First of all, who is neckbeard? Many of you refer to him as the prodigy of all trolls.
I started this thread in hope that it would work like a court of law. I provide my argument, and in rebuttal, you provide yours (if you disagree). Many followed this code of conduct, and I thank you for your arguments. While I may not agree with some, I'm grateful that you stated your position and provided concrete examples. Calling me stupid, a troll, immature, narrow-minded is very childlike. Calling me narrow-minded and explaining your position on the issue, however, is respectful and worthy.
So far I gather this much from my thread. Those who are in the military or at some point have been in it, have family in it, or friends enlisted, seem to disagree with me. You brought up many valid points, thanks for widening my perspective.
Many agree with me. This just shows to tell that my way of thinking is not limited to my family and my upbringing. This means that there has to be at least some truth in my very crude generalizations and stereotypes.
@Angry Irishman: This feels like a personality test. I love them!
How old are you? It's pretty clear that my age is below 30 from my mediocre writing skills.
Have you ever considered doing something for your country or fellow citizens?
In other words, volunteering? I have done it for two groups: the disabled and the elderly. They actually need the help.
Or is that out of line or unnecessary in society?
I'm undecided on that. On one hand, I see that many cultural groups and underprivileged citizens need the help. On the other, the more help you get the lazier you get. In fact, a close friend of mine was laid off roughly 3 years ago. He was VERY hard working. After getting his unemployment for 2 years he got lazy and stopped looking for a job. I guess helping IS necessary, but in a different way than it is currently done. Give the citizen a fishing rod, not a fish.
What do you do for a living?
Student. I have a full time job during the summer.
Where are you a citizen?
The United States.
Do you think being a soldier or in the military doesn't entail war (killing?) regardless of intellect or rank?
I have no problem with killing, especially if you are a soldier. It needs to have a purpose that is universally accepted, however (WWII). We can all agree (even some Nazi's) that intervention in Europe was desperately needed.
Do you understand the roles of the military?
Depends on the military. The one in the U.S has many roles. Protecting its citizens is one. But I am not the only one who feels like we are overreaching a bit.
Do you think a soldier is not a citizen?
Of course a soldier is a citizen. A serial killer is also a citizen and should be given a fair trial regardless of his atrocities.
Should we or any other country not have a military? Why?
In a Utopian world, maybe. But humans are genetically predisposed to fight.
How do you feel about minorities?
Depends on the minority. If they work hard for a good life for their family and themselves, that is amazing. My parents came to the U.S from Europe (not gonna say which country, but it isn't third world) and worked their fingers off.
And finally....Do you consider yourself educated?If so, please elaborate.
Trick question? I don't really know. It depends on the topic. I know NOTHING about cars (see my post about selling my car) but I know a lot about psychology and sociology (had a teacher who wrote many books about the subject and is actually somewhat famous). I scored a 2300 on my SAT, but its been proven to be a bit biased.
I started this thread in hope that it would work like a court of law. I provide my argument, and in rebuttal, you provide yours (if you disagree). Many followed this code of conduct, and I thank you for your arguments. While I may not agree with some, I'm grateful that you stated your position and provided concrete examples. Calling me stupid, a troll, immature, narrow-minded is very childlike. Calling me narrow-minded and explaining your position on the issue, however, is respectful and worthy.
So far I gather this much from my thread. Those who are in the military or at some point have been in it, have family in it, or friends enlisted, seem to disagree with me. You brought up many valid points, thanks for widening my perspective.
Many agree with me. This just shows to tell that my way of thinking is not limited to my family and my upbringing. This means that there has to be at least some truth in my very crude generalizations and stereotypes.
@Angry Irishman: This feels like a personality test. I love them!
How old are you? It's pretty clear that my age is below 30 from my mediocre writing skills.
Have you ever considered doing something for your country or fellow citizens?
In other words, volunteering? I have done it for two groups: the disabled and the elderly. They actually need the help.
Or is that out of line or unnecessary in society?
I'm undecided on that. On one hand, I see that many cultural groups and underprivileged citizens need the help. On the other, the more help you get the lazier you get. In fact, a close friend of mine was laid off roughly 3 years ago. He was VERY hard working. After getting his unemployment for 2 years he got lazy and stopped looking for a job. I guess helping IS necessary, but in a different way than it is currently done. Give the citizen a fishing rod, not a fish.
What do you do for a living?
Student. I have a full time job during the summer.
Where are you a citizen?
The United States.
Do you think being a soldier or in the military doesn't entail war (killing?) regardless of intellect or rank?
I have no problem with killing, especially if you are a soldier. It needs to have a purpose that is universally accepted, however (WWII). We can all agree (even some Nazi's) that intervention in Europe was desperately needed.
Do you understand the roles of the military?
Depends on the military. The one in the U.S has many roles. Protecting its citizens is one. But I am not the only one who feels like we are overreaching a bit.
Do you think a soldier is not a citizen?
Of course a soldier is a citizen. A serial killer is also a citizen and should be given a fair trial regardless of his atrocities.
Should we or any other country not have a military? Why?
In a Utopian world, maybe. But humans are genetically predisposed to fight.
How do you feel about minorities?
Depends on the minority. If they work hard for a good life for their family and themselves, that is amazing. My parents came to the U.S from Europe (not gonna say which country, but it isn't third world) and worked their fingers off.
And finally....Do you consider yourself educated?If so, please elaborate.
Trick question? I don't really know. It depends on the topic. I know NOTHING about cars (see my post about selling my car) but I know a lot about psychology and sociology (had a teacher who wrote many books about the subject and is actually somewhat famous). I scored a 2300 on my SAT, but its been proven to be a bit biased.
Facebook
Twitter