iPhone 4s... My Thoughts/Impressions

ibex333

Diamond Member
Mar 26, 2005
4,094
123
106
So I just got a White iPhone about 3 weeks ago and I feel that it qualifies me to talk about it and compare it to Android devices.
This is by no means a review, just some thoughts organized into numbered points.
Let me note that I am by no means an Apple fanboy, I never had an iPhone before. That being said I may be turning into a fanboy now.

1)I thought that getting it in White would be awesome, because everyone has Black. Well apparently "everyone" is not stupid. There is something up with the White iPhone - maybe it's just me but the white face doesnt cotrast well with the screen and the borders are clearly visible, whereas with the black face it all comes together very well. Some people mentioned that the black iPhone takes better pictures than White, because the flash somehow reflects off of the white face and decreases the quality of the pictures. May be a bunch of BS though.

Anyway, on to the more important stuff.

2)Dont believe all this crap about people saying that the iPhone 4s is somehow "outdated" as opposed to latest Android devices. The fact remains, that the iPhone simply WORKS and works every time, while the Android phones sometimes work and sometimes dont! And please let's not argue about that, because you all know it's true.
My iPhone never, ever froze, rebooted or gave me even the slightest hint of problems. With my Droid 2 Global, I couldnt even dial numbers 100% of time. Every now and then, the phone would freeze or reboot on it's own. Sometimes during dialing, I would have to press the same digit twice or three times for it to process. And no, it's not just my phone or just this model. I used many other Android phones that my friends own and they all have similar problems.

3)A lot of people tout the Samsung Galaxy S2 as a superior phone. Well, it is an awesome phone. I used it personally, but it is NOT superior. Just like the S2 excels over the iPhone in screen size and even maybe design in some ways, the iPhone still triumphs in camera quality and GPU power. Some people say the S2's camera is almost as good as the iPhones. NO, SORRY, it is NOT. Try taking pictures at night, and you will immediately notice a big difference. The S2 simply cannot compare. Also, notice the speed of taking shots with both phones. Dont get me wrong, the S2 is great in it's own right, and may be the best android phone yet. I didnt notice any slowdowns or freezes on a friends S2.

4)The iPhone has many things on it which are not available on Android phones or that are not available unless you know where to look for them and how to enable them.

Some examples:

a)The whole process of texting is so much more elegant on the iPhone! My DROID may have had a led indicator, but the iPhone is just so much better in notifying me about text overall. It has an audible tone and it flashes the screen. You simply cannot miss that. My Droid would turn of sound for texts randowmly as it would see fit. It would either be too quiet or too loud. Never "just right" like the iPhone. Texts send faster and it al ljust feels snappier.

b)iPhone sends push notifications. I thought it would be annoying, but it's actually awesome. I get notified every time I have a message on a social networking site or a dating site or whatever. I never had that with Android. I am sure someone will tell me this stuff was somewhere in the options or available with an addon. But hey! I dont want to dig for it... My iPhone just has it from start. How cool is that?

c)Games... Do I even have to talk about that? There are so much games on the iPhone as opposed to Android. Dont know about you but for me it's very, very important. I am bored to death on the train and durign work, so I have to be entertained. ; ) Plants and Zombies looks and works great!

d)Sound controls feel a lot smoother and transition better than on the Android phone I had.

e)Virtual keyboard is incredibly responsive. I thought I would miss the physical kb, but I dont! That's quite a feat on Apple's part.

5)A lot of the apps feel better and more responsive. For example some of the apps that view power point presentations and pdf files feel a lot better than they do on Android.


The ONLY cons I could find on the iPhone are:

1)Smallish screen... But ehh.. whatever.. Enough for me, and gives better pixel density resulting in nicer looking gfx.

2)A lot of apps dont rotate screen. With Android, almost anyting and everything could be rotated to landscape. : (



Summary. The iPhone just works! I thought people were making this up but it's 100% true! Android sometimes works and sometime it doesnt. Just like the Galaxy S2 has advantages over iPhone, the iPhone has advantages over S2. The S2 is NOT a superior phone overall, but it's not worse than the iPhone either! The iPhone 4s is AWESOME. I love it.
 

SAWYER

Lifer
Apr 27, 2000
16,742
42
91
*grabs popcorn*
tHw0b.gif
 

evident

Lifer
Apr 5, 2005
12,125
744
126
i have both the iphone 4s and sgs2 and i can subjectively say that i like the sgs2 alot more. sure the camera is a smidge worse than the 4s, the screen on the sgs2 is much nicer.
 

zCypher

Diamond Member
Aug 18, 2002
6,115
171
116
2)Dont believe all this crap about people saying that the iPhone 4s is somehow "outdated" as opposed to latest Android devices. The fact remains, that the iPhone simply WORKS and works every time, while the Android phones sometimes work and sometimes dont! And please let's not argue about that, because you all know it's true.
Shouldn't have brought it up if you don't want anyone to respond to it. ;)
I agree that the iPhone4S is not "outdated", I've never personally heard anyone say this about the iPhone. There is an important distinction to make here. The iPhone has one set of hardware. Obviously, it will either work or it won't. I've no doubt that many Android based devices have been quirky. My phone has never frozen or rebooted or done anything weird though (SGSIIX). A few of my colleagues have the HTC Desire HD and none have any complaints about buggy behavior either.

I can definitely agree that the iPhone is one finely polished product that DOES just work. But I just can't agree with lopping all Android devices into one category, they obviously are not all created equal due to its open nature.

3)A lot of people tout the Samsung Galaxy S2 as a superior phone. Well, it is an awesome phone. I used it personally, but it is NOT superior. Just like the S2 excels over the iPhone in screen size and even maybe design in some ways, the iPhone still triumphs in camera quality and GPU power. Some people say the S2's camera is almost as good as the iPhones. NO, SORRY, it is NOT. Try taking pictures at night, and you will immediately notice a big difference. The S2 simply cannot compare. Also, notice the speed of taking shots with both phones. Dont get me wrong, the S2 is great in it's own right, and may be the best android phone yet. I didnt notice any slowdowns or freezes on a friends S2.
I was pleasantly surprised by the pics I was able to take, honestly I was not expecting much since it IS a camera phone. Those I know with iPhones have not been blown away by their cameras. I don't know anyone with the 4S though, so that might be better. Why don't you post some pics you've taken? :)

4)a)The whole process of texting
The iPhone has a friggin awesome keyboard. Despite its small size, one can text comfortably and it just feels natural. I love my SGSIIX though, its huge size makes texting a breeze too. IMO the difference in texting between these two devices would not be a dealbreaker for me if I were still shopping for a phone.

b)iPhone sends push notifications. I thought it would be annoying
It is annoying. I can't count how many people I've run into that have conflicts with their email on the computer because iPhone is also configured with the same email address + push enabled. How come the blackberry users don't seem to have that trouble so much? I don't need push. The text notifications are perfect the way they are on my phone and Gmail is one tap away.

c)Games... Do I even have to talk about that? There are so much games on the iPhone as opposed to Android. Dont know about you but for me it's very, very important. I am bored to death on the train and durign work, so I have to be entertained. ; ) Plants and Zombies looks and works great!
Do you have Tank Hero? That's one of my favorite ones so far. How do you play anything with such a small screen ;)

d)Sound controls feel a lot smoother and transition better than on the Android phone I had.
Not too sure what you mean here. You mean to adjust the volume?

e)Virtual keyboard is incredibly responsive. I thought I would miss the physical kb, but I dont! That's quite a feat on Apple's part.
Agreed. This does not take away from the Android keyboards though really.

1)Smallish screen... But ehh.. whatever.. Enough for me, and gives better pixel density resulting in nicer looking gfx.
Definitely smallish, example of nicer looking gfx?

2)A lot of apps dont rotate screen. With Android, almost anyting and everything could be rotated to landscape. : (
I've noticed this. Same thing happens on Android but it's not as bad.

Summary. The iPhone just works! I thought people were making this up but it's 100% true! Android sometimes works and sometime it doesnt. Just like the Galaxy S2 has advantages over iPhone, the iPhone has advantages over S2. The S2 is NOT a superior phone overall, but it's not worse than the iPhone either! The iPhone 4s is AWESOME. I love it.

This is where I don't really agree, seems like you're just trying to prompt responses like mine and worse. :p It doesn't make sense to me to say "Android sometimes work and sometimes doesn't" because Android is not the same on all phones. There are so many different iterations of Android and there will be big differences among them.

I wonder how iOS would do spanned across an equal number of different hardware configurations?
 
Last edited:

Ns1

No Lifer
Jun 17, 2001
55,420
1,600
126
How well does your iPhone work when you need to attach two files to an email to your boss?

in 3 years I have never had an issue with this or flash.


re: OP

I love my iPhone. There's only 2 things I wish it would copy from the Android camp

1. Larger screen - obvious....
2. Drag and drop files onto the phone - probably the biggest thing. I would love to use my phone as a USB drive using only the sync cable (like my friend's Evo)
 

boomhower

Diamond Member
Sep 13, 2007
7,228
19
81
I have an iPhone 4S and love. I've also use Android(for much longer than the iPhone actually). This just screams of trolling.
 

runawayprisoner

Platinum Member
Apr 2, 2008
2,496
0
76
How well does your iPhone work when you need to attach two files to an email to your boss?

As discussed in another thread, I don't think such a thing happens on a regular enough basis to make it a deal breaker.

Also considering that there is a way to do it, albeit a bit more complicated, it's not an impossible task to do.

It might be more trouble, but it's not more trouble than having to wade through more folders.

Edit for information I just obtained since last time:
A jailbreak tweak can actually get it to behave the way you want. If you need to know what it is, it's a tweak in Cydia called AnyAttach. Though the user has to fork over $1.99 for it.

But hey, it comes with Dropbox support, can attach multiple files, and works with a direct reply. In other words, it's exactly what you are asking for.

I think we are just nitpicking too much here...
 
Last edited:

redrider4life4

Senior member
Jan 23, 2009
246
0
0
What is the deal with people comparing brand new apple devices against older variants? This isn't just in the phone market, but this is how every argument starts with their damn computers too.

I've heard well my brand new macbook works so much better than my 4 year old laptop, it's like really? A brand new computer works better than an old pos computer? I would never have expected that.
 

Oyeve

Lifer
Oct 18, 1999
22,055
880
126
Wow, another one of these threads. And I am sooooo bored I actually read it.
 

Zaap

Diamond Member
Jun 12, 2008
7,162
424
126
Wow, another one of these threads. And I am sooooo bored I actually read it.
^ Same here.

I have to ask, why is it we don't see these threads every time someone buys a new Android phone? "Hey everyone, let me convince you all that I really do think my phone is awesome! No, really! Here's a bunch of paragraphs of me trying hard to convince you (and myself) that I'm actually happy with my choice!"

No, I don't think there's anything wrong with the iPhone hardware wise- it's the mentality of constantly feeling one has to justify it to themselves and the world that leaves me scratching my head.
 

Ns1

No Lifer
Jun 17, 2001
55,420
1,600
126
No, I don't think there's anything wrong with the iPhone hardware wise- it's the mentality of constantly feeling one has to justify it to themselves and the world that leaves me scratching my head.

I don't know, why doesn't an Android device incite enough excitement in someone to make a thread like this?

My mom got her first 2 real iDevices this year and I've NEVER seen her so excited for a technology related product.
 

redrider4life4

Senior member
Jan 23, 2009
246
0
0
The SGS2 is really from April so yeah a phone 6 months newer will be that much better in this day and age. Maybe it was out in the US late, but it is still an older Android variant. Not to mention like someone else said he was coming from a crappy droid 2.

It's like comparing a 3GS which I know people that have tons of problems with the battery and freezing.
 

Ns1

No Lifer
Jun 17, 2001
55,420
1,600
126
The SGS2 is really from April so yeah a phone 6 months newer will be that much better in this day and age. Maybe it was out in the US late, but it is still an older Android variant. Not to mention like someone else said he was coming from a crappy droid 2.

Is everyone really admitting here that Android sucks balls as of 1 year ago?
 

vshah

Lifer
Sep 20, 2003
19,003
24
81
The SGS2 is really from April so yeah a phone 6 months newer will be that much better in this day and age. Maybe it was out in the US late, but it is still an older Android variant. Not to mention like someone else said he was coming from a crappy droid 2.

It's like comparing a 3GS which I know people that have tons of problems with the battery and freezing.

droid 2 isn't really crappy, and it's useless to compare a sgs2 vs an ip4s, because in the end you're comparing ecosystems and it comes down to much more than hardware.

gs2 hardware is close to the ip4s (except gpu), but that means squat if someone prefers the apple ecosystem over android.
 

Zaap

Diamond Member
Jun 12, 2008
7,162
424
126
I don't know, why doesn't an Android device incite enough excitement in someone to make a thread like this?

My mom got her first 2 real iDevices this year and I've NEVER seen her so excited for a technology related product.
It's one thing to like something you bought, and review it subjectively. It's another when it's the typical fanboish: "Wow this is just soooo superior to ____ based on [lots of outdated/subjective/half-truth to outright falsehood reasons] that I don't see Android phone owners creating thread after thread after thread about.
 

Ns1

No Lifer
Jun 17, 2001
55,420
1,600
126
It's one thing to like something you bought, and review it subjectively. It's another when it's the typical fanboish: "Wow this is just soooo superior to ____ based on [lots of outdated/subjective/half-truth to outright falsehood reasons] that I don't see Android phone owners creating thread after thread after thread about.

I'm sorry that your flavor-of-the-week android device doesn't incite enough excitement to make a post about.


FWIW, I went to another AT&T store yesterday and they still don't have the SGS2 for me to play with. I was really, really excited about that device but Samsung/ATT have made it impossible for me to find one and check it out.