If a potential employer calls you up with an offer...

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

SagaLore

Elite Member
Dec 18, 2001
24,036
21
81
Originally posted by: Dezign
Originally posted by: bunker
If I'm the hiring manager and someone says they'll get back to me, I'm going to the next person on my list.

The job market still isn't great and there are plenty of people that will jump on almost any offer.

Hmm. Ouch. Contrary to the advice I've been given so far, but a good point. You wouldn't wait around? If the person did say they'd be interested and get back to you, would you automatically cancel them and make an offer to the next person on the list?

Typically, if I apply for a job I really want, and they call me and ask me if I am still interested, I will take it.
 

jjones

Lifer
Oct 9, 2001
15,424
2
0
Assuming you reject the initial offer because it is not acceptable, then you must have a counter-offer in mind. If this is the case, then I would inform them that you are interested but would like to see if they are negotiable on the compensation package. If they are, then request a meeting at their earliest convenience to hammer out the final deal.

If they are not negotiable on the compensation, then ask them for a few hours, or until early the next morning to make a decision.

If the initial offer is acceptable, then don't play any games, just accept the offer.
 

Riprorin

Banned
Apr 25, 2000
9,634
0
0
Tell them that you have several other opportunities/offers that you're considering and you need a day or so to think it over.

I don't think that appearing desperate is a very attractive quality.
 

Ameesh

Lifer
Apr 3, 2001
23,686
1
0
Originally posted by: bunker
If I'm the hiring manager and someone says they'll get back to me, I'm going to the next person on my list.

The job market still isn't great and there are plenty of people that will jump on almost any offer.

i seriously doubt you are a hiring manager with that attitude or you are filling a position that probably doesnt even require an interview.
 

Ameesh

Lifer
Apr 3, 2001
23,686
1
0
there nothing wrong in sounding excited about getting the offer but dont accept on the spot, just tell him you'll get back to him tommorow and you want to take the night to consider it.

 

kenshorin

Golden Member
Apr 14, 2001
1,160
0
0
Originally posted by: Dezign
Originally posted by: bunker
If I'm the hiring manager and someone says they'll get back to me, I'm going to the next person on my list.

The job market still isn't great and there are plenty of people that will jump on almost any offer.

Hmm. Ouch. Contrary to the advice I've been given so far, but a good point. You wouldn't wait around? If the person did say they'd be interested and get back to you, would you automatically cancel them and make an offer to the next person on the list?

Most hiring personnel will give you at least a day or two to consider the options that you have been presented with. Give them a close enough deadline when you will get back to them, and don't miss it, and you should have no problems.

Thats the way its been for every job I've been offered. (and I'd be willing to bet that I was not head and shoulders above everyone else in a few of those offers either.)
 

Vic

Elite Member
Jun 12, 2001
50,422
14,337
136
Always be excited at a job offer. It's not bad news (quite the contrary, it's great news). But you don't accept on the spot either. Jeez, get the numbers first. Ask them to fax or email an offer letter to you with all the details -- pay, benefits, vacation, etc.. Nothing shows seriousness more than wanting to see the $$. Inform them that you will review it promptly and get back to them first thing tomorrow.

Don't play games or even consider playing games -- i.e. worrying about sounding "desperate", etc. Duplicity is not a good way to start off the employment relationship. Be serious. If you like the compensation package, say so and take it, or they might give it to someone else. If you don't, say so and counter with what you really want (provided it is reasonable). If no negotiation is possible, then either accept or be prepared to not take the job. The key point is to get it in writing with an opportunity to review it and consider it.
 

jamesave

Golden Member
Aug 27, 2000
1,610
0
76
Originally posted by: Vic
Always be excited at a job offer. It's not bad news (quite the contrary, it's great news). But you don't accept on the spot either. Jeez, get the numbers first. Ask them to fax or email an offer letter to you with all the details -- pay, benefits, vacation, etc.. Nothing shows seriousness more than wanting to see the $$. Inform them that you will review it promptly and get back to them first thing tomorrow.

Don't play games or even consider playing games -- i.e. worrying about sounding "desperate", etc. Duplicity is not a good way to start off the employment relationship. Be serious. If you like the compensation package, say so and take it, or they might give it to someone else. If you don't, say so and counter with what you really want (provided it is reasonable). If no negotiation is possible, then either accept or be prepared to not take the job. The key point is to get it in writing with an opportunity to review it and consider it.

Especially when they have other candidate-

BTW, congrats.
 

Argo

Lifer
Apr 8, 2000
10,045
0
0
Design, I'm not sure if you already got the answer but here's what I'd do. I'd ask them when do they expect a reply. Most companies give you a day or two. The lowest I've seen was 3 days and the longest - 2 weeks. As soon as they hang up I'd head over to www.salary.com and check out average salary in that area. If the offer happens to be in line with the average, and provided you like it - I'd accept, now isn't the time to be picky.

If however, it happens to be lower than mean, I'd mention that to the recruiting manager and ask for increase. Of course this depends on how comfortable you are with taking a risk. I highly doubt they'll take their offer back just because of that - they selected you for a reason and they want you to join them. The worst thing that could happen is they'll stick with their offer, which will put you in a difficult situation. In my case they gave me a $2,000 increase, at which point I accepted.

Hope this helps,

-Joe
 

Yax

Platinum Member
Feb 11, 2003
2,866
0
0
"May I have a couple of days to consider your offer before giving you an answer?"