<<personally i thought she was robbed in nagano... but that aside she wasted another 4 years of her life to train for this year, and i think it's sad that she wasn't able to perform her best because i for one feels she does deserve a gold medal.
as for the routine difficulty, i think this is just what it always comes down to in skating and gymnastics and sports of this type. Youth will eventually prevail... the reason being when kwan started skating jumps like 3x axles were just being introduced in womens skating and could only be done well by a select few... now its a norm... it's hard for veterans to learn new tricks... i.e. i doubt any of the male pro's on the stars on ice tour can do a 4x jump... personally i don't like the trend mainly because it takes away from the overall picture... younger skaters can do the more difficult moves but usually at a cost of presentation... they can pull it off, but mainly because of their size and increased centripetal forces when they spin... eh, i'm rambling on now...>>
Unlike the men's competition, the women's competition has not made any significant advancements since the Nagano games. The most difficult jump for a woman to perform is still the triple-triple combination, it was true in 98, it's still true now, no woman skater now can do triple axels or quads, that hasn't changed. Tara Lipinski was able to do a triple-triple in Nagano, Michelle Kwan was not, that gold metal decision was debatable. If these judges really wanted to be sentimental because of Kwan's background, then they would not have botched two chances to crown her the gold metal. Learning the sacred triple-triple combination is not old dog trying to learn new trick, it has been performed by women before Kwan's time, and she had four years to master this jump but she showed no sign of improvement here in Salt Lake, turning her planned triple-triple into a typical triple-double, which is why it was pretty much a consensus that she did not deserve the gold this time. Some people tell me they don't care about technicality, I say fine, the judges care. Triple-triple combination jumps will soon be a norm in women's figure skating, the same effect Quadruple jumps had on the men's figure skating, back in Nagano, quads were unheard of, now they're taken for granted. To sum it up, for Michelle Kwan to have any chance in winning a gold metal in the next Olympics, she absolutely has to turn up a notch in her technical skills, while try to maintain her edge on the artistic side. Even then, I would say her chances are slim, because we have these young kids who are technically superior to her and are still improving. It's hard to squeeze out anymore improvements out of Michelle Kwan.
<<they should probably start capping a more realistic age limit for skaters and a more concrete judging system...>>
Age limit wouldn't be practical, if a country has a great champion, it would be desired for him/her to be on Olympic stage as long as he/she can, setting age limits shortens their Olympic career which is really not what the countries or the Olympics want. But I agree there ought to be some changes to the judging system.