How NOT to open a box

Page 3 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.
Mar 11, 2004
23,444
5,852
146
My Sennheiser MM 550-X & Klipsch Image One's would like to have a word with you...

They're acceptable for what they are but you're just plain delusional if you don't think they're still flawed inherently due to the Bluetooth. Just like noise cancelling and other wireless there's tradeoffs.

And er, I thought your Beats were so amazing?
 

alkemyst

No Lifer
Feb 13, 2001
83,769
19
81
They're acceptable for what they are but you're just plain delusional if you don't think they're still flawed inherently due to the Bluetooth. Just like noise cancelling and other wireless there's tradeoffs.

And er, I thought your Beats were so amazing?

He not only has all the headphones, he serves margaritas to his WHOLE BLOCK weekly.

Don't get his posts, but I don't get yours usually either.
 

Markbnj

Elite Member <br>Moderator Emeritus
Moderator
Sep 16, 2005
15,682
14
81
www.markbetz.net
Cords FTW!

I hate cordless mice. Keyboards too. I value reliability over not having cords to deal with.

Corded mouse, and corded keyboard. Tried wireless once, got sick of forgetting to put the mouse back in its little charger at night, and having it run out of juice halfway through the day. Got sick of having to go through the little connection ritual every few days. Not worth it.
 

QueBert

Lifer
Jan 6, 2002
22,993
1,185
126
They're acceptable for what they are but you're just plain delusional if you don't think they're still flawed inherently due to the Bluetooth. Just like noise cancelling and other wireless there's tradeoffs.

And er, I thought your Beats were so amazing?

They are amazing, but people on here are so blinded by their hate for everything Beats. So I thought I'd bring up a couple "respected" audio names. Bluetooth + an apt-X source you won't be able to tell tell the difference between wired and wireless. Both my Senn's & Klipsch support it and I'd say especially the Senn's sound reasonably close to my Grado SR 225i's, which are the best sounding pair I have. They sound so good they replaced my Audio Technica ATH-M50's for my go to cans. I have a closet full of headphones, I guess I'm somewhat of a collector. I honestly can't remember the last time I used a wired pair. My Beats win out because they easily have the best blend of comfort and SQ.

Bluetooth & A2DP use to blow monkey balls, but the technology has come along way. IMHO apt-X is the future of wireless audio.The downside is to get the level of SQ that's on par with wired isn't cheap. My Senn's cost as much as my 3 favorite wired pairs combined. So there's definitely a big trade-off.
 
Last edited:

Imp

Lifer
Feb 8, 2000
18,828
184
106
Corded mouse, and corded keyboard. Tried wireless once, got sick of forgetting to put the mouse back in its little charger at night, and having it run out of juice halfway through the day. Got sick of having to go through the little connection ritual every few days. Not worth it.

When I got my Logitech G5 on clearance years ago, I could have gotten a G3 (?) wireless for $10 more. It came down to not wanting to deal with the battery.

Nowadays that I'm more paranoid, I'm glad I don't have a wireless mouse pumping my death-gripped right hand full of RF 8 hours a day...
 

Lifted

Diamond Member
Nov 30, 2004
5,748
2
0
Corded mouse, and corded keyboard. Tried wireless once, got sick of forgetting to put the mouse back in its little charger at night, and having it run out of juice halfway through the day. Got sick of having to go through the little connection ritual every few days. Not worth it.

The joys of rechargeable batteries.

Using cordless mice and keyboards at home and work and I change the alkaline batteries once per year at most.

Those NiMH rechargeables don't seem so "green" if they have to be charged 100x to get the same use as an alkaline. You're spending more on the battery to start with, then more on electricity to charge it (granted it's very little juice), then you get the pleasure of having to constantly charge it or you can't use your computer.
 

HeXen

Diamond Member
Dec 13, 2009
7,838
39
91
They're acceptable for what they are but you're just plain delusional if you don't think they're still flawed inherently due to the Bluetooth. Just like noise cancelling and other wireless there's tradeoffs.

And er, I thought your Beats were so amazing?

Hey I have a pair of Beats. It's true however that people love to knock on popular trends and it's obvious to point out the people that actually never really owned or experienced whatever it is they are ragging on. Beats in particular are expensive compared to some but many of those others don't use silver cladded OFC shielded cable, all metal housings and glossy paint either. Everything has trade offs but they do sound equal quality in comparison to my Ultrasones in that it produces all the frequencies and achieves the full harmonics in recording but warmer which is my personal preference for sound. It's like boring vs exciting.

Most important thing to remember about audio is that everyone listens differently. What frequencies and even specific instruments and ranges they notice vs what they don't notice or physically can't hear are the roots that divide everyone's opinion on what sounds good. Most people can't even listen enough to what someone is saying to repeat it word for word much less listen to music completely.
 
Last edited:

Imp

Lifer
Feb 8, 2000
18,828
184
106
Jackass... Now I'm tempted to get a set of Dre over-ears. I am way too damn old to be seen sporting a set though.
 

rh71

No Lifer
Aug 28, 2001
52,844
1,049
126
The joys of rechargeable batteries.

Using cordless mice and keyboards at home and work and I change the alkaline batteries once per year at most.

won't last a whole year if you play games with your keyboard/mouse, especially those that require constant keypress to move.
 

Red Squirrel

No Lifer
May 24, 2003
70,718
13,850
126
www.anyf.ca
Corded mouse, and corded keyboard. Tried wireless once, got sick of forgetting to put the mouse back in its little charger at night, and having it run out of juice halfway through the day. Got sick of having to go through the little connection ritual every few days. Not worth it.

I hate how everything is going wireless now. Very hard to find a wired mouse or keyboard these days, and it seems they don't make good ones either. Like that kit in the video is about as good as you'll find. So if you want a fancy gaming keyboard or mouse they only make wireless. I like my MS ergo keyboard but it's getting to a point where I should replace it (very dirty and faded) but I really don't want to go wireless.

What wireless is good for is something like a HTPC. But for a desk, what's the point? You still have to plug a receiver into the USB so you have a wire anyway. it's not magical, it needs something to communicate with.
 

Childs

Lifer
Jul 9, 2000
11,313
7
81
I never felt so sorry for a box in my life. I was relieved when he finally put the box out of it's misery.
 

alkemyst

No Lifer
Feb 13, 2001
83,769
19
81
I hate how everything is going wireless now. Very hard to find a wired mouse or keyboard these days, and it seems they don't make good ones either. Like that kit in the video is about as good as you'll find. So if you want a fancy gaming keyboard or mouse they only make wireless. I like my MS ergo keyboard but it's getting to a point where I should replace it (very dirty and faded) but I really don't want to go wireless.

What wireless is good for is something like a HTPC. But for a desk, what's the point? You still have to plug a receiver into the USB so you have a wire anyway. it's not magical, it needs something to communicate with.

you are buying cheap. There are nice ergo keyboards out there. The MS wasn't that great.
 

Ichinisan

Lifer
Oct 9, 2002
28,298
1,235
136
Bluetooth audio sucks ass in general, so that coupled with a brand known for overpriced style over substance products, hmm now why would someone guess that trend isn't likely to change?

What sucks about Bluetooth A2DP from a digital source? Bit rate?
 

Ichinisan

Lifer
Oct 9, 2002
28,298
1,235
136
Guys, it's just a cardboard box. Of all the things in the world to judge, we're judging how some Spanish kid opens a box, I sunk a new low by the fact I even had to point this out.

Some people in this thread don't seem to realize how much fail is in the video. I think you might have opened it the same way :awe:

For the record, you're supposed to cut a single sticker and the top flips open. That's how it is with almost every single keyboard.
 
Mar 11, 2004
23,444
5,852
146
They are amazing, but people on here are so blinded by their hate for everything Beats. So I thought I'd bring up a couple "respected" audio names. Bluetooth + an apt-X source you won't be able to tell tell the difference between wired and wireless. Both my Senn's & Klipsch support it and I'd say especially the Senn's sound reasonably close to my Grado SR 225i's, which are the best sounding pair I have. They sound so good they replaced my Audio Technica ATH-M50's for my go to cans. I have a closet full of headphones, I guess I'm somewhat of a collector. I honestly can't remember the last time I used a wired pair. My Beats win out because they easily have the best blend of comfort and SQ.

Bluetooth & A2DP use to blow monkey balls, but the technology has come along way. IMHO apt-X is the future of wireless audio.The downside is to get the level of SQ that's on par with wired isn't cheap. My Senn's cost as much as my 3 favorite wired pairs combined. So there's definitely a big trade-off.

I wouldn't say blinded makes any sense. They built a reputation, not for quality sound, but for essentially jewelry. I haven't seen any thorough tests for the bluetooth Beats, so I'll remain skeptical until I see otherwise.

I'd have figured you for a basshead so I'm pretty surprised that you really go for Grado sound. I have a hunch it might be the open baffle that is what you're liking, as all the other headphones you've mentioned are closed.

It has come a long way, but that's because it was just awful before. Like I said, its fine if they work well for you but there's absolutely some limitations. Its possible plenty of people would be ok with though. But plenty of people are ok with ibuds too.

Hey I have a pair of Beats. It's true however that people love to knock on popular trends and it's obvious to point out the people that actually never really owned or experienced whatever it is they are ragging on. Beats in particular are expensive compared to some but many of those others don't use silver cladded OFC shielded cable, all metal housings and glossy paint either. Everything has trade offs but they do sound equal quality in comparison to my Ultrasones in that it produces all the frequencies and achieves the full harmonics in recording but warmer which is my personal preference for sound. It's like boring vs exciting.

Most important thing to remember about audio is that everyone listens differently. What frequencies and even specific instruments and ranges they notice vs what they don't notice or physically can't hear are the roots that divide everyone's opinion on what sounds good. Most people can't even listen enough to what someone is saying to repeat it word for word much less listen to music completely.

My condolences.

Actually Beats aren't that expensive (there are a lot of headphones in the $300+ range), the problem is they're ~$100 in quality (if that really) that are sold for much more because of some glossy paint and them catering to people that don't know headphones.

Yeah, too bad they might have put all that in and then skimped on a poor housing and driver which is by far the thing that you most need to get right when it comes to headphones. You basically just described why Beats are such a joke, its flash and style over substance.

Ultrasones aren't exactly considered great either. They have their own gimmick. They're really hit and miss.

Sorry that's immaterial, as we can measure how they sound. That's no guarantee that it will still sound good but there's a very strong correlation, especially when you know what measurements tend to be exhibited by good sounding headphones.

What sucks about Bluetooth A2DP from a digital source? Bit rate?

There's several. Namely, bluetooth will be wireless, so it'll suffer from the same problems other wireless headphones have (it'll have to have an amp and DAC within the headphone, deal with battery issues, wireless problems such as transmission distance, etc). Then couple that with syncing issues (I don't have a need to bother with bluetooth but I see a lot of complaints about bluetooth audio syncing problems, especially in portable setups). And yeah bitrate, although that's apparently changing and I don't think it would be that big of an issue. Maybe latency but I don't know.
 

Markbnj

Elite Member <br>Moderator Emeritus
Moderator
Sep 16, 2005
15,682
14
81
www.markbetz.net
I hate how everything is going wireless now. Very hard to find a wired mouse or keyboard these days, and it seems they don't make good ones either. Like that kit in the video is about as good as you'll find. So if you want a fancy gaming keyboard or mouse they only make wireless. I like my MS ergo keyboard but it's getting to a point where I should replace it (very dirty and faded) but I really don't want to go wireless.

What wireless is good for is something like a HTPC. But for a desk, what's the point? You still have to plug a receiver into the USB so you have a wire anyway. it's not magical, it needs something to communicate with.

Agreed, but there are some decent wired keyboards. Logitech makes a few including some gaming models.
 

CZroe

Lifer
Jun 24, 2001
24,195
857
126
There's several. Namely, bluetooth will be wireless, so it'll suffer from the same problems other wireless headphones have (it'll have to have an amp and DAC within the headphone, deal with battery issues, wireless problems such as transmission distance, etc). Then couple that with syncing issues (I don't have a need to bother with bluetooth but I see a lot of complaints about bluetooth audio syncing problems, especially in portable setups). And yeah bitrate, although that's apparently changing and I don't think it would be that big of an issue. Maybe latency but I don't know.

You obviously don't know much about A2DP - Advanced Audio Distribution Profile (AKA "Stereo Bluetooth Audio"). First of all, not all A2DP-receiving devices are "headphones." Having an amp and DAC in the receiver is no different than having one in your MP3 player. Part of the A2DP spec is that it can optionally stream the raw MP3 bitstream for decoding on the receiving device so there is ZERO quality degradation and there is actually the potential for a quality IMPROVEMENT. IOW, the Beats Pill may actually be better than some high-end headphones plugged into a particular digital audio player (even if the $20 A2DP speaker from Big Lots isn't).

Next, battery issues are NOT a problem with HT audio, car audio, and other devices that don't run on batteries, so it's hardly a reason to say that A2DP "sucks." My Sony BT22 headphones lasted ages and I almost never had them run dead while being used. Heck, even my Jabra BT8010, a normal Bluetooth earpiece, had great battery life when using A2DP. Back when I used a Samsung YH-999 Portable Media Center to watch all my TV I hated that there was no way to power my wired JBL On Tour speakers from the PMC. My battery life was functionally limited to the shortest of the two even without wireless audio. Now, even ignoring that nearly everything can power or charge through USB these days, I can switch streams from one A2DP device to another when I need to. I own a second Parrot SK4000 Bluetooth kit for my motorcycle helmet in case I want to ride all day and need to have one charging under the seat while I use the other (crossed the country with this setup twice).

As for syncing issues: That was solved with the very first A2DP MP3 player ever available at retail in the USA (Insignia-branded player from Best Buy). The engineers even bragged to me on the anythingbutipod or dapreview forums about how proud they were that they were able to get the video synced with the A2DP audio stream. Any other issues are typically sloppy UI issues. When a notification sound plays on an Apple device, Apple's sloppy UI guys don't seem to care that the A2DP stream was closed and the device was in standby (since there was no active audio stream) and that the notification sound played while the stream was being initialized. It needs to be buffered if the stream is being routed elsewhere. If they haven't figured that out yet it's really because they don't care, don't test, or fail at the one thing most people praise them for (UI).

Edit: Just for LULZ:
There's several. Namely, traditional headphones will be wired, so it'll suffer from the same problems other wired headphones have (it'll have limited routing, limited length, fragile connectors, cables prone to snags and shorts, and it'll have to have an amp and DAC that you can't bypass or improve on within the source device, etc).

FTFY.

I HATE having to charge my phone in the car when it's plugged in to charge in my car. One cable is a lot longer than the other and I can never find a place without awkward routing on one or both sides of my manual shifter. It's always in the way and there is no place to put it with both cables sticking out of my phone! Also the fiasco every time someone want to plug their phone into my HT at home is reason enough to use A2DP: Cables that aren't long enough to keep the phone nearby (for control) or cases that don't fit certain audio cables or cables that developed shorts and get tripped on and broken (often damages the device/receiver as well), etc.

Wires are almost always a clusterf**k. It's bad enough that we usually have to use them for charging.
 
Last edited: