I tried to support Chrysler... but dayum... bring on Honda! (or Toyota)

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

jhayx7

Platinum Member
Oct 1, 2005
2,226
0
0
Originally posted by: iamwiz82

I just bought a Toyota two weeks ago. I just get annoyed when people bitch and moan over a maintenance item. Spark plugs go bad, and according to the maintenance schedule I am looking at, they are to be replaced at 30,000 miles. Honda recommends the exact same interval for the Civic.

No, Honda states 100k miles:

Under normal usage, a tune-up is not required until typically more than 100,000 miles (only routine inspections and fluid changes are required up to this point). Credit for this longevity goes to long-wearing iridium spark plugs, a long-life timing chain, and careful engineering of the precisely manufactured SOHC valvetrain-which reliably maintains proper valve tappet clearances until the first tune-up

I replaced mine at 100k and they looked worn but not destroyed. I replaced the old spark plugs with new Iridium plugs and am looking forward to replacing them at 200k.
 

Raduque

Lifer
Aug 22, 2004
13,140
138
106
Originally posted by: CrackRabbit

The hose may not of taken that long but getting to the back three spark plugs on a transversely mounted V-6 could be a large chunk of it.
Probably had to drop the motor to just get to them.

Yep, this is likely the cause of the high bill. Labor involved with getting at the back 3 spark plugs, hooray for FWD!

edit: fixed quote tags
 

BNO

Senior member
Jan 6, 2001
279
0
76
Originally posted by: jhayx7
Originally posted by: iamwiz82

I just bought a Toyota two weeks ago. I just get annoyed when people bitch and moan over a maintenance item. Spark plugs go bad, and according to the maintenance schedule I am looking at, they are to be replaced at 30,000 miles. Honda recommends the exact same interval for the Civic.

No, Honda states 100k miles:

And most Toyotas are 120,000 miles

 

CFster

Golden Member
Oct 16, 1999
1,903
0
76
Where do people get this information.

The book only gets 1.6hrs to change all the plugs on an '03 Caravan.

Not sure which motor he has, the 3.3L or 3.8L, but the labor time is the same.

You don't have to tilt the engine forward or drop it down or anything. The only engines you had to tilt forward were some GM V6s.



 

thomsbrain

Lifer
Dec 4, 2001
18,148
1
0
Originally posted by: iamwiz82
Spark plugs are regular maintenance items. They are $2/each at the auto parts store. You take your Honda in for it's regular maintenace, why not the van?

modern hondas only need new plugs every 105,000 miles. no joke. "scheduled maintenance" on their current models is literally nothing more than occasional oil, filter, and air filter changes plus inspections, until you get to 105,000 miles, and then you change belts and plugs. at ~120,000 miles, you change your coolant and transmission fluid for the first time. compared to even old hondas, these new ones are practically maintenance-free.
 

Pepsi90919

Lifer
Oct 9, 1999
25,162
1
81
Originally posted by: iamwiz82
Spark plugs are regular maintenance items. They are $2/each at the auto parts store. You take your Honda in for it's regular maintenace, why not the van?

it was probably a vacuum hose, the other thing he stated, not the spark plugs. and in minivans, it's hard to change spark plugs, adding to the total cost.
 

Gamingphreek

Lifer
Mar 31, 2003
11,679
0
81
Thats interesting about Chrysler. We've had many vans with Chrysler and I have also noticed the exact same things. Don't get me wrong, they were nice vans, but very unreliable.

Usually with Chrysler you worry about the Drivetrain. I know in our last one (Before we traded for a Honda Pilot) the Torque Converter was pretty bad after a mere 55,000 miles. It would slip a way too much and then jolt and engage. The transmissions, while we had no problems with them, are pretty pitiful as well. They had a nice idea with their "4th Prime" gear, but at the same time, they are one of the only manf who still use 4-speed engines religiously.

If I remember right the main problems we had with ours were the belts. I can't remember what exactly happened- I would have to ask my father if he remembers.

The engines, from what I remember were fairly nice though. Nothing special about them, but at the same time, our 3.8L V6 had absolutely no problem hauling my parents, myself, 2 sisters, 2 dogs, and luggage up and down mountains.

As for the spark plugs, you should ask to see them. It's your car the dealer should respect your request. As long as the engine isn't misfiring, or firing with too much O2 (You know all the possibilities) then your spark plugs should be absolutely fine.

I honestly don't know what hose could possibly cost the difference there though. Vacuum hoses, Intake all are fairly cheap. The A/C is the only one I can think of that may cost more.

-Kevin
 

JulesMaximus

No Lifer
Jul 3, 2003
74,544
924
126
Originally posted by: Ktulu
Originally posted by: rudder
Originally posted by: Ktulu
Originally posted by: rudder
Originally posted by: iamwiz82
Originally posted by: jhayx7
Originally posted by: iamwiz82
Spark plugs are regular maintenance items. They are $2/each at the auto parts store. You take your Honda in for it's regular maintenace, why not the van?

So she takes it to the shop and reports back that we have bad spark plugs and a ripped hose (cant remember what she said exactly)... cha-ching $450.

Re-read the post. Spark Plugs + hose should not have been over $150.

I think he was pointing out how bad they stuck it in his prison wallet without any hello jelly.

I did re-read it. I also read where he doesn't even know what was done. I cannot think of many hoses that have 6-8 hours of labor involved in replacing them.

Nothing was done... it was just a quote. My point is the dodge sucks, i think its the fuel injectors and the dealer is probably trying to scam my wife.

Dodge sucks or the dealer sucks?

both suck.. the van is crap and the dealership is an ass to deal with. Never had that problem at an Honda dealer I have visited.

Well I doubt Honda or Toyota are immune from shady dealerships or bad products.

I've never had any trouble with the Toyota dealership when I had a Toyota or the Nissan service department for my Maxima and Lexus will freaking bend over backward to make sure you're happy. I've never experienced anything near the level of Lexus service from any American car dealership. I have a friend who had a brand new C6 Corvette and he had horrible experiences at the dealership. This is a guy who paid over $45k for a brand new Vette.

My wife's Lexus IS250 had a small tear develop in the driver's seat after about 10k miles. It was about an inch long and the dealer replaced the entire seat (not just the seating surface, the entire seat) with a brand new one under warranty...no questions asked. I wonder what a power driver's seat for an IS250 costs if you had to replace it yourself.

They also detailed the car for her and gave her a free loaner car while they had her car.
 

bctbct

Diamond Member
Dec 22, 2005
4,868
1
0
Originally posted by: thomsbrain

modern hondas only need new plugs every 105,000 miles. no joke. "scheduled maintenance" on their current models is literally nothing more than occasional oil, filter, and air filter changes plus inspections, until you get to 105,000 miles, and then you change belts and plugs. at ~120,000 miles, you change your coolant and transmission fluid for the first time. compared to even old hondas, these new ones are practically maintenance-free.

what is the replacement schedule on the timing belt?

 

vi edit

Elite Member
Super Moderator
Oct 28, 1999
62,484
8,345
126
Originally posted by: bctbct
Originally posted by: thomsbrain

modern hondas only need new plugs every 105,000 miles. no joke. "scheduled maintenance" on their current models is literally nothing more than occasional oil, filter, and air filter changes plus inspections, until you get to 105,000 miles, and then you change belts and plugs. at ~120,000 miles, you change your coolant and transmission fluid for the first time. compared to even old hondas, these new ones are practically maintenance-free.

what is the replacement schedule on the timing belt?

Belts are around 90k, although some brands like VW suggest doing it at around 60k. Chains *typically* are the life of the engine.
 

jagec

Lifer
Apr 30, 2004
24,442
6
81
Originally posted by: rudder
Edited to add another point: I used to not mind doing my own maintainence... but now I am busier and have more money, I pay someone else. I am just amazed about the lack of quality in this dodge mini van. Its babied by the wife, regular scheduled maintainence items are taken care of... yet I was quoted $450 to repair something in a car that has 54K miles versus my awesome running civic.

You may be a mechanic.. super for you... you may like Dodge cars... double good for you. My next car will be a honda or toyota.

After having to deal with the Suzuki dealership for the past couple of months (someone backed into my bike, figured I'd let the professionals handle it since it hadn't been dumped before and insurance was paying), I'm becoming more and more convinced that shops end up wasting MORE of your time as well as money vs. doing it yourself.

If you do it yourself, you pull stuff out, take a few hours to figure out the problem and put things back together, and then it's done.

With a shop, you take it in, either get a loaner or start taking the bus, spend the next several days playing phone tag just to get an idea of when they'll be finished, argue over the estimate, more phone tag, argue over the bill, get told that it's finished, take time off work to pick it up, turns out it's not, more phone tag, finally it does get done but they didn't do ALL the work, more phone tag...

Just not worth the hassle IMHO.
 

dartworth

Lifer
Jul 29, 2001
15,200
10
81
Originally posted by: JulesMaximus


My wife's Lexus IS250 had a small tear develop in the driver's seat after about 10k miles. It was about an inch long and the dealer replaced the entire seat (not just the seating surface, the entire seat) with a brand new one under warranty...no questions asked. I wonder what a power driver's seat for an IS250 costs if you had to replace it yourself.

They also detailed the car for her and gave her a free loaner car while they had her car.


so your wife is a fatass...big deal...
 

TraumaRN

Diamond Member
Jun 5, 2005
6,893
63
91
What I don't understand is how one bad experience suddenly means that another car company is better....

I mean my father has worked for Ford for years and years now...all we've ever owned is mostly Ford products and styling or personal tastes aside we've never had any 'major' issues with any of them.

My mother's 2003 Explorer has needed a new oxygen sensor and has 60K miles on...otherwise normal maintenance

Dad's 1999 Explorer, 165K miles on...just had a vacuum hose replaced last week, other than that I can't ever remember him taking it in for repairs.

My 2002 Taurus with 107K miles on....routine maintenance...friday it gets new tires, and shocks

Etc etc....

Everyone could go on about their lemon experiences....yet it just FLOORS me that one lemon makes them think American is bad, or Imports are bad....
 

Pepsi90919

Lifer
Oct 9, 1999
25,162
1
81
Originally posted by: dartworth
Originally posted by: JulesMaximus


My wife's Lexus IS250 had a small tear develop in the driver's seat after about 10k miles. It was about an inch long and the dealer replaced the entire seat (not just the seating surface, the entire seat) with a brand new one under warranty...no questions asked. I wonder what a power driver's seat for an IS250 costs if you had to replace it yourself.

They also detailed the car for her and gave her a free loaner car while they had her car.


so your wife is a fatass...big deal...

i see you're taking the high road in this discussion
 

markgm

Diamond Member
Aug 23, 2001
3,291
2
81
I'm with you. My first car was American made and it didn't last far into 100k. My Honda is at 140k and runs very well like the day I bought it. They are put together in a way that makes working on them easier too. I couldn't get over how much thought went into things when I decided to rip apart the dash to install a car computer. It all just made sense.
 

Chunkee

Lifer
Jul 28, 2002
10,391
1
81
our 2000 grand caravan was at 130k and was still going strong when we traded it for a new 2006 kia sedona...which we really like...we bought 2 of them


jc
 

RU482

Lifer
Apr 9, 2000
12,689
3
81
Originally posted by: rudder
Never had that problem at an Honda dealer I have visited.


Ever been to Penske Honda on 96th in Indianapolis?
Talk about a bunch of cocks
 

Black88GTA

Diamond Member
Sep 9, 2003
3,430
0
0
Originally posted by: rudder
Originally posted by: iamwiz82
Originally posted by: jhayx7
Originally posted by: iamwiz82
Spark plugs are regular maintenance items. They are $2/each at the auto parts store. You take your Honda in for it's regular maintenace, why not the van?

So she takes it to the shop and reports back that we have bad spark plugs and a ripped hose (cant remember what she said exactly)... cha-ching $450.

Re-read the post. Spark Plugs + hose should not have been over $150.

I think he was pointing out how bad they stuck it in his prison wallet without any hello jelly.

I did re-read it. I also read where he doesn't even know what was done. I cannot think of many hoses that have 6-8 hours of labor involved in replacing them.

Nothing was done... it was just a quote. My point is the dodge sucks, i think its the fuel injectors and the dealer is probably trying to scam my wife.

Edited to add another point: I used to not mind doing my own maintainence... but now I am busier and have more money, I pay someone else. I am just amazed about the lack of quality in this dodge mini van. Its babied by the wife, regular scheduled maintainence items are taken care of... yet I was quoted $450 to repair something in a car that has 54K miles versus my awesome running civic.

You may be a mechanic.. super for you... you may like Dodge cars... double good for you. My next car will be a honda or toyota.

A girl I work with has an '05 Corolla with probably about 15k miles on it. Last week, the car died in the middle of the road at an intersection. Turns out the ECU is fried. Good thing she still has her warranty. My boss was not so lucky, however. The ECU also went out a while back on his 2000 (I think) Accord with ~70k on it. $1200 for the repair on that, since it was out of warranty.

Based on my own experience, I own an 89 Prelude (which I actually really like) with about 122k miles on it and it is completely falling apart. Water leaks everywhere, a bad steering rack, bad alternator, both axles shot, transmission slipping badly, horrible motor surge, etc. I've taken care of lots of this, but the point is - Honda and Toyota are not the magic-mobiles that everyone makes them out to be. Look at Toyota's recent rash of recalls for proof.
 

holden j caufield

Diamond Member
Dec 30, 1999
6,324
10
81
Originally posted by: nakedfrog
Huh. My 2004 Sebring is over 66k miles and it's doing just fine. My friend drove his 99 Stratus until it had 100k miles, then traded it in on a Chrysler Minivan so he could haul large items around.

sorry but this doesn't prove much. Any car should go 66k miles without major probs and 100k isn't a stretch nowadays without probs
 

pradeep1

Golden Member
Jun 4, 2005
1,099
1
81
Yeah, we are a Toyota family. We have yet to give up on a car because it was dead. Mostly they've just gotten old and we've donated them to Easter Seals or Goodwill, or someone in need.

My jalopy 95 Camry has close to 200,000 miles on it, and it starts without hesitation, runs like a charm, gives good gas mileage, and even the AC works strong. She burns about a quart of oil every 3-4 months, but that's it.

I remember my friends who bought American cars back in the day (90s) who used to think that a car with mileage over 75K was "high mileage". Heck, I bought that 95 Camry in 98 with almost 57K miles on it, and my friends almost sh*t in their pants when I told them that. They thought I was foolish to put "so much money in an old car". That car has outlived all of their cars combined it seems.

 

huberm

Golden Member
Dec 17, 2004
1,105
1
0
i used to have a 99 dodge dakota with 70k miles on it that left me stranded 12 times in 13 months (no, this is not an exagerration). I had the dakota to replace my dodge avenger that blew an engine at 90k miles. And yes I do all the maintenance.

Needless to say, I now own a Toyota Tundra and have never been as happy with a vehicle. This is the first vehicle I have owned that I don't even have a single complaint or annoyance. After I bought it, the Toyota dealer even sent me cookies in the mail! Now thats service!
 

desy

Diamond Member
Jan 13, 2000
5,446
214
106
NA cars of the 90's mostly suck no denying that. I had an awsome reliable 94 Corsica though that had over 200K miles on it when I sold it minor repairs needed. Then it needed a steering rack so I sold it to the mechanic and he's now driving it everyday. Gotta love that anecdotal evidence

Its just been the very last few years NA cars are approaching Jap quality and by jap I mean Honda and Toyota cause all the rest are about the same as NA cars. They are better than European cars.

I'm much more inclined to buy a car I like than worry about reliablity nowadays because they are all mostly reliable and quality has boiled down to niggly things as apposed to major problems
 

Squisher

Lifer
Aug 17, 2000
21,204
66
91
Originally posted by: JulesMaximus
Originally posted by: Ktulu
Originally posted by: rudder
Originally posted by: Ktulu
Originally posted by: rudder
Originally posted by: iamwiz82
Originally posted by: jhayx7
Originally posted by: iamwiz82
Spark plugs are regular maintenance items. They are $2/each at the auto parts store. You take your Honda in for it's regular maintenace, why not the van?

So she takes it to the shop and reports back that we have bad spark plugs and a ripped hose (cant remember what she said exactly)... cha-ching $450.

Re-read the post. Spark Plugs + hose should not have been over $150.

I think he was pointing out how bad they stuck it in his prison wallet without any hello jelly.

I did re-read it. I also read where he doesn't even know what was done. I cannot think of many hoses that have 6-8 hours of labor involved in replacing them.

Nothing was done... it was just a quote. My point is the dodge sucks, i think its the fuel injectors and the dealer is probably trying to scam my wife.

Dodge sucks or the dealer sucks?

both suck.. the van is crap and the dealership is an ass to deal with. Never had that problem at an Honda dealer I have visited.

Well I doubt Honda or Toyota are immune from shady dealerships or bad products.

I've never had any trouble with the Toyota dealership when I had a Toyota or the Nissan service department for my Maxima and Lexus will freaking bend over backward to make sure you're happy. I've never experienced anything near the level of Lexus service from any American car dealership. I have a friend who had a brand new C6 Corvette and he had horrible experiences at the dealership. This is a guy who paid over $45k for a brand new Vette.

My wife's Lexus IS250 had a small tear develop in the driver's seat after about 10k miles. It was about an inch long and the dealer replaced the entire seat (not just the seating surface, the entire seat) with a brand new one under warranty...no questions asked. I wonder what a power driver's seat for an IS250 costs if you had to replace it yourself.

They also detailed the car for her and gave her a free loaner car while they had her car.

Toyota is at the bottom of the list in Customer Service Satisfaction.

Try again.

Text
 

JulesMaximus

No Lifer
Jul 3, 2003
74,544
924
126
Originally posted by: dartworth
Originally posted by: JulesMaximus


My wife's Lexus IS250 had a small tear develop in the driver's seat after about 10k miles. It was about an inch long and the dealer replaced the entire seat (not just the seating surface, the entire seat) with a brand new one under warranty...no questions asked. I wonder what a power driver's seat for an IS250 costs if you had to replace it yourself.

They also detailed the car for her and gave her a free loaner car while they had her car.


so your wife is a fatass...big deal...

My wife is 5'4" and weighs 125lbs jackass.