Originally posted by: Zenoth
Now with all that said, I'm also considering the following titles from your suggestions guys:
Star Wars: Jedi Knight -Jedi Academy- (is it better than Jedi Outcast?)
Star Wars: Republic Commando (is it only squad-based like... say... S.W.A.T?)
The Settlers: Rise of an Empire (ah yes, another "Empire" game, is it similar to AoE or RoN? Or maybe Civilizations?)
Age of Mythology (yet another RTS I completely missed, it seems very similar to Age of Empires, and perhaps done by the same developer?)
Civilizations 4: Beyond the Sword (Ok, the last Civilization game I've played was so long ago that I don't remember which one in the series it was, so I would like to ask, is Civ 4 turned-based like the Total War series and then you go and fight in a 3D environment? Or is it more like Sim City with more military mechanics and such?)
Thanks again guys.
I'm glad you liked thrones and patriots! It is a kickass game. Have you tried the cold war mode yet (defcon 1 FTW)? It was my favorite (next to the French revolution)
I'm not sure what to do about your Homeworld 2 problems... that is very abnormal. Now, as for the games you haven't tried yet...
Jedia Academy is the "sequel" to Jedi Outcast. You don't play Kyle Katarn anymore, you play some new Jedi. However, I did enjoy the gameplay more. It felt pretty similar to Jedi Outcast but the lightsaber combat was improved and expanded.
Republic Command is squad-based, but I never played SWAT, so I can't give you a comparison. The characters are personable, the combat is fantastic, the storyline is great, and overall it is a great squad-based shooter and one of the best Star Wars based games. Each character is supposed to have a specialty (demolitions, hacking, etc.) but I don't think these designations matter - for example, I don't think the demolitions expert necessarily applies demo charges more quickly or more effectively than any other squad member...
Not making a sequel to Republic Commando is a crime against humanity. It is really good and deserves development time much more than some of Lucasart's other projects.
The Settlers - I haven't played it
Age of Mythology - It is very similar to Age of Empires. According to wikipedia, it was a spinoff game from the Age of Empires franchise, in fact. There are tons of similarities. Of course, Age of Empires didn't have heroes with mystical powers or mythological creatures. I enjoyed building hydras - as they killed enemies, they would grow more heads and become more powerful

If I remember correctly, there are 3 major "sides" being the Norse, the Egyptians, and the Greeks. Apparently there was a highly-rated expansion that I hadn't heard of... hmm
Civ 4 Beyond the sword - It is completely turn-based. There is no fighting in a 3D environment like in Total War. You build civilizations, you wage war, but you never play it like an RTS. It's a great time if you enjoy these games. It's not as good as Alpha Centauri, but that bar is set so high that we may as well not use that game as a comparison. I swear, if Sid Meier would only release a slightly updated version of Alpha Centauri (graphical improvements + maybe a few gameplay improvements, but not many), we'd see a seriously fantastic game on our hands. Beyond the Sword is nice because it includes a lot of 3rd party content, extra races, etc. I always find myself getting bored near the modern era, since the game has essentially come down to a war game (rather than expanding + empire building). Piuc2020 pretty much sums up how I feel about Civ 4 (and the soundtrack is neato)
Piuc2020 also recommended C&C3, a game that I think is missing on my list. It was great, too. I liked it much better than Generals. It's cheesy at times, but I thought the storyline was good. And there's going to be an expansion with a global conquest mode!