Originally posted by: manly
Originally posted by: NewSc2
I thought Randy Johnson deserved a title, but not Bonds. For years he didn't get along with the media, his team, and nobody really liked him, except he could hit homers. He hits 73 in 1 year, and then the media is all over him and glorifying him and everybody loves Bonds now?
Bonds may be the most feared slugger this side of Babe Ruth, but in the end, pitch around him all the time and he can't push the team to victory. I actually don't care how he relates to the media, but he's known to be aloof to teammates and an inspiration to the Randy Moss's of the world.
The funny thing is, nobody knows how it's humanly possible for him to be entering his prime at this stage of his career, but any speculation aside, his now massive frame + lackluster attitude at times in left field make him a B defender at best whereas he was excellent earlier in his career. Arguably, his fielding clumsiness contributed to game 6 and 7 losses. The fact that a very fit athlete as Bonds is too fragile to play day starts after night games is also suspicious.
Frankly, I'd take Willie Mays in his prime over Barry right now no contest (and I'm too young to have seen Mays ever play). I'd also be inclined to take A-Rod right now straight up for playing better defense at a much tougher position.
The best thing you could say about Bonds is that they love him in S.F. and he's a huge draw for the ballclub and even MLB in general (after the media fell in love with him last season).
Personally, I'm an A's fan in SoCal and unless any of the sports teams I root for pulls a Dodgers of the past decade, it's unlikely for me to switch allegiances win or lose.