If Peyton Maning & the Colts DON'T win the Super Bowl

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

Gunther

Golden Member
Mar 6, 2001
1,292
0
0
I don't think its really going to matter what team he plays for because imo he is the reason the colts havent won a superbowl. You can blame the colts defense all you want, but in reality he is the one who performs poorly in the playoffs. If you look at the numbers the defense usually plays about the same in the playoffs as they were playing during the regular season, but peyton's performance drops during the playoffs.
Imo peyton is a great quarterback, but he doesn't seem to be able to deal with immense pressure well like in a playoff game.
 

Fern

Elite Member
Sep 30, 2003
26,907
174
106
Originally posted by: Gunther
I don't think its really going to matter what team he plays for because imo he is the reason the colts havent won a superbowl. You can blame the colts defense all you want, but in reality he is the one who performs poorly in the playoffs. If you look at the numbers the defense usually plays about the same in the playoffs as they were playing during the regular season, but peyton's performance drops during the playoffs.
Imo peyton is a great quarterback, but he doesn't seem to be able to deal with immense pressure well like in a playoff game.

I don't recall Peyton ever having a "melt down" (like Eli or Grossman) in the playoffs.

But wouldn't surprise me if his numbers are down a bit in playoffs - the competition should be much better in the playoffs.

Fern
 

herkulease

Diamond Member
Jul 6, 2001
3,923
0
0
Originally posted by: cubby1223
Originally posted by: laurenlex
He needs to take a pay cut to get some salary cap room for the D. But he won't.

<------- Hates Manning.
Does nobody comprehend math?
http://msn.foxsports.com/nfl/teamSalary?categoryId=67048

NFL Salary Cap: $102 million
Colts Payroll: $69 million
Payton Manning's Salary: $670k

Those numbers are wrong. they are last year's salary with players moved to current teams. Anyhow the colts payroll maybe 69 million but their cap figure much higher. If that was accurate then the Falcons are over the salary cap. Anyhow Peyton took home a fat check a few years ago. But how his salary is counted towards the cap is broken up over the years.

anyhow USA today is more accurate. link

Provides not just player salary but also their cap value.

 

slsmnaz

Diamond Member
Mar 13, 2005
4,016
1
0
Originally posted by: Gunther
I don't think its really going to matter what team he plays for because imo he is the reason the colts havent won a superbowl. You can blame the colts defense all you want, but in reality he is the one who performs poorly in the playoffs. If you look at the numbers the defense usually plays about the same in the playoffs as they were playing during the regular season, but peyton's performance drops during the playoffs.
Imo peyton is a great quarterback, but he doesn't seem to be able to deal with immense pressure well like in a playoff game.

Did I just dream of him having a perfect passer rating in the playoffs vs Denver recently? I must have since you said his performance ALWAYS drop.

You mentioned the problem, the D plays the exact same which is bad. When you must consistently score 30-40 pts to win a game it will bite you.
 

mchammer187

Diamond Member
Nov 26, 2000
9,114
0
76
Originally posted by: cubby1223
Originally posted by: laurenlex
He needs to take a pay cut to get some salary cap room for the D. But he won't.

<------- Hates Manning.
Does nobody comprehend math?
http://msn.foxsports.com/nfl/teamSalary?categoryId=67048

NFL Salary Cap: $102 million
Colts Payroll: $69 million
Payton Manning's Salary: $670k

from wikipedia:

In 2004, Manning became the highest-paid player in NFL history at the time, signing a $99.2m contract for seven years with a $34.5m signing bonus, which averages out to $14.17m annually. Under the contract, Manning is also eligible to earn an extra $19m in incentives.[citation needed]
 

slsmnaz

Diamond Member
Mar 13, 2005
4,016
1
0
Originally posted by: herkulease
Originally posted by: cubby1223
Originally posted by: laurenlex
He needs to take a pay cut to get some salary cap room for the D. But he won't.

<------- Hates Manning.
Does nobody comprehend math?
http://msn.foxsports.com/nfl/teamSalary?categoryId=67048

NFL Salary Cap: $102 million
Colts Payroll: $69 million
Payton Manning's Salary: $670k

Those numbers are wrong. they are last year's salary with players moved to current teams. Anyhow the colts payroll maybe 69 million but their cap figure much higher. If that was accurate then the Falcons are over the salary cap. Anyhow Peyton took home a fat check a few years ago. But how his salary is counted towards the cap is broken up over the years.

anyhow USA today is more accurate. link

Provides not just player salary but also their cap value.

So Edge was a bigger cap hit yet Manning is blamed? What did they do w/ that money when he left? Seems they could have bought a decent defense but didn't. I guess Manning makes personnel decisions too.
 

Deeko

Lifer
Jun 16, 2000
30,213
12
81
Originally posted by: Fern
Originally posted by: Deeko
you can't "quit", they have "contracts"

Meh, Cowher has a year left on his, Saban had several years on his Dolphin contract.

Prolly just takes some money to make it happen. If he wants to quit, I don't think they'd try to force him to stay.


Fern

they are coaches, not players, and yea Peyton could "retire" from the NFL but then he'd have to pay back much of his salary cap and it would be a fight for him to play for anyone else. You can't just "quit" on a team. You can hold out, but you can't "quit", and the Colts sure as sh!t aren't about to let go the best QB in the league, whom they've invested 10 years and many millions of dollars in.
 

herkulease

Diamond Member
Jul 6, 2001
3,923
0
0
Originally posted by: slsmnaz
So Edge was a bigger cap hit yet Manning is blamed? What did they do w/ that money when he left? Seems they could have bought a decent defense but didn't. I guess Manning makes personnel decisions too.

Peyton gets blamed because his 99 million dollar deal and subsequent extension to help with cap space would still be around the next 5-6 years at least if not longer.

Edge had a high cap figure in 2005 because his contract was already up after the 2004 season. they franchised him, which is just a 1 year contract. so they can't spread the cap charge over a few seasons.

I dunno what they did with the money the salary cap increased nearly 17 million dollars from 05 to 06 and the colts were some 9 million or so under the 102 million dollar cap. Whether that 9 mil under before the season started already factored in Marvin's extension I don't know.

Anyhow I don't think even peyton can take a pay cut that will really help the team. I mean if I was playing and already got a 100 million dollar deal. and was deseperate I'd sign on for a few more years at 1 dollar and spread cap hits over the extra years. Only thing stopping would be the players association who would file complaints about it.

This off season will be telling of the colts. they let go of two players they could've used this year Larry Tripplett the DT and David Thorton the LB.

Dwight Freeney I know contract is up and some offensive players too like Dallas Clark. It'll tell us which direction the organization is going.
 

Deeko

Lifer
Jun 16, 2000
30,213
12
81
Originally posted by: j00fek
its all about the rings

tom brady 3

peyton 0

lol

such a hilarious argument, I forgot that QBs actually play 1 v 11, and play defense too

by your logic, terry bradshaw is the best QB of all time!
 

Phokus

Lifer
Nov 20, 1999
22,994
779
126
Originally posted by: Deeko
Originally posted by: j00fek
its all about the rings

tom brady 3

peyton 0

lol

such a hilarious argument, I forgot that QBs actually play 1 v 11, and play defense too

by your logic, terry bradshaw is the best QB of all time!

Yeah it was a simplistic argument, but doesn't brady have better postseason numbers than manning?
 

hpkeeper

Diamond Member
Jun 30, 2000
4,036
0
0
Originally posted by: cubby1223
Originally posted by: laurenlex
He needs to take a pay cut to get some salary cap room for the D. But he won't.

<------- Hates Manning.
Does nobody comprehend math?
http://msn.foxsports.com/nfl/teamSalary?categoryId=67048

NFL Salary Cap: $102 million
Colts Payroll: $69 million
Payton Manning's Salary: $670k

Where are you getting $670k for Manning's salary...? maybe in 2005. This year his salary is paying him $1.0M and has a potential of $9.0M in bonuses.
 

herkulease

Diamond Member
Jul 6, 2001
3,923
0
0
Originally posted by: Deeko
Originally posted by: Fern
Originally posted by: Deeko
you can't "quit", they have "contracts"

Meh, Cowher has a year left on his, Saban had several years on his Dolphin contract.

Prolly just takes some money to make it happen. If he wants to quit, I don't think they'd try to force him to stay.


Fern

they are coaches, not players, and yea Peyton could "retire" from the NFL but then he'd have to pay back much of his salary cap and it would be a fight for him to play for anyone else. You can't just "quit" on a team. You can hold out, but you can't "quit", and the Colts sure as sh!t aren't about to let go the best QB in the league, whom they've invested 10 years and many millions of dollars in.

He'll have to pay back some of his signing bonus money. But that's only if the team wants to be mean and demand some of it back. The team isn't relived of the cap charges a former player's contract incurs either(retires, traded). The niners have been using the "dead weight" excuse the last few years for not signing players.
 

Deeko

Lifer
Jun 16, 2000
30,213
12
81
Peyton's posteason numbers: 193/322(59.9%), 2,461 yd(7.64), 15 td(4.66%), 8 int (2.48%), 89.05 QB rating
Brady's postseason numbers: 225/367(61%) 2493 yds(6.79), 15 TD(4.08%), 5 int(1.36%), 89.42 QB rating

So, pretty similar, Peyton with a higher YPA and higher TD%, Brady with a higher completion and lower int%. Virtually identical ratings. Both have played VERY well in the playoffs, the difference being Brady has a defense to support him.

ps my numbers came from Wikipedia
 

yosuke188

Platinum Member
Apr 19, 2005
2,726
2
0
Everyone loves to blame the Colts defense. It's true they do give up a lot of points.

But that's because all the money goes into the offense. They have the best 2 WR combination of Harrison and Wayne, and O-line that is close to best in the league, a great receiving TE Dallas Clark. They use to have the Edge, now they have a 1st round pick RB Addai. And of course there's Peyton Manning.

And I somehow remember that the Colts scored only 3 points in a playoff game against the Pats. You can say they scored a ton against Denver in the playoffs, but when with that kind of an explosive offense, they are suppose to score a lot, and when they don't, they lose. Manning has to come through on every game, and he just doesn't do it on some playoff games.
 

JulesMaximus

No Lifer
Jul 3, 2003
74,600
1,005
126
I got news for you. Peyton Manning and the Colts aren't going to the Super Bowl this year.
 

slsmnaz

Diamond Member
Mar 13, 2005
4,016
1
0
Originally posted by: yosuke188
Everyone loves to blame the Colts defense. It's true they do give up a lot of points.

But that's because all the money goes into the offense. They have the best 2 WR combination of Harrison and Wayne, and O-line that is close to best in the league, a great receiving TE Dallas Clark. They use to have the Edge, now they have a 1st round pick RB Addai. And of course there's Peyton Manning.

And I somehow remember that the Colts scored only 3 points in a playoff game against the Pats. You can say they scored a ton against Denver in the playoffs, but when with that kind of an explosive offense, they are suppose to score a lot, and when they don't, they lose. Manning has to come through on every game, and he just doesn't do it on some playoff games.

Did you even watch the Steelers game last year? The Colts o-line was awful! It was also years before any of them were voted to the Pro-Bowl. If you build a team that must score 30-40 pts a game to win then you will get bitten.
 

Shlong

Diamond Member
Mar 14, 2002
3,130
59
91
Originally posted by: cubby1223
Originally posted by: laurenlex
He needs to take a pay cut to get some salary cap room for the D. But he won't.

<------- Hates Manning.
Does nobody comprehend math?
http://msn.foxsports.com/nfl/teamSalary?categoryId=67048

NFL Salary Cap: $102 million
Colts Payroll: $69 million
Payton Manning's Salary: $670k

That's his base salary. You have to include his signing bonus (which I think was pro-rated) and then you'll get his salary cap hit.

http://www.coltfreaks.com/index.php?call=bios 10.6 million cap hit in 2006 (9.62% of the 102 million NFL salary cap). Next year the salary cap goes higher but so does Manning's cap hit as his base salary increases.
 

Deeko

Lifer
Jun 16, 2000
30,213
12
81
Originally posted by: j00fek
numbers as in WINS

About 30 or so players for each team play in an NFL game. You do realize that, right? Its not a difficult concept. Players make plays. Teams win games. If statistically what Peyton is doing is about the same as what Brady is doing, how can you say Brady is a much better player? Also, Brady is allowed to play "safer" football and not take as many chances, because he has a defense capable of stopping the other team. Who is to say that Peyton wouldn't be undefeated and have a 100 playoff rating if he had a better defense? Its not even that they don't score points - they do - Manning has NOTHING to do with how many points the other team scores.
 

Deeko

Lifer
Jun 16, 2000
30,213
12
81
by the way, you certainly sound like a Pats fan, so I understand your point of view, but remember that I am a fan of a team that also had a QB win 3 superbowls in 4 years - and go to the championship game in between, as opposed to not making the playoffs. I see Pats fans calling Brady the best or 2nd best QB of all time. Not only do I think that is ridiculous, but I certainly wouldn't even put Aikman there, maybe not even top five.

This is all neither here nor there. The question is should Peyton leave the Colts, and I say no - he's in a high powered offense, and if they manage to get a few good defensive players (and keep the ones they have healthy), they are a superbowl contender every year.