how does a ps3 compare with a pc?

aceofskies05

Senior member
Jun 13, 2006
630
0
0
i played resitence fall of man and the graphics were running through a composite cable :(, and the shadows, lighting, and rendering looked alot like pc, but just curious how would a ps3 compare with a pc?

ex.
amd XXXXX
gpuXXXX
ect..
 

platinumike

Platinum Member
Nov 18, 2004
2,114
3
0
any video card out in the last 6 months can produce ps3 graphics. Right now the ps3 graphics aint anything to amazing. Theyll get better though
 

Kromis

Diamond Member
Mar 2, 2006
5,214
1
81
According to Ken Kutaragi, he even said himself that "it clearly is a computer". No, I am NOT lying!
 

Fenixgoon

Lifer
Jun 30, 2003
33,050
12,433
136
Originally posted by: aceofskies05
well im just talking graphics i know the ps3 has supercomputer powers.

supercomputer my a$$.... might have the theoretical output, but i doubt it actually crunches anywhere close to what a REAL supercomputer can do.

also, IIRC, most of the calculations per second from consoles include GPU calculations, which is cheating, a bit :p
 

Auryg

Platinum Member
Dec 28, 2003
2,377
0
71
Originally posted by: XJustMeX21
Originally posted by: aceofskies05
well im just talking graphics i know the ps3 has supercomputer powers.

um been buying into the sony hype much?

Haha, yes he has. The ps3 (and 360, for that matter) use processors that are built quite differently than any PC processor. I'm not a hardware guy so I can't get in to the specifics, but they aren't nearly as efficient as our processors.
 

0roo0roo

No Lifer
Sep 21, 2002
64,795
84
91
err its been left behind ..quad core, 8800gtx's... you can quibble about the cpu, but the video cards out for pc now are clearly faster than what the ps3 has.
 

Lonyo

Lifer
Aug 10, 2002
21,938
6
81
Originally posted by: Auryg
Originally posted by: XJustMeX21
Originally posted by: aceofskies05
well im just talking graphics i know the ps3 has supercomputer powers.

um been buying into the sony hype much?

Haha, yes he has. The ps3 (and 360, for that matter) use processors that are built quite differently than any PC processor. I'm not a hardware guy so I can't get in to the specifics, but they aren't nearly as efficient as our processors.

Apparently the PPE has the power of a 1.6GHz G5.
A 1.6GHz G5 is slower than a 1.6GHz Conroe, I believe. So basically the Xbox 360 has 3xG5 1.6GHz, while PC's can now have 2 or 4 2.5GHz Core 2's, which are like 50% faster. The Cell has 1x1.6GHz G5, and a 7 SPE's, which are less powerful at general tasks, and also require more specialised coding.

Basically PC's are easier to make use of, while the Cell processor has theoretical power, it's not always going to be that useful in real world applications, which means it's not really anybetter than current desktop processors, even if it has more theoretical power (although with quad core CPU's, and AMD's 4x4 platform with support for 2xquad core processors that theoretical power advantage will probably be lost).

Graphics wise PC's are better (the 8800 series at least), although it's easier for developers to take advantage of more of the RSX in the PS3, because they can develop specifically for it and its strengths.

Basically, the PS3 is probably on par with PC's at the moment, but PC's are on the verge of being much better. You have to remember that although it will take work to make the most of the Cell, it also takes work to develop for non-standardised PC's, so you can't take full advantage of PC hardware either. PS3 devs make better stuff down the line as they become more familiar with the system, PC stuff gets better because we get faster hardware :D
 

Sniper82

Lifer
Feb 6, 2000
16,517
0
76
Right now I think a 7600GT(1gb, 3200+ or better) can do what the PS3 does gfx wise. In a couple years when PS3 really starts getting put to use it would take something more then whats out now(well a 8800 might pull it off). Just a guess though.
 

destrekor

Lifer
Nov 18, 2005
28,799
359
126
people people people.. stop hating on Sony because of the supercomputer comment.. I remember when they first made that remark and they directly compared it to some of the supercomputers from back in the late 90s iirc, so it's like a supercomputer in its power, just not specifically the supercomputers of today. ;)
 

Fenixgoon

Lifer
Jun 30, 2003
33,050
12,433
136
Originally posted by: destrekor
people people people.. stop hating on Sony because of the supercomputer comment.. I remember when they first made that remark and they directly compared it to some of the supercomputers from back in the late 90s iirc, so it's like a supercomputer in its power, just not specifically the supercomputers of today. ;)

in that case my sempron is probably a supercomputer too:disgust:
 

TheRyuu

Diamond Member
Dec 3, 2005
5,479
14
81
First the GPU in the PS3 (i've heard) isn't as powerful as the GPU in the 360 and the GPU in the 360 isn't as powerful as a 8800.

As for CPU power, modern computer CPU's are way more powerful. The cell processor is crap. Slower then the 3 core (6 threaded) Xbox 360 power pc CPU.