Originally posted by: racolvin
Originally posted by: shira
You know, I suspect all the reasons that people oppose "illegals" are phony. I suspect that if objective research were done, it would be determined that illegals represent a huge PLUS to the U.S. economy. But everyone needs someone to hate; someone to blame for the erosion - real or perceived - of the standard of living in America. And illegals are an easy target.
I suspect that if one by one, all the reasons to oppose illegals were shot down convincingly, the reactionary right would STILL despise illegals. Why? Because they're "illegal." And they're different. And they're poor. And many of them don't speak English.
Kick the bastards out! Those who hire them? Hang 'em high! Feels good to be kicking butt again for a change.
Jingoist, ignorant fools.
What a steaming pile of bleeding-heart liberal poo ...
*I* personally oppose them for the following reasons:
1) They're here illegally. They flaunt the laws of the very country they're trying to get in to and then expect the laws of that same country to help and protect them.
2) Yes, they don't speak English. Citizenship standards require a basic command of reading and writing in English, so why should they be exempt?
3) Identity theft by illegals. As has already been mentioned in this very thread, stolen SS#'s are used to get the job and yes they pay taxes into the system via that method but the cost to the individual whose SS#'s was used isn't calculated.
4) They diminish they accomplishment and efforts of those who DID do things the legal way and became citizens.
I could go on but what's the point? All you'll do is cry about how horrible it is to treat them like criminal despite the fact that they ARE criminals...
What would I do to change things?
1) Children will no longer automatically be citizens if they're born on US soil if both parents are here illegally. Automatic citizenship will only be bestowed on a child if at least one of the parents is a LEGAL CITIZEN, not just a resident.
2) Local law enforcement can detain and states can deport on their own, as long as ICE is notified at every step along the way
3) Employers found hiring and paying illegal workers will be fined $1,000 per day per illegal worker with no limit to how high the fine can go, even if that means bankrupting and shuttering the employer. Does that mean some pain? Yes it does but employers will dump those illegal workers fast and with no work and no automatic citizenship for their babies (see #1 above) the incentive to come to America illegally will fade FAST.
4) Step up enforcement of #2 and #3