HR 1 urgently needs to pass through filibuster

Page 13 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

fskimospy

Elite Member
Mar 10, 2006
88,225
55,768
136
The best republican response to this is that they'll do really unpopular things the country will hate them for should it be eliminated.

Also that it wasn't used heavily by incredible racists to preserve deeply unfair and harmful policies (very much it was).
I mean the Rs aren't going to win veto proof majorities lol.

The reverse argument is what if the Ds retained congress by passing enormously popular bills, smashing partisan gerrymandering, and adding a state all as a result of nuking the filibuster?
Also as previously mentioned when people warn of republicans repealing the ACA and such, they couldn’t even get 50 votes for that. The filibuster didn’t save shit.
 

kage69

Lifer
Jul 17, 2003
31,706
48,494
136
Maybe the best way to phrase this is removing the FB can get bills passed the people want. These just happen to be the policies of Democrats.

Exactly.

I expect they'll still have difficulty with that though. We're dealing with people who feel they are entitled to cheat in elections, not to mention supporting insurrection and sedition. These people still think they are some kind of silent majority, even after Traitor Trump lost the popular by almost 8 million. Even when Senate Dems represent 41 million more Americans than Senate Rs.
 

HomerJS

Lifer
Feb 6, 2002
39,802
33,421
136
Exactly.

I expect they'll still have difficulty with that though. We're dealing with people who feel they are entitled to cheat in elections, not to mention supporting insurrection and sedition. These people still think they are some kind of silent majority, even after Traitor Trump lost the popular by almost 8 million. Even when Senate Dems represent 41 million more Americans than Senate Rs.
Fuck them. Mitch already showed up the way when he stole Obama's SC pick for almost a year and pushed through ACB in 2 weeks.

Do it because we can!
 

IronWing

No Lifer
Jul 20, 2001
73,486
35,163
136
There is a reason why no one wants to remove the filibuster. In the current distribution of the senate, removing filibuster would benefit the Democrats. Just what if the Republicans win the senate in 2022? Without the filibuster the Democrats would be at a total loss.
Mitch cheerfully ditched the filibuster when it was convenient to his donors’ agenda.
 

trenchfoot

Lifer
Aug 5, 2000
16,053
8,649
136
Fuck them. Mitch already showed up the way when he stole Obama's SC pick for almost a year and pushed through ACB in 2 weeks.

Do it because we can!

The problem we have here is the Repubs demand and expect the rest of us to do as they say and not as they do. It's OK for them to cheat, lie, suppress and do whatever else it takes to "Win at All Costs" but hell hath no fury greater than the Repub's angst over having the same being done to them in return. To them that's just not how the game is supposed to be played.
 

woolfe9998

Lifer
Apr 8, 2013
16,242
14,244
136
Exactly.

I expect they'll still have difficulty with that though. We're dealing with people who feel they are entitled to cheat in elections, not to mention supporting insurrection and sedition. These people still think they are some kind of silent majority, even after Traitor Trump lost the popular by almost 8 million. Even when Senate Dems represent 41 million more Americans than Senate Rs.

Your argument here assumes that core Trump supporters are the objects of persuasion. They are not. The people who need convincing are the swing voters. Such as the Hispanic voters who went from Clinton->Trump or the educated white suburbanites who went Trump->Biden.

There is no point in trying to persuade the GOP base of anything. The dems could give them literally everything they want wrapped in a bow and they'd complain about the color of the bow.
 

fskimospy

Elite Member
Mar 10, 2006
88,225
55,768
136
Your argument here assumes that core Trump supporters are the objects of persuasion. They are not. The people who need convincing are the swing voters. Such as the Hispanic voters who went from Clinton->Trump or the educated white suburbanites who went Trump->Biden.

There is no point in trying to persuade the GOP base of anything. The dems could give them literally everything they want wrapped in a bow and they'd complain about the color of the bow.
I feel like America is eventually going to have a very ugly reckoning with these individuals. I expect before it's all over they are going to make a very serious attempt at overthrowing our democracy. No idea if it will succeed or not, but they are going to try.
 

K1052

Elite Member
Aug 21, 2003
53,628
48,196
136
Joe Manchin is releasing an op ed about his ideas on voting rights legislation

1) Manchin will probably generally support the legislation, with some changes (it does need a few). He will stress bipartisan cooperation.
2) Some changes will be made and he'll have outstretched his olive branch to Rs.
3) Rs will shit all over him and the bill publicly for days and weeks for his trouble.
4) Bipartisan outreach having been concluded he will consent to weakening the filibuster.

Personally I'd like to see the HR1 components refined and broken up in to distinct bills and made as bullet proof as possible from legal challenge. Partisan gerrymandering and voting access should top the list since those are the most popular items.
 

Amol S.

Platinum Member
Mar 14, 2015
2,587
783
136
The only way to get Hispanic voters back is to explain the difference between socialism and Democrats to them. That was the main reason why Florida ended up going to Trump. He told the Hispanics in Florida that the Democrats are "Socialists", who are trying to convert the U.S. into U.S.S.R. (United States Socialist Republic).

The problem is, how are the Democrats going to explain to the Hispanics that Democrats are not Socialists.
 

fskimospy

Elite Member
Mar 10, 2006
88,225
55,768
136
The only way to get Hispanic voters back is to explain the difference between socialism and Democrats to them. That was the main reason why Florida ended up going to Trump. He told the Hispanics in Florida that the Democrats are "Socialists", who are trying to convert the U.S. into U.S.S.R. (United States Socialist Republic).

The problem is, how are the Democrats going to explain to the Hispanics that Democrats are not Socialists.
Hispanics are not a cohesive voting group and don't share a common ancestry. Lots of Hispanic voters want way more socialism and would be delighted to hear that Democrats are socialists.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ewdotson

thilanliyan

Lifer
Jun 21, 2005
12,080
2,280
126
He told the Hispanics in Florida that the Democrats are "Socialists", who are trying to convert the U.S. into U.S.S.R. (United States Socialist Republic).
I'm really not sure how they fell for that. The US will NEVER become like the USSR, private entities have way too much power.
 

K1052

Elite Member
Aug 21, 2003
53,628
48,196
136
I'm really not sure how they fell for that. The US will NEVER become like the USSR, private entities have way too much power.

Tell FL Cuban and Venezuelan voters that Biden is basically Casto or Chavez: votes in the bag. Also Trump's harsh anti-Mexican and Central American immigration policies were favored by those groups who see themselves as rightful recipients of policy favor instead of lucky by historical quirks. They'd probably vote to shoot all the Mexicans in the country if they could.
 

kage69

Lifer
Jul 17, 2003
31,706
48,494
136
Your argument here assumes that core Trump supporters are the objects of persuasion.

You misunderstand, and it's probably my fault. While in agreement with Homer, I was directing that at a poster I am unfamiliar with and was referencing trumpets as a 3rd party. I don't know that he/she is a trumpet. Could be just a swing voter who doesn't go out of their way to get informed and who has more tolerance for corruption and treason than we do.

Persuasion? Trump supporters are objects of prostitution, they sold out their country, morals and dignity to get behind a pornstar banging traitor and conman. My view on the Trump base is unchanged: thankfully not big enough to win elections, and they should also fuck off to Russia since they hate democracy.
 

trenchfoot

Lifer
Aug 5, 2000
16,053
8,649
136
Problem here is that many Repubs have convinced themselves that they and only they are the "Real Americans, the genuine article, the true patriots and protectors of all that is holy" and everyone else must be illegal immigrants, commies, satan worshippers or enemies conspiring to overthrow the America as they see it as.

The one thing that needs to be kept in mind is that Trump, being who he has proven to be over those four horrific years of his term has a following of 70+ millions of whom have not only completely ignored those glaring personality disorders of his and the disastrous results those disorders brought upon the nation, they've also had to fabricate excuses for Trump's nefarious behavior as well as conjure up unbelievable conspiracies against Biden and the Dems so as to justify their putting party over country.

For lack of legislating anything meaningful for the masses, the party has had to resort to committing dirty deeds done dirt cheap with the full approval of their rank and file members. IOW, their working class members have chosen to sacrifice themselves at the alter of the wealthy in order to remain faithful to a party that exploits them for everything they've got.

That's one hell of a scam their leadership have managed to pull over on them.
 

Jhhnn

IN MEMORIAM
Nov 11, 1999
62,365
14,686
136
Tell FL Cuban and Venezuelan voters that Biden is basically Casto or Chavez: votes in the bag. Also Trump's harsh anti-Mexican and Central American immigration policies were favored by those groups who see themselves as rightful recipients of policy favor instead of lucky by historical quirks. They'd probably vote to shoot all the Mexicans in the country if they could.

So what? Cuban and Venezuelan Americans aren't much of a political force outside a very few areas simply because their numbers are actually quite small compared to the overall population. There are 24M people in Florida and less than 2M are of Cuban descent.


Venezuelan Americans are even more scarce. Mexican Americans are by far the largest group of Hispanics in the US-

 

hal2kilo

Lifer
Feb 24, 2009
26,447
12,575
136
Hispanics are not a cohesive voting group and don't share a common ancestry. Lots of Hispanic voters want way more socialism and would be delighted to hear that Democrats are socialists.
It's mostly Florida's special immigrant class.
 

MrSquished

Lifer
Jan 14, 2013
26,329
24,572
136

Republicans in the Missouri legislature don't think the people who voted to expand Medicare count so they're just not going to do it.

This is what's coming down the road at us in the next couple election cycles.

This, voting suppression, trying to overthrow an election. If your friends don't know it yet, let them know, the GOP and all who support it are evil or complicit in evil.
 

woolfe9998

Lifer
Apr 8, 2013
16,242
14,244
136
Yep, another reason HR1 must pass. The repugs will likely hold off the tipping point in several states for at least a decade if allowed to continue with these voter suppression bills and gerrymandering.

 
  • Like
Reactions: ch33zw1z