles / drones to sink ships in the Red Sea, to close the Suez Canal.
THAT is the bloodthirsty option.

Do you even comprehend how many more people will die as a result of the Houthi's ongoing violence? How many they already killed previously?

12-18: USS Carney responds to distress call following Houthi-claimed attack on commercial ship in Red Sea
12-18:
Oil rises by more than 2% on Red Sea tanker attack, re-routings

Price of oil rises, stokes inflation on Americans, they turn away from Biden.... Trump wins 2024, Russia gets to attack NATO without consequence....
The dominoes here span far and wide. Their missiles and drones need to be counter fired upon immediately.
Oil tankers being attacked will help usher in a timeline you do not want to live in.
 

KMFJD

Lifer
Aug 11, 2005
31,805
50,094
136
Firing missiles / drones to sink ships in the Red Sea, to close the Suez Canal.
THAT is the bloodthirsty option.

Do you even comprehend how many more people will die as a result of the Houthi's ongoing violence? How many they already killed previously?

12-18: USS Carney responds to distress call following Houthi-claimed attack on commercial ship in Red Sea
12-18:
Oil rises by more than 2% on Red Sea tanker attack, re-routings

Price of oil rises, stokes inflation on Americans, they turn away from Biden.... Trump wins 2024, Russia gets to attack NATO without consequence....
The dominoes here span far and wide. Their missiles and drones need to be counter fired upon immediately.
Oil tankers being attacked will help usher in a timeline you do not want to live in.
Much cheaper, less bloodthirsty to stop funding Israel's genocide and have them allow in food/water? Or send in a a carrier group? It's you that doesn't comprehend

The US would rather fight a new war than stop a genocide
 
Last edited:

pauldun170

Diamond Member
Sep 26, 2011
9,291
5,345
136
Tossing this here as a resource
 

cytg111

Lifer
Mar 17, 2008
25,465
14,976
136
Its all prophecy isnt it?

US had incentive to secure global shipping routes after WW2, those incentives are eroding.

 
  • Like
Reactions: Leeea