IDE vs SCSI

meaty

Banned
Jan 27, 2000
784
0
0
I am a speed freak & was wondering if the move from ata133 7200rpm HD to 15k SCSI would be worth the huge chunck of change?
This would mainly used for burning DVD's/CDR's & gaming:) Would I see a major difference?
I know SCSI has it issues & dont want to run into any, also what would be the best ULTRA160 SCSI controller for your $$.
 

Oyeve

Lifer
Oct 18, 1999
22,071
885
126
Bottom line is SCSI (especially u160) is always better than IDE. As for it being worth it is purely a personal thing. I use all U160 and love it. I have 14 u160 drives in 2 external chassis using 1 Adaptec 21960N card and a U160 scsi raid card. This is an extrememly exspensive setup which is why IDE is usually preferred. I can utilize all my drives at the same time and my system hardly slows down at all. If you run all your IDE devices at the same time your system will crawl. SCSI does need better cooling though. My take is if you can afford it then why not?
 

Hender

Senior member
Aug 10, 2000
647
1
0
You won't see a major speed boost, really. SCSI is superior to IDE in terms of drive technology and reliability, as well as CPU usage and sustained transfer rates, but it's not something you'll notice on the type of system you have and what you use it for because you're not likely doing any heavy video and multimedia editing that practically requires SCSI. I have a full SCSI disk system (HD, DVD, CDRW) just for kicks--let me rephrase that, I have a full SCSI subsystem because I already had the expensive card and several of the peripherals, and it's cheaper to continue buying SCSI than replace everything--and all I can do is transfer files from one location on my hard drive to another faster than an IDE drive, as well as load CounterStrike maps a full 5-10 seconds faster than anyone else.

If you're not going to use it as a server or as a multimedia editing machine, ignore the cost of SCSI. It's still superior to IDE, but not in any way that would be tangible for you're really that desparate for speed, pick up an ATA/133 RAID card from Promise or someone and set up a RAID 0 array with another hard drive. It would offset some of the problems with IDE and put you more on the level of SCSI, but as a fraction of the price.
 

majewski9

Platinum Member
Jun 26, 2001
2,060
0
0
I would just buy two IDE drives and RAID them!!!! SCSI is too costly per gigabyte! Controllers are also like 100+ for u160!