how close to the sun would the earth need to be to

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

junkiefp

Senior member
Aug 2, 2006
387
0
0
What would happen if we create super turbo engines and push our planet away from the sun so we would combat global warming!!!!
 

DaShen

Lifer
Dec 1, 2000
10,710
1
0
Originally posted by: BigJ
Originally posted by: DaShen
Too many factors, I am sure.

Solar flares would have to be taken into account. The average temperature of the sun and then how it dissapates has to be taken into account but I am guessing since space is ideal for experiementation (close to absolute zero), you can just figure how heat dissapates. Boiling is 100 F or close to 22 C right, so then you would just calculate the dissapation factor and then match it as close to that number as possible (295 K). It may have to be slightly closer due to atmosphere, but I am betting that the atmosphere would be swallowed up and actually be fuel to raising the temperature so who knows.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sun

Stick your finger in your mouth. 2 degrees hotter is about 100F.

I think you mean 100C ;)

Hahaha oops. I always seem to mix up stuff like that.
100C then 212F, 373L
 

clamum

Lifer
Feb 13, 2003
26,256
406
126
The reason Venus is so hot is because of its extremely dense atmosphere, and in fact its hotter than Mercury even though it's farther away from the Sun. If we were in Venus' spot with our planet it would not be that hot... just saying it might have to be closer.
 

marulee

Golden Member
Oct 27, 2006
1,299
1
0
I guess the question you should ask is how much temperture needs to be rise from sun to boil the surface on the earth. Distance will never change noticeably within the period of our generation.
 

waggy

No Lifer
Dec 14, 2000
68,143
10
81
does it really matter what would happen? to be honest i woldnt care. since all life (plant, animal etc) would be dead.
 

geecee

Platinum Member
Jan 14, 2003
2,383
43
91
Originally posted by: clamum
The reason Venus is so hot is because of its extremely dense atmosphere, and in fact its hotter than Mercury even though it's farther away from the Sun. If we were in Venus' spot with our planet it would not be that hot... just saying it might have to be closer.
Also, Venus' atmosphere is primarily CO2. Scientists are linking global warming here on Earth to rising CO2 levels. If you consider that the CO2 content of our atmosphere is a fraction of 1%, then you'd have to conclude that Venus' atmosphere makes for one hell of a greenhouse! While distance to the Sun is a factor, that crazy CO2 concentration probably has quite a bit to do with the unusually high surface temps on Venus as well.

EDIT: If you look at Mars, you'll see that despite how much further away it is from the Sun, the temperature at some places and times is actually capable of supporting life, so in Venus' case, it's probably not just its distance to the Sun.
 

DaShen

Lifer
Dec 1, 2000
10,710
1
0
Originally posted by: geecee
Originally posted by: clamum
The reason Venus is so hot is because of its extremely dense atmosphere, and in fact its hotter than Mercury even though it's farther away from the Sun. If we were in Venus' spot with our planet it would not be that hot... just saying it might have to be closer.
Venus' atmosphere is primarily CO2. Scientists are linking global warming here on Earth to rising CO2 levels. If you consider that the CO2 content of our atmosphere is a fraction of 1%, then you'd have to conclude that Venus' atmosphere makes for one hell of a greenhouse! While distance to the Sun is a factor, that crazy CO2 concentration probably has quite a bit to do with the unusually high surface temps on Venus as well.

We should try to convert the CO2 to O2 and Carbon and see if we can get a balance on Venus. ;) :p hahahaa... too many Sci-fi books.
 

Jeff7

Lifer
Jan 4, 2001
41,596
20
81
Originally posted by: geecee
Originally posted by: clamum
The reason Venus is so hot is because of its extremely dense atmosphere, and in fact its hotter than Mercury even though it's farther away from the Sun. If we were in Venus' spot with our planet it would not be that hot... just saying it might have to be closer.
Venus' atmosphere is primarily CO2. Scientists are linking global warming here on Earth to rising CO2 levels. If you consider that the CO2 content of our atmosphere is a fraction of 1%, then you'd have to conclude that Venus' atmosphere makes for one hell of a greenhouse! While distance to the Sun is a factor, that crazy CO2 concentration probably has quite a bit to do with the unusually high surface temps on Venus as well.

Just the simple fact that Venus is about 50 million miles further from the sun than Mercury, and its surface is still a few hundred degrees hotter than that of Mercury, should tell you something about 1) the ability of an atmosphere to retain heat, and 2) the ability of dense CO2 to hold in heat.


But the question here was simply, how close would Earth need to be to raise the temperature of the oceans to the point where they'd boil away?

Now, how complex do we make this? Once they just start boiling, the humudity will increase considerably, which may serve to trap even more heat. At the same time, the atmosphere might become saturated, so the boiling point could rise. All kinds of fun stuff could happen.

Let's just assume, "Surface temp of 100C - how close would Earth need to be to reach this point."

And you know, I think that if I knew the average output of the sun, I could figure it out. Radiative energy's strength is 1/radius^2, where radius = distance from the emitter. But I'd also have to calculate the watts required to boil a cubic meter of salt water, and I have to do enough math problems for my classes, and I just don't feel like doing this. :)

Originally posted by: DaShen
We should try to convert the CO2 to O2 and Carbon and see if we can get a balance on Venus. ;) :p hahahaa... too many Sci-fi books.
There's plenty of solar energy available, at least above the clouds. Venus Express has reflectors around its solar cells to reduce the amount of light absorbed so as to help keep the probe cool.

Relevant note:
VEX's solar panels "deliver power of 821 watts in the Earth?s orbit and 1,468 watts in the Venusian orbit at end of mission."
Source

 

2Xtreme21

Diamond Member
Jun 13, 2004
7,044
0
0
There is speculation that Venus could have / did support life at one point before the runaway greenhouse effect took hold of the planet. Distance from the sun doesn't have as big of an impact on temperature as you might think.
 

2Xtreme21

Diamond Member
Jun 13, 2004
7,044
0
0
You can use Stefan-Boltzman's law to determine what you want to know, I think:

Ts * sqrt( Rs / 2D) = Te

Ts = Temperature of sun = 5960 K
Rs = Radius of sun = 6.96x10^8 m
Te = Avg. temperature of the Earth = You want it to be 100C = 373.15 K
D = Distance from Earth to Sun

Rearranging you get:

( Rs / ( 2 * ( Te / Ts )^2 ) ) = D


( 6.96x10^8 m / ( 2 * ( 373.15 / 5960 ) ^2 ) ) = D

D = 8.88 x 10^10m


Our current distance is 1.5x10^11m, FYI... and Venus' is 1.082x10^11m.
 

AgaBoogaBoo

Lifer
Feb 16, 2003
26,108
5
81
We also need to factor in that the Earth rotates and so it needs to be hot enough that it can get boiling without cooling off so fast that it negates any increase in heat.

I like this question, but don't know enough to give a real answer.
 

pontifex

Lifer
Dec 5, 2000
43,804
46
91
Originally posted by: waggy
does it really matter what would happen? to be honest i woldnt care. since all life (plant, animal etc) would be dead.

just humor me.
believe it or not, there really is a reason behind this post, unlike the stupid "will an airplane take off from a treadmill" threads.
 

E equals MC2

Banned
Apr 16, 2006
2,676
1
0
Dude, the ocean doesn't even need to boil.

If the earth's temperature as a whole even went up 5 degrees, we'd be some serious shiit beyond man's control. Global flooding due to ice caps melting, all ecosystems are completely thrown off the scale, hundreds of thousands of species would go to extinct from 5 degrees alone.
 

pontifex

Lifer
Dec 5, 2000
43,804
46
91
Originally posted by: E equals MC2
Dude, the ocean doesn't even need to boil.

If the earth's temperature as a whole even went up 5 degrees, we'd be some serious shiit beyond man's control. Global flooding due to ice caps melting, all ecosystems are completely thrown off the scale, hundreds of thousands of species would go to extinct from 5 degrees alone.

no, i very specifically need the oceans to boil and evaporate. i really don't care much about what else happens, but boiling and evaporating is essential.

actually, if you can think of another way to make water all over the world disappear completely, let me know. the boiling seas thing seems to be the most logical way i can think of it happening, even though its not very logical to begin with, but i'm willing to hear all options.
 

Atheus

Diamond Member
Jun 7, 2005
7,313
2
0
Originally posted by: FoBoT
what is your method of moving the orbit?

LOL, reminds me of that 'how to destroy the earth' thing.

"You will need: a big heavy rock, something with a bit of a swing to it... perhaps Mars."
 

pontifex

Lifer
Dec 5, 2000
43,804
46
91
Originally posted by: Atheus
Originally posted by: FoBoT
what is your method of moving the orbit?

LOL, reminds me of that 'how to destroy the earth' thing.

"You will need: a big heavy rock, something with a bit of a swing to it... perhaps Mars."

whats that from, sounds funny
 

Stiganator

Platinum Member
Oct 14, 2001
2,492
3
81
if we're talking 100 C then everything would die except for archaebacteria. They would be having a hay day, deep sea vents would probably be fine as well.
 

pontifex

Lifer
Dec 5, 2000
43,804
46
91
Originally posted by: Atheus
Originally posted by: pontifex
Originally posted by: Atheus
Originally posted by: FoBoT
what is your method of moving the orbit?

LOL, reminds me of that 'how to destroy the earth' thing.

"You will need: a big heavy rock, something with a bit of a swing to it... perhaps Mars."

whats that from, sounds funny

This will be right up your alley.

http://qntm.org/destroy

lol, thats funny.
well, the earth needs to survive this meeting with the sun. doesn't have to be pretty when its done, the planet just needs to be intact when its over with.
 

Stiganator

Platinum Member
Oct 14, 2001
2,492
3
81
When a big enough section of ice caps melted it would destroy all humans. I would guess the tsunami would be about 10km tall across all of earth. look at the ones that happen in bays in Alaska---> 500m tall.
 

91TTZ

Lifer
Jan 31, 2005
14,374
1
0
Mars is colder and further away than Earth, but its oceans boiled away.

Remember, both heat and pressure factor into the boiling point. You can boil cold water by lowering the pressure.
 

Atheus

Diamond Member
Jun 7, 2005
7,313
2
0
Originally posted by: Stiganator
I would guess the tsunami would be about 10km tall across all of earth.

I find that extremely hard to believe. That is higher than everest... it would pick aircraft out of the sky...